RSS
More Feeds












God's Politics

Who Lit The Fire Under the Right-Wing ‘Populists’ Against Health-Care Reform?

by Rose Marie Berger 08-10-2009

obamacareBy now, we’ve all seen the angry “regular Americans” who are rising up to resist health-care reform. They are demonstrating loudly at town hall meetings. They are holding rallies. They are e-mailing all their friends and family about the absolute horrors that will accompany any government-run program of Obama-Care.

Who are these people? Where did they come from? Is this really how Americans feel about health-care reform?

I started digging a little into the organizing strategy behind this “grassroots” movement and found … wait for it … Ralph Reed!

You remember Ralph from the Christian Coalition, right? He was the political strategist for the Far-Right Republican wing and handed the political Far Right a “faith-based” cover for their political agenda. More recently, he ran for Lieutenant Governor of Georgia in 2006 but lost due his involvement in the Abramoff Indian gaming and Congressional bribery scandal. In 1997, Ralph started Century Strategies, a political consulting firm for Republican candidates and causes. His clients have included Enron, online gambling companies, Indian gambling firms, and the cable industry to fight decency standards proposed in Congress.

So, when Far-Right political operatives and insurance industry giants wanted to defeat major health-care reform, who did they call? Their old buddy Ralph Reed.

Ralph’s friend, and former Century Strategies’ business exec, Tim Phillips, was tasked to head up Americans for Prosperity, a right-wing PR firm funded primarily by Koch Industries (global energy firm that runs coal plants, agribusiness, major oil refineries, etc. Papa Koch was a card-carrying member of the John Birch Society, according to BusinessWeek). AFP is part of a handful of corporate industry front-groups that are leading the propaganda campaign against health-care reform. AFP’s health-care targeted subsidiary is called Patients First. PF is launching bus tours against health-care reform right now. It’s AFP who brought you “Joe the Plumber,” the “Drill, Baby, Drill” rallies, the “tea-bagging parties” (ahem), and most recently the “Survivor” TV ad with the Canadian woman who had to sneak into the U.S. to get her cancer treated, because “in Canada, treatment is delayed or denied.” Wrong.

Here are a few of the groups: Club for Growth is a right-wing lobbying organization that represents the Wall Street elite. RecessRally.com is the network getting people out to the town hall meetings. It’s a subsidiary of the American Liberty Alliance, whose executive director is Eric Odom, a Far-Right media strategist and president of Strategic Activism, his online political strategizing company. RecessRally is networked with American Majority, a right-wing non-profit that is staffed primarily with conservative Christians who came out of the Bush administration and the Generation Joshua project (a Christian youth league training students in conservative activism).

So, that’s a rough roundup of who’s leading the so-called “populist uprising.” As Rachel Maddow said in her excellent expose, “Corporate interests do this ‘fake grassroots’ movement as an industry. This is a professional PR campaign to line their own pockets. It is professional, corporate-funded Republican PR  and should be named and reported as such.”

I recommend reading Lee Fang’s article “Tim Phillips, The Man Behind The ‘Americans For Prosperity’ Corporate Front Group Factory.” And, in the interest of full disclosure, Fang works for the Center for American Progress, a think-tank full of operatives for the Dems. But Lee is a really good researcher. Here’s a bit of his article:

The rate at which the Koch Industries funded Americans for Prosperity (AFP) churns out front groups to promote its right-wing corporate agenda sets the organization out among similar conservative “think tanks.” This week, AFP created their latest front group called “Patients United Now,” an entity set up to defeat health care reform. Patients United follows a familiar pattern AFP has used for their other front groups: create a new stand alone website, fill it with lines like “We are people just like you” to give the site a grassroots feel, and then use the new group to recruit supporters and run deceptive advertisements attacking reform.

Access to adequate health care is a human right. Human rights generally are antagonistic to corporate interests. As people of faith we are called to stand up for human dignity and human rights. Now would be a good time to go ahead and shine the Light on these corporate con artists, especially the one’s masquerading as Christians.

Rose Marie Berger, an associate editor at Sojourners, blogs at www.rosemarieberger.com.

To learn more about health-care reform, click here to visit Sojourners’ Health-Care Resources Web page.

Share or bookmark this post:
  • email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • del.icio.us
  • Digg
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Mixx
  • NewsVine
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • Yahoo! Bookmarks
advertisement


Comment Code of Conduct

I will express myself with civility, courtesy, and respect for every member of the Sojourners online community, especially toward those with whom I disagree—even if I feel disrespected by them. (Romans 12:17-21)

I will express my disagreements with other community members' ideas without insulting, mocking, or slandering them personally. (Matthew 5:22)

I will not exaggerate others' beliefs nor make unfounded prejudicial assumptions based on labels, categories, or stereotypes. I will always extend the benefit of the doubt. (Ephesians 4:29)

I will hold others accountable by clicking "report" on comments that violate these principles, based not on what ideas are expressed but on how they're expressed. (2 Thessalonians 3:13-15)

I understand that comments reported as abusive are reviewed by Sojourners staff and are subject to removal. Repeat offenders will be blocked from making further comments. (Proverbs 18:7)

  • Ivory_Tower
  • ShazamMan
    Daylight is right on all counts. Back in '06, Nancy Pelosi expressed support for disruptors, because they were protesting the war. But now, it's a different story. She engages in name-calling toward the present disruptors. But that's just the sort of hypocrisy I would expect from a liberal Democrat. That being said, I don't endorse disruptions, but people have the feeling that their voices won't be heard otherwise.
  • jewish_carpenter
    Protesters in the 60s weren't being flogged on by a shill for corporate interests. Did you read the article? Do you understand the significance of someone being paid by corporations to mislead and upset those who are easily confused?
    For 30 years, humanitarians in govt have been trying to pass meaningful legislation that would ensure accessibility to a basic level of medical care to all Americans, and have been slandered or shouted down by those in govt who work for the healthcare corporations.
    We dropped our health insurance (for 3 healthy people) after I lost my job and our HMO premiums went up to within $50 of our mortgage. We are one accident away from losing our house.
    If a person has half a brain, it's pretty obvious that all the lies about healthcare reform are emanating from the HMOs, who will lie, cheat and steal to maintain their 20% profit margin.
    The CEO of Cigna made an average of $5,883 an hour last year. The only ones who don't care about this probably own stock in CIGNA, or have lifetime, guaranteed affordable health care.
  • jewish_carpenter
    Did you read this article? Do you realize the significance of corporations paying someone to deliberately mislead those who are easily confused and get them all upset about nothing?
    They are the Pharisees; they are betraying the teachings of Jesus by manipulating the masses so that the healthcare corporations can keep getting their 20% profit margin.
    For 30 or more years, the humanitarians (the ones with TRUE family values) in government have been slandered and shouted down by those in government who work for HMOs.
    We dropped our health insurance (for 3 healthy people) after I lost my job and our HMO premiums went up to within $50 of our mortgage payment. We are one accident or serious illness away from losing our house. We are only one family of 47 million in this situation.
    Those with lifetime, guaranteed, affordable health care who have worked for the govt, etc. seem to think there's no problem with the existing state of health care in America.
  • mscynthia
    Last I heard Ralph Reed is still laughing his socks off at his own clients. He still has no respect for them.
  • mscynthia
    I knew it!!
    It smelled like a Reed Duck, it looks like a Reed Duck and I bet it even taste like a Reed Duck.
    But I'm not eating that bird. Its an invasive spieces. Somebody tag that bird so we can track it on our GPS. More weeds left over from the Bush Garden.
    I hope they get booked for fraud, like last time.

    Thanks for your great gum shoe DNA work Rose. I'm sending this blog to everyone I can think of.
  • mscynthia
    And since when did the left get funding from corporate America to the tune of billions and billions.
  • WaveTossed
    Unfortunately, Boortz's very un-libertarian (in my opinion) views about foreign intervention are very basic points of disagreement. To me, "libertarian" means that the U.S. is not the Morality Thought Police of the world. We certainly don't need the U.S. government spending kazillions in interfering in foreign countries any more than having it interfere (except very minimally) in our own country.

    Which is why Ron Paul is My Man. I don't agree with everything he says, mainly about immigration. His views on immigration and those of the Cato Institute's are very different. And I agree with the Cato Institute when it comes to immigration.
  • letjusticerolldown
    It's not an easy call but in our case it was quite objective. In our case the 'state of the art' ended up my wife being cared for at home with the back up of a system actively supporting her. And it would not have happened in Montgomery. She would have died within a few hours or at least within a few weeks.

    My father died at Mayo in the hands of the best in the world--blinded by their own expertise. The only one who was on the right track was his smalltown doc. So I know your point.
  • Ivory_Tower
    Irrelevant to the conversation - again, we should condemn the injustice and act personally to fight against it. Donate your time and money to non-profits and charities, for example.

    The matter is the role of government. Using the force of government results in in its own injustices. The result of retributive / distributive justice, which is the matter here, is to take from some and give to others. Rather than people making the choice (the heart being in the right place) you impose the will of the people on all, which does nothing to put people's hearts in the right place, and may actually be counter productive, as they become bitter towards government and the recipients of the benefits.

    The government should stick to procedural justice and the subsequent penalties. Like a referee in a basketball game calling fouls against agreed to rules. What they are getting to is saying, "oh, we don't like the score. It's not fair that one team had a seven footer and Michael Jordan, so we'll use our authority beyond what is prescribed in the rule-book (the constitution, and teh Bible for that matter) to even the score and call it a tie." It is simply not the job of man to force equal results.
  • nad2
    that is fair. interesting, isn't it, that people in the capital city of a state tell you to go elsewhere to get good care. i've had the same experience recently w/ family in a different capital. of course, i hear people in the profession say all the time just the opposite, which we are doing by staying put. it is a very tough call to make - leave your home to get state of the art care, or be at home & get perfectly good care (that is where we are - sort of - we are close to home getting perfectly good care as opposed to being 5 states away getting state of the art). peace,
  • Ivory_Tower
    Yes several bills out there. I am referring to the 1,000 page bill, the primary bill being debated: http://docs.house.gov/edlabor/AAHCA-BillText-07...

    The other bills need to be paid attention to, as it is the incrementalism of government - put a primary bill out there and pass five other minor bills without debate.

    I love the Cato alternative: here for those interested: http://healthcare.cato.org/

    It should also be understood how free markets raise the overall standard of living: http://www.fte.org/capitalism/index.html
  • letjusticerolldown
    Well, I wouldn't want to get in an argument about the causes of substandard care. But just as an example, when my wife became critically ill in Montgomery, a specialist at Baptist who had never seen us before warned her to essentially 'get out of town' (actually he was more blunt than that). He moved her into intensive care to at least get a level of nursing she needed--and from his perspective the systemic issue was not disconnected from rates. 90% of nursing homes (this is an actual number) lack sufficient nursing care. Over half of the revenue stream for nursing homes is from Medicaid (another 12% from Medicare). Medicaid pays for 2/3 of the residents. There is a direct line (not the only line) from Medicaid rates to staffing levels to quality of care in nursing homes. How much of a factor that is in determining the standard of care in relation to other factors--I cannot say.

    Blessings
  • Ivory_Tower
    I'm in Austin - Ron Paul is almost my rep :) Yes, he's a breath of fresh air.. But as far as Boortz goes, he's the best we libertarians can get, so I'll take what I can.
  • carlcopas
    Ivorytower,
    Old Testament prophets such as Micah and Amos strongly condemned the unjust exploitation of the poor by the wealthy and powerful. In which category of justice would you place these critiques?
  • nad2
    from one alabamian to another (& one who deals w/ hospitals, doctors, & nursing homes regularly & from all sides here in my profession), reimbursement rates are not the main culprit if substandard care is involved. hope you are well. peace brother,
  • WaveTossed
    "I'm a Boortz guy, so your generalizations don't irk me."

    My main problem with Boortz is his desire to spend millions on foreign wars (such as the black hole in Iraq). Myself, I'm a Ron Paul gal.
  • letjusticerolldown
    I do not believe they have that ethical freedom; and at least to a degree do not have that legal freedom. The same is true with nursing homes with very few currently able to make money on medicaid/medicare rates without delivering substandard care. This is particularly true in my state of Alabama (our beloved state, I should say).
  • WaveTossed
    "There is something to be said for just simply defeating this bill and starting over with a more reasoned debate."

    Actually, there are at least five different bills being considered. The idea of "just defeat the [one] bill" is simply a myth.

    Many people, even libertarians such as myself, believe that something must be done. The current system is untenable and is certainly NOT a true free-market system. If we just shout down the various bills, without proposing alternatives, nothing will be done. Unfortunately, there are agendas that wish for nothing to be done.

    i believe that libertarians and other free-market people need to push an alternative. I like the Cato Institute's plan.
  • nad2
    i bid you good day, this is ridiculous. yes, according to you i think the government should do it all (which by implication would make me a socialist, right?). according to you, wikipedia is a reliable knowledge base. according to you, i want you to render to ceasar, who is just like our american representative government, the dictatorial theft machine that it is. hell, according to you, God allocated you your $ (which is bizarre coming from a libertarian - i marvel at your ability to hold those two ideas in your head at the same time, btw). seriously, i just don't think we are communicating, which is no slight to you, just a fact, so i'll give you the last word & be done.
blog comments powered by Disqus
click here for comments tech support
advertise here
  • MOST VIEWED
  • MOST COMMENTED
  • MOST RECENT
advertise here
advertise here
advertise here
advertise here


HOME | SUBSCRIBE | DONATE | TAKE ACTION | MAGAZINE  
SOJOMAIL | BLOGS | MEDIA | EVENTS | RESOURCES | ABOUT US  
Sojourners | 3333 14th Street NW, Suite 200 | Washington, DC 20010  
Phone 202.328.8842 | Fax 202.328.8757 | sojourners@sojo.net  
Unless otherwise noted, all material © Sojourners 2008