RSS
More Feeds












God's Politics

The Plank in Australia’s Eye

by Jarrod McKenna 11-09-2009

“F%*# OFF! WE’RE FULL!” read the bumper sticker I saw this morning, written within the outline of the Australian continent. The offense of the bumper stickers I felt twice as hard after hearing that another boat of people fleeing horrific circumstance had sunk off the Australian coast. This is the side of Australia you won’t see advertised in our tourism campaigns. Beaches, barbecues, bronzed bodies, and beautiful sunsets are what we love to show the world. Yet the prophets’ poetry draws our attention to what we want to ignore. What we hide. What we silence and long to keep a secret.

091106-we-are-all-boatpeopleWho wants to mess with the world’s image of the sun-kissed, fun-loving, larrikin nation “Down Under”? I believe God does. Biblically our redemption is not found in hiding our shame but in letting the Spirit transform it. As Philip Berrigan would say, “The poor tell us who we are. The prophets tell us who we can be. So we hide the poor and kill the prophets.” One of Australia’s greatest shames is the way we imprison, ignore, silence, and hide [now offshore] refugees who tell us who we are, and who we can be.

Australia must face what Dr. Cornell West would call “the night side” of our national identity. Tied up in this ‘night-side of Aussie pride’ is the irrational xenophobia that makes it not just possible, but popular(!) for both sides of politics to use the plight of some of God’s most vulnerable children seeking safety — refugees — as a political football. Tragically, how asylum seekers have been treated by Australia reads as a case study of anthropologist Rene Girard’s theory of “scapegoating” as the glue of society. Power politics in this country are being held together by the hatred of this most defenseless ‘other’.

A couple of years back while working with Aboriginal activist Uncle Kevin Buzzcott, he said to me, “When are you white fellas going to realize that you are all ‘boatpeople’!?! If you are not going to let them [refugees] in, us black fellas should send you all home!”

Maybe deep in the white Australian psyche is the fear that just as the European colonisers stole the land from the indigenous peoples, so we might have the land stolen from us. Maybe what Uncle Kevin Buzzcott is pointing us to is the reality that what we fear is not “the other” but a projection of own worst selves. This would explain the both blatant and veiled history of legislated racism such as the “White Australia policy” and more recently, the supposedly overhauled “Pacific Solution.” We Australians can be very quick to point out the racist histories of South Africa and the United States without removing the plank in our own eye.

[to be continued...]

portrait-jarrod-mckennaJarrod McKenna is seeking to live God’s love as a dad, husband, brother, activist trainer and [eco]evangelist. He is a co-founder of the Peace Tree Community serving with the marginalised in one of the poorest of areas in his city, in Western Australia heads up an award winning multi-faith youth service initiative called  Together for Humanity, and is the founder and creative director of Empowering Peacemakers (E.P.Y.C.), for which he has received an Australian peace award in his work for in empowering a generation of (eco)evangelists and peace prophets.

Share or bookmark this post:
  • email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • del.icio.us
  • Digg
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Mixx
  • NewsVine
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • Yahoo! Bookmarks
advertisement


Comment Code of Conduct

I will express myself with civility, courtesy, and respect for every member of the Sojourners online community, especially toward those with whom I disagree—even if I feel disrespected by them. (Romans 12:17-21)

I will express my disagreements with other community members' ideas without insulting, mocking, or slandering them personally. (Matthew 5:22)

I will not exaggerate others' beliefs nor make unfounded prejudicial assumptions based on labels, categories, or stereotypes. I will always extend the benefit of the doubt. (Ephesians 4:29)

I will hold others accountable by clicking "report" on comments that violate these principles, based not on what ideas are expressed but on how they're expressed. (2 Thessalonians 3:13-15)

I understand that comments reported as abusive are reviewed by Sojourners staff and are subject to removal. Repeat offenders will be blocked from making further comments. (Proverbs 18:7)

  • makemoneyathomeinaustralia
    Piracy is a war-like act committed by private parties (not affiliated with any government) that engage in acts of robbery and/or criminal violence at sea. The term can include acts committed in other major bodies of water or on a shore. It does not normally include crimes committed against persons travelling on the same vessel as the perpetrator (e.g. one passenger stealing from others on the same vessel). The term has been used to refer to raids across land borders by non-state agents. Piracy should be distinguished from privateering
  • kiramatalishah
    According to the study, the most important tool for small businesses to succeed in 2010 is search engine marketing, while email marketing, public relations and social media cited as crucial for success. 23.8% of all small businesses reported that search engine marketing was the tool most needed for their business to succeed in 2010.
    www.onlineuniversalwork.com
  • Dicky28
    I'm sure we've all been watching the people in Haiti fighting over the aid that is being handed out. I'm sure no one thinks this is a good situation. It is much safer for those being aided and is also much fairer if the aid is handed out in an orderly fashion on the basis of who is in most need. The way it is happening now, those who need it the least are getting the most aid. It is survival of the fittest (strongest). Those most in need have no chance of fighting their way through everybody else to get the aid. It is the same with boat people (refugees) coming to Australia. Those 'refugees' that arrive in Australia by boat are those who have managed to finance their travels half way around the world, through numerous countries, and then can afford to pay a lot of money to the Indonesian people smugglers to bring them across to Australia. Those most in need of refuge are stuck in some UN camp much closer to where they have come from. They don't have the means that the boat people have. The last few Australian Governments have all greatly increased our refugee intake. Those who are welcomed are those judged to need our help the most. Encouraging people to come illegally by boat risks their lives and encourages corrupt practices, just the same as chucking the aid out of a helicopter does. In that situation, the strongest get the aid and then have power over everybody else to distrbute as they see fit. Does anyone truly believe that is the best system? Do you Jarrod? I'd like to hear your thoughts.
  • ridwanzero
    Many companies all over the world need your opinions on their products. They will send you a simple online survey forms, where you need to fill it out and they pay you money.

    The most remarkable thing about this paid survey program is that anyone can make money with it.
    It doesn't require any special skills, training, education or previous business experience. You only need access to the Internet and basic typing skills.
    It is the perfect home business for stay at home moms, students, home makers, retirees or anyone that is in need of some extra cash.


    www.onlineuniversalwork.com
  • davidbaer
    What I like about small business owners is that they are not afraid to take huge risks and lay it all on the line. But, I agree they do need a lot of help with their marketing. I think having them go the social media and email route is not only the least expensive but its also the most effective. Thanks for the stats!
    With Facebook and Twitter being among the leaders of the Social networks, marketing as a small business is being transformed..
    Respondents according to the Vertical Response survey appear to need some differentiation with the use of SE marketing and Social media Marketing

    www.onlineuniversalwork.com
  • abassseo
    Can you allow me to advertise my online business in your blog? it will be a great help if say yes. thanks a lot!
    You helping a lot of PPL thanks for your golden ideas about home based jobs.

    I would like to share the secret of profit online
    Learn How I Earn $50 to $250 Every Day!

    www.onlineuniversalwork.com
  • davidbaer
    Cash Making Opportunities - The Beginning The working life is already tough enough, but the worries of being out of work was even tougher. The unsecured working environment have prompted me to search the internet for an alternative source of extra income so that I could learn how to Make Money Work for me and be Financially Independent. I listed down a number of Free Internet Business Opportunity Ideas while researching ways how people earn money online while working-from-home.......

    www.onlineuniversalwork.com
  • Bungarra
    Thanks for the feed back
    Do not agree at all. What is the real difference between a person
    attempting to get to Australia by boat or other means or using Qantas etc
    with a short term visa with no intention of returning? They then become
    undocumented workers who can be exploited by unscrupulous employers. Seen
    it in action here. Over stayers tend to disappear into the community.
    It just that they are more conspicuous when coming by boat. You are making
    an assumption that the papers required for a visa are more or less legit.
    Not necessarily so they can and are bought/forged.
    At least the boat people get properly looked at once caught. Look at the
    record of war criminals ex various conflicts in Australia.
    Look at the question re the student visas etc. Those who are well connected
    can get in, even the children of dictators and others who should be on the
    prohibited list for crimes against humanity.
    However this is only a diversion form the real issue.
    I am totally disgusted by the way this issue has been used in politics here.
    There has been huge amounts spent, rather than just pick them up, process
    fairly rapidly and properly - no Cornelia Rowe's please. Spending long
    periods in detention is not on. Nor is transporting peoples away from
    Australia just to keep the façade up that we have not allowed them here. All
    of this is to ensure that some can be seen as defending Australia, and to
    get and or maintain political power when the major issues are in other
    places ie are we getting value from the various large multinationals here,
    are they interfering too much in our affairs to our detriment (yes in my
    industry) or the impact of trade subsidies on our products, and are the
    terms of the free trade agreements we are entering to just?
    I spent some time in Shanghai as a small child, and saw the white Russian
    refuges there. Their stories left a deep impression on me. Do we recognise
    the common humanity of all or not?
    As I understand it, the boat people are not illegal when they arrive and
    seek refuge status, the visa over stayers are.
    John Holmes
    46 Gallagher St, Eden Hill, 6054
    Ph (08) 9377 0607
    Mob 0400 185 458
    Email homesjc@iprimus.com.au
  • lgarth80
    Very small comment - with the overstay visas, there is an expectation after the "tourists" come with assumed proper documents, that deportation can occur in the event of trouble. With people arriving on boats, they can have badly damaged or no legal documents of identification, making it difficult for deportation.

    Hence the issue with a person overstaying on a visa = they get deported when found, and if they don't there is no Medicare, etc.

    If someone comes and gains asylum through no documents (benefit of the doubt), then there is full Medicare and lifetime option of Australian citizenship, which costs the taxpayer far more over the long term, particularly when families are involved.

    I'm sorry if this view seems racist, jaundiced or anything but fair on those escaping tyrannic regimes and in genuine need of asylum. Just thought that I should put order into the differences between Qantas and illegal boats on the NW corner of Australia.
  • mervynthomas
    I feel sick whenever I see this bumper sticker. But what bothers me more is when I hear kindly Christian people in my own parish saying the same sort of things - less crudely, without the obscenity, but coming directly from the same attitudes.

    Although explicitly racist statements are no longer acceptable in mainstream Australia, scare mongering about being `swamped' by refugees seems to be an acceptable political tactic.
  • Faydine
    Oh -- don't get me wrong, I fully understand that much of what the
    government did was wrong, and the Trail of Tears is a great example of that.
    My dad grew up in Stillwell, OK and grew up with an old Cherokee man who had
    been on it. If I recall correctly, his name was Clem Beaver, but dad often
    told stories of the Beaver kids he went to school with, so I may have the
    first name wrong.

    I was referring to the many attempts by white individuals to actually do
    something good or worthwhile in a cross-cultural setting and really screw it
    up.
  • Joe_Allen_Doty
    I have documented proof that I have Native American heritage and my tribe is Cherokee. The proof is on the Certificate of Degree of Indian Blood card issued by the Department of the Interior's Bureau of Indian Affairs.

    My main Cherokee Ancestors left the original lands and went to Arkansas before the removal by force called the "Trail of Tears. Then after the Cherokee Nation was established in Indian Territory, they moved into the Cooweescoowee District of the new "Nation."
  • Joe_Allen_Doty
    I meant "they did NOT have to be worried about being caught as 'undocumented aliens'."
  • Bungarra
    This is not an easy problem.
    The politics of 'boat people' in Australia is a function complex mix of political agendas and hidden agendas. The previous government, Howard et al, won their last election on the fate of a group of boat people picked up at sea after their boat foundered by a passing tanker.

    The demonising of these people as being 'queue jumpers', potential terrorists, ignoring the right of Australia to determine who enters Australia, together with remanets of older policies often hidden by 'PC' talk activated a significant resentment in the population and ensured election. Yet the changes of peoples in camps in SE Asia getting resettlement any time soon is rather low.

    If there is no queue – there are not queue jumpers. People have accumulated in camps where there is little chance of getting out. Yet this did not stop demonising them.
    Never let the facts get in the way of a political push.
    Policies at the time included imprisonment of children in camps with their parents in very remote and some what oppressive camps. Many people were and are damaged by such policies.

    That the opposition is using the current increase in boat people - the end of the Tamil Tigers is a major source, as a major political weapon against MR Rudd and his government. Polls indicate that they are having some success. It is a "we are tougher than you' arms race. Yet the spending to achieve these policies in the past was out of proportion to just processing rapidly and then moving people on to a satisfactory place.

    The PM has demonised people smugglers. Yet the numbers involved are insignificant too the 50,000 or so/year who enter Australia on short term visas and then do not go home until caught by immigration. Is Qantas a people smuggler?

    Another very real issue with uncontrolled boat arrivals to Australia is that of quantities. Any visitor to Australia will be asked detailed questions and checked re the carriage of prohibited food stuffs. This is because there are many significant pests, weeds and diseases of agriculture and humans not present in Australia, so prevention is still very worth while. The cost of controlling a Foot and mouth out break would be huge and cause the loss of many markets.

    The problem I have is that the older attitudes which generated the scandal of the Stolen Generation refereed to above and the Children of the Empire are still influential. Justice does not seem to be great supply if the people concerned are not us. As well, there has not been a large enough concerted push to reduce the flow of refugee / economic migrants at a regional basis.
  • Faydine
    There was a movie on cable this weekend that touched on bringing Native Americans into schools to make them white -- and in this case, take all the Indian out of them. It also made it clear that not everyone in the school agreed with the headmaster's position. One of the instructors encouraged the Indian boy to learn to write in English so he could preserve his culture. While I totally disagree with taking the native out of any person, I'm glad there were Native Americans who learned to write in English to give us insights into what we did wrong then.

    I have been involved with cross-cultural ministries for years -- and churches that are eager to send wide-eyed and well-meaning folks into another culture for the sake of the gospel. I think this points again to the simple fact that cross-cultural ministry is really hard work that is very easy to mess up. I don't believe it's impossible -- I do believe God calls us to do it and can equip us to do it -- but it's very easy to mess up.
  • The fact that he's a member of the accused party helps, but note that he didn't make an absolute statement like "Thus saith the Lord." He states a biblically based opinion.
  • jarvo1
    Every minister claims it either explictly or implictly. There are even Brian Houstons in this world that do so... Maybe your one of them?
  • Some have come from Afghanistan, Iran, Iraq.
    This group have come from Sri Lanka and are probably mostly Tamils fleeing the war there.
    The war is now over, but life in Sri Lanka for Tamils is
    not easy. This group say they have been living in Indonesia for a long time waiting in the queue to get a refugee visa to Australia. But some just give up waiting for years and decide to pay a people smuggler to send a leaky boat to Oz and try to
    make it to australias coastline to claim asylum.
    This is a high risk but it is not unlawful according to the UN convention to do so.
    Compared to other countries Australia takes very few refugees as part of the overall migrant intake
    But Australians excessively freak out over people who arrive in this way as though it is an invasion, or will lead to a massive uncontrolled amarda if it is not stopped.
  • Minnesotan
    I am curious who are the "boat people" seeking asylum and where are they coming from? They must be fleeing an oppressive government from somewhere. Where are they coming from? Vietnam? Indonesia? Papua New Guinea?
  • brianhouston
    Wow. you speak for God? very bold statement there.
blog comments powered by Disqus
click here for comments tech support
advertise here
  • MOST VIEWED
  • MOST COMMENTED
  • MOST RECENT
advertise here
advertise here
advertise here
advertise here


HOME | SUBSCRIBE | DONATE | TAKE ACTION | MAGAZINE  
SOJOMAIL | BLOGS | MEDIA | EVENTS | RESOURCES | ABOUT US  
Sojourners | 3333 14th Street NW, Suite 200 | Washington, DC 20010  
Phone 202.328.8842 | Fax 202.328.8757 | sojourners@sojo.net  
Unless otherwise noted, all material © Sojourners 2008