advertisement
RSS
More Feeds












God's Politics

Women Missionaries Who Can’t Preach at Home

by Mimi Haddad 01-12-2009

Do you have family or friends on the mission field who are women? How many of them preach, teach, and exercise their gifts of leadership beside men on the mission field? Yet, many of the churches that send these women to the mission field do not provide opportunities for them to preach, teach, or exercise leadership when they return home. Does this seem consistent to you?

In one of my previous posts we glimpsed the biblical foundations for women’s leadership offered by the founder and first president of Prairie Bible School, L.E. Maxwell. Maxwell gave women positions of leadership as members of the board of directors, as professors of theology and Bible doctrine, as principal of Prairie’s High School, and as preachers not only during their summer conferences, but also on Sunday morning in Prairie’s auditorium—the Tabernacle, the largest religious auditorium in Canada.

In a recent interview, Dr. Robert Rakestraw, a graduate of Prairie, a member of CBE and the Evangelical Theological Society, and a retired professor of theology at Bethel Seminary in St. Paul. said “Maxwell was one of the most zealous advocates of missions, and he was also an outspoken advocate of women preaching and teaching at all levels. If you were in favor of missions you had to be egalitarian. I remember Maxwell preaching on Psalm 68:11, the great company of women who published the glad tidings. Maxwell believed that the cause of Christ was shared by both men and women alike.” For this premiere evangelical institution, Scripture was the guide for faith and practice. A passion to make disciples of all nations (Matt. 28:20) was treasured at Prairie.

There is perhaps no other individual more compatible with the missionary zeal of L.E. Maxwell than Fredrik Franson, founder of the Evangelical Alliance Mission, now TEAM. Born in Sweden in 1852, Franson immigrated to the US and came to faith in Nebraska in 1872. Shortly after meeting D.L. Moody in 1877, Franson launched into the rigors of extensive missionary service on four continents training missionaries, writing, and establishing strategic missionary partnerships. Ultimately, Franson was credited for founding not only TEAM (Evangelical Alliance Mission), but also Danish Mission Confederation, Swiss Alliance Mission, Barmea Alliance Mission, Finnish Alliance Mission, Swedish Evangelical Mission in Japan, and Swedish Alliance Mission.

Franson, like Maxwell, was an ardent supporter of women missionaries. Determined to make known the biblical basis for women’s equal service in any endeavor, Franson wrote Prophesying Daughters in 1896. Relying upon a whole Bible approach, Prophesying Daughters is striking for its cohesive, original, and concise survey of Scripture. Fundamental to Prophesying Daughters is the goal of observing the biblical support to free women from gender prejudice in order to release them for evangelism. He “labeled as heretics those who grounded a doctrine on one or two passages in the Bible, without reading the references in their context” (Charles O. Knowles, [Let Her Be: Right Relationships and the Southern Baptist Conundrum Over Women’s Role,] Columbia, MO: KnoWell Publishing, 2002, p. 85). Prophesying Daughters opposes the selective reading of Scripture in favor of overarching biblical themes that include, rather than exclude women’s God-given gifts. Franson weighed in with the early church fathers and also Martin Luther in his brief defense of women’s equality in ministry. Franson perceived no ministry in which women may not lead. He was no gradual emancipationist. He was a full-orbed egalitarian, and his biblical scholarship had one focus—to reveal Scripture’s support for women’s service on the mission field.

If all of Scripture points to Christ, we cannot afford to overlook the women of Scripture who declared the good news of Jesus. But, their voices have been stopped by those who rely upon two passages (1 Tim. 2:11-15, 1 Cor. 14:24) “without reading them in context” (Prophesying Daughters, p.35). If a woman teaching was forbidden, Franson noted

… the instruction which Prisca gave to Apollos would also be against God’s command, and Paul’s order to women to be ‘good teachers’ (Titus 2:3) would be abrogated, and then women’s work in Sunday schools, in public schools, and in the teaching they convey through books and articles in religious papers would all be forbidden (Prophesying Daughters, p. 36).

“The danger of founding a doctrine on a single text, without comparing it with hundreds of other texts that speak of the same theme, cannot be emphasized enough,” said Franson (Prophesying Daughters, p. 36). “If a sister can more easily bring souls to the Savior … then she sins if she does not use those gifts that God has given her” (Prophesying Daughters, p. 39). And the results of this are disastrous in light of eternity. In response to the fact that so many “people are in the water about to drown,” (Prophesying Daughters, p.29) Franson wrote:

A few men are trying to save [the drowning], and that is considered well and good. But look, over there a few women have untied a boat also to be of help in the rescue, and immediately a few men cry out… ‘No, no, women must not help, rather let the people drown.’ What stupidity! And yet this picture is very fitting. Men have, during all these centuries, shown that they do not have the power alone to carry out the work for the salvation of the world: therefore, they ought to be thankful to get some help (Prophesying Daughters, p. 29).

Egalitarians, with a high view of Scripture, have and continue to root their service in Scripture. Scripture itself compels us to share the greatest love we know—the life of Jesus. Let us remember the profound leadership of Fredrik Franson, L.E. Maxwell, Ruth Dearing and many more. May we “consider the outcome of their way of life and imitate their faith” (Heb. 13:7b).

Mimi Haddad

Mimi Haddad is the president of Christians for Biblical Equality.

Categories: Diversity, Gender, Ministry
Share or bookmark this post:
  • email
  • Facebook
  • TwitThis
  • del.icio.us
  • Digg
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Mixx
  • NewsVine
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • YahooMyWeb
advertisement


Comment Code of Conduct

I will express myself with civility, courtesy, and respect for every member of the Sojourners online community, especially toward those with whom I disagree—even if I feel disrespected by them. (Romans 12:17-21)

I will express my disagreements with other community members' ideas without insulting, mocking, or slandering them personally. (Matthew 5:22)

I will not exaggerate others' beliefs nor make unfounded prejudicial assumptions based on labels, categories, or stereotypes. I will always extend the benefit of the doubt. (Ephesians 4:29)

I will hold others accountable by clicking "report" on comments that violate these principles, based not on what ideas are expressed but on how they're expressed. (2 Thessalonians 3:13-15)

I understand that comments reported as abusive are reviewed by Sojourners staff and are subject to removal. Repeat offenders will be blocked from making further comments. (Proverbs 18:7)

  • carolvan
    "....many of the churches that send these women to the mission field do not provide opportunities for them to preach, teach, or exercise leadership when they return home."

    One of my professors at George Fox Evangelical Seminary made a bold, startling statement regarding this practice. He believed the practice was certainly deeply sinful toward women, but it was also deeply racial. If women are "appropriately" responsible for teaching children, but not WASP men, then what does that really say about attitudes toward minority or non-western men if we can place women over them? It is a powerful and insidious reinforcement of inequity and hierarchy toward the non-western male, as well as toward women.
  • SisterMarie
    carolvan,

    As I slowly read through Mimi Haddad's post, the thought kept coming that before she finished writing, that she might speculate on why it is that it's ok for women to be missionairies but not minister here at home. Before I had scrolled down to your comment, I had reached the same conclusion as you.
  • Yup. Basically, women can't hold authority over men, unless the men are African.
  • Joe_Allen_Doty
    In the book of Acts, there were women mentioned who were pastors, teachers, evangelists and deacons. Some of the English Bible translations have the Greek masculine noun meaning "deacon" translated as "servant" when the context referred to a woman.

    But, a church deacon is an appointed position and therefore it has to be a masculine noun.

    I have known women who were missionaries, pastors, evangelists and even Bible teachers. My own mother was a Bible teacher to adults in an Assembly of God when I was growing up. The pastor of that church was a woman.

    I knew two women while they were pastors of an Assembly of God in Aiea, Hawaii in the Pearl Harbor Area and they also had AG missionary status. I attended their church on Sunday both of the times I was on R&R in Hawaii while I was stationed in South Vietnam.
  • Lhill
    God has given us experiences in life to know what is acceptable. I have had the great privilege to have had female and male pastors. I also have had my own life relationships as a Christian leader that have resonances with scripture, especially as they have been lived out as an aspect of Jesus's teachings about women as teachers and preachers. Of course we are a part of God's leadership. How could it be any other way? I look into my own self to see God and know that I am a part of the leadership of the Church. This is my soul's journey, given by God.
  • kevin47
    "Do you have family or friends on the mission field who are women? How many of them preach, teach, and exercise their gifts of leadership beside men on the mission field?"

    Is this a common phenomenon? I haven't heard of a church that holds to the complimentarian view sending women to preach. If we send missionaries to preach, it is because they are either forming or joining a local church. Of course, missionaries of either gender are encouraged to use their leadership gifts, but that is a different matter.
  • To answer kevin47 who asked, "Is this a common phenomenon?"

    Personally, I've seen it happen all the time. I was raised as a missionary kid in Africa & Southeast Asia where women preaching and teaching was not a big deal at all.

    The denomination I currently belong to (Christian and Missionary Alliance) ordains women who become missionaries overseas or even if they, get this, pastor at a non-English speaking church here in the U.S. (such as a Chinese Alliance church).

    Interestingly enough, the CMA will not ordain women as pastors if the church is a regular old WASP congregation that speaks English like the one I attend. It sounds crazy, but my wife and I have personally encountered this obstacle because she's interested in preaching/ordination but the gender restrictions are applied very inconsistently (i.e. certain kinds of leadership and teaching are ok in mixed groups, but not others).

    Mimi Haddad is right on the money. The idea of "gender-based ministry roles" that prohibit all women (regardless of gifting or ability) from positions of "spiritual authority" is too often used as a standard selectively applied to ordination and preaching, but not to other influential positions such as worship leader, youth minister (which is often called "director" so that the position sounds more administrative/occupational), overseas missionary (as long as you're single), book author, biblical/theological academic scholar, conference speaker or devotional/bible study leader who is allowed to "share from her heart" (implying that too much use of her mind might cross the line into territory reserved for men only).

    This too shall pass.
  • kevin47
    I am unfamiliar with the CMA. Their standpoint is hypocritical, but should not be construed as a defense for women in the pastorate.

    As far as the ministry roles you mention, I think churches should make very clear which roles women should take on, and why this is so. Decisions coming from bias or cultural mores are not authoritative.

    For our church, the difference between leadership of a bible study and leadership of a church boils down to the role of teaching during a church service. It doesn't have anything to do with a mind/heart issue.
  • SisterMarie
    Sounds like a bunch of Bravo Sierra to me.
  • kevin47
    It probably does, but who cares?
  • canucklehead
    see Janette Hassey "No Time for Silence" (pp. 15-19) for a summation of C&MA founder, A.B. Simpson's very "pro" women stance. L.E. Maxwell was a graduate of the C&MA influenced school at Midland, Kansas, early 1920s, where he took up Simpson's views on the matter, as instructed by Dorothy Ruth Miller, who taught at Nyack, the pioneer C&MA school in New York
  • Where in Scripture does it say that women can teach in Bible studies but not in a church service?
blog comments powered by Disqus
click here for comments tech support
advertisement
  • MOST VIEWED
  • MOST COMMENTED
  • MOST RECENT
advertisement
advertisement
advertisement
advertisement
advertisement


HOME | SUBSCRIBE | DONATE | TAKE ACTION | MAGAZINE  
SOJOMAIL | BLOGS | MEDIA | EVENTS | RESOURCES | ABOUT US  
Sojourners | 3333 14th Street NW, Suite 200 | Washington, DC 20010  
Phone 202.328.8842 | Fax 202.328.8757 | sojourners@sojo.net  
Unless otherwise noted, all material © Sojourners 2008