Get E-Mail Updates

Jena is America

Related Reading

Take Action on This Issue

Tell the Senate: Don't Cut International Aid

Please join us in telling the Senate: Protect foreign aid programs that help the poor and the needy. 

Today, Sept. 20, over 10,000 people will converge on Jena, Louisiana, to call for justice for the "Jena 6." Thousands more will hold vigils in cities across America. As reported previously on this blog, it all started on Sept. 1, 2006, when a black student at the high school asked an administrator if he could sit underneath a tree in the courtyard where traditionally only white students sat. The administrator told him that he could sit wherever he wanted. The next morning, there were three nooses hanging in that tree. The school dismissed this hate crime as a prank. When black students protested, the local district attorney threatened that he could take their life away with a "stroke of my pen." Then, white students provoked a series of incidents with black students.


In one altercation, a white graduate of the high school threatened three black students with a shotgun. The black youth wrestled the gun out of his hands, but incredibly were charged with theft of the weapon, ignoring the fact that they were defending themselves! Then, a group of white youth attacked a single black youth at a party -- and the police took no serious action. Finally, a black youth named Mychall Bell struck a white youth who had taunted him with racial slurs, and several of his friends joined the fray. The white youth went to the hospital, but was released that day and went to a party that night. The six black students were charged with attempted murder. After a national outcry, the charges were reduced to conspiracy and battery. This month, a Louisiana court of appeals vacated the charges against Bell, ruling that the prosecutor was wrong to charge him as an adult instead of a juvenile -- but he is still sitting in jail instead of moving forward with his education.


When I was in college, I was part of a faith-based movement called Friends of Justice. We emerged as an interracial alliance after a drug sting that arrested 60 percent of my town's young black men all in one fell swoop. Friends of Justice came together across racial lines to say this wasn't right, and we started praying, singing, and reading the Bible together. Now, Friends of Justice organizes across Texas and Louisiana to fight cases of civil rights violations and prosecutorial misconduct. In January, we got a call from a desperate mother in Jena, Louisiana, and so we sent out our executive director, Alan Bean, to do an investigation. After we generated international media attention, the cause of the Jena 6 attracted support from a host of civil rights organizations and celebrities.

America is shocked by the naked bigotry they see in Jena, Louisiana. Why aren't Jena's white residents equally protective of all their town's children? By only intervening to protect whites, Jena's white establishment bears the responsibility for letting conflict escalate between black and white youth.

It would be tempting to dismiss the Jena story as representing the vestiges of bigotry in small-town Louisiana -- but Jena is America.


Judging from some of the comments I hear from white Americans, many are stuck in an "us vs. them" mentality, where justice becomes a zero-sum-game: "there they go again, breaking the law and then playing the race card to escape responsibility!" Since we don't think of black youth as "our" youth, we resent it when someone stands up for their rights as citizens. It grieves me to say this, but too many white Americans see black youth only as potential threats that must be contained by all available means. Many protest that the problem lies only within "troublemaking black youth" -- rather than our broken criminal justice system.


There is no quick fix for America's distorted moral imagination. We can only move forward as a nation when our hearts and minds are transformed by the gospel. Lord, gives us eyes to see and ears to hear.


Lydia Bean is a founding member of Friends of Justice and a doctoral candidate in sociology at Harvard University. To get involved, you can visit the Friends of Justice blog, make a donation, and sign up for Action Updates. Hear a song about Jena, "Sitting on the Wall," performed by Alan and Lydia Bean at the Pentecost 2007 conference. (Refresh your browser if the song doesn't load correctly.)

Sojourners relies on the support of readers like you to sustain our message and ministry.

by: Payshun

09-20-2007 @ 3:44pm

I want that t shirt. As a black man this is raising some rather deep issues for me. I also don't know exactly what to say. But I agree w/ your blog completely. I find that the majority of white people I talk to are quite sympathetic if disempowered so... But all the black people I talked to are up in arms about this and want some heads to roll. I feel this too. I am really tired of being nice.

I really tired of people still sleeping. I am tired of playing the alarm button. I don't know what to do completely except support what's going on over there and call Jesse Jackson on his stupid comments about Barrack. But that's a separate and dumb issue. Sorry for bringing it up.

But there are so many layers to this case, the story and everything else. I don't know where to start exactly.

p

by: scgirl

09-20-2007 @ 3:57pm

Just because you feel wronged .. you cant not take the law in to your own hands .. This is a case of bullying . If the races were reversed ... Would the White boys have your support ? as A minotity woman . I am see this is another case of not moving forward . We should not still be looking at color and dividing America .

by: Jeff

09-20-2007 @ 4:03pm

I have only read one article on this, but it seems like there is some injustice here. I grudgingly have to agree with Jesse Jackson in part. Someone on the national stage should have made this an issue sooner. It may be a tad racist to take only Barak to task. Many people will pick sides on this issue based on Jesse Jackson ("if Jesse's for it, I'm against it).

If this is truly an injustice it should not be Dems or blacks stepping up, but all Americans. As a white very conservative American, count me in.

Jeff

by: neuro_nurse

09-20-2007 @ 4:09pm

"We should not still be looking at color and dividing America."

Welcome to Louisiana!

"If the races were reversed ..."

Not in this state or, as far as I can tell, anywhere south of the Mason-Dixon Line.

Racism is alive and well in this country, in the words of Justin Wilson, "I guarantee!"

Jena is a 4 hour drive from New Orleans, and I have a class I can't skip this afternoon, otherwise I'd go.

Seek peace and pursue it.

by: Jeff

09-20-2007 @ 4:15pm

Scgirl,
The troubling thing for me is that the school and the local police treated the two groups differently. The authorities lost control when they let the white boys off with barely a hand slap. When the authorities don't protect you, what choices do you have? When the ropes were hang in the tree, that should have been the point that severe punishment took place. The white boys continued to push the boundaries of what they could get away with. The police didn't draw the line, the black young men did. Someone was going to get seriously hurt, they made sure it was them.

Jeff

by: Stephanie

09-20-2007 @ 4:16pm

I am from the Jena area and I can say the racisim is a very powerful force there. Sadly, none of this story surprises me. (sigh)

by: Eric

09-20-2007 @ 5:47pm

It's pretty sad that things like this still go on today. Where were the school and city officials when the first signs of this problem erupted? If they had done something then their town wouldn't be all over CNN this morning.

by: Payshun

09-20-2007 @ 6:05pm

scgirl,

I am not going to attack a white guy walking down my neighborhood streets. It's just not going to happen. All I am doing is talking about how I feel which is better than acting out of vengeance.

p

by: GOHERD93

09-20-2007 @ 6:07pm

SC girl isnt far off of her thinking .. The black community seems to alwasy stick up for their race .. right or wrong if it is against Whites. For instance, The Duke Lacross players. Jesse has not apologized to them as of yet .

by: Harold C

09-20-2007 @ 6:30pm

I live in Louisiana,and it amazes me that a so-called Christian leaves the main portio of 'truth' out of this story. The 'Jena six' are 6 people of color who held a white boy down,kicked his ribs,ruined both his ears (permanently) ND BEAT HIM WITH SHOES. wHY WAS THIS LEFT OUT OF YOUR SO-CALLED STORY? sINCE THESE BRAVE SIX AGAINST ONE ALMOST COMMITED DEADLY ASSAULT,THEY were charged as adults. A black radio station in Baton Rouge has been trying their best to ignite a national riot against 'police,nat. guard and others'. Then one nat. media source appeared angry because the only restuarant in Jena would not be open for the 'celebration'-they failed to report that the black radio station told its listeners 'not to spend one penny in Jena'. I don't believe the fools have yet realized that it is a federal crime to encourage a riot across state lines.

by: Daniel

09-20-2007 @ 6:32pm

I will start this off by stating that I am white, and I am prejudice. I can't stand lazy people who starve society and prefer to stand on the street looking for handouts instead of getting a job. That prejudice has no race, gender, or age.

I think what the boys did was wrong and stupid. However, it was not illegal. The ACLU would argue that is was free speech.

I am tired of Jesse Jackson, Rev Al Sharpton, NAACP, etc of playing the race card. The black boys committed assault, which was illegal the last time I checked, and should be punished. Not because they are black, but because they were wrong.

I do believe there is still a lot of racism in this country. However, I fell more, not all, of it is with blacks.

We do not have white history month, white entertainment television, National Association of White People.

I long for the day when we only celebrate July 4th. Not June Teenth, Cinco De Mayo. Just July 4th. Then, we won't be white, black, ore hispanic. We will be American.

by: Gordon

09-20-2007 @ 6:34pm

I found this case appalling. There does indeed seem to be some prejudice at work here. Whether it's evidence of a larger problem nationally is arguable.

by: Annie (UK)

09-20-2007 @ 6:37pm

I've just seen the News reports on today's events in Jena on British TV. What concerns me is that 99% of the people present were Afro-American. Where were the white evangelical leaders who are usually so vocal on social issues like abortion and gay rights? Did no white Christians feel that they should attend and offer support. It seems that hundreds of poor black and white American youths can die together in Iraq to serve the interests of their government but are certainly not treated equally back in the "democratic" Homeland.

by: kevin s.

09-20-2007 @ 6:37pm

I am generally sympathetic to the cause of the Jena 6, but turning this into polemic seems neither helpful nor useful. The Jena Times offers a chronological account of the events (offered largely without commentary) at this address. Just scroll down to view it.

http://www.thejenatimes.net/home_page_graphics/home.html

With regard to the weapon theft incident, a white male reported that he had been robbed and beaten. The account conflicted with those who were arrested, but eyewitness accounts to gel with those of the alleged victim.

The biggest problems that I see are thus:

1) Putting nooses on trees is like bringing a gun to school. Nooses are murder weapons. The students responsible should have been expelled. That said, criminal charges would have been very difficult to bring to prosecution, and only an overzealous DA would prosecute such a case.

2) The media did everything in its power to sensationalize the story.

3) The prosecution decided to become overzealous once black participants were involved in a crime. The beating was a clear case of battery (knocking someone unconscious is battery), but not attempted murder.

I don't see where all the protests (with SWAT teams and Black Panthers and etc...) are going to make this situation better. I wish the black community had better spokespeople that Sharpton and Jackson, whose preening participation will only fuel the contention that this is simply an example of playing the race card.

by: Louisiana born

09-20-2007 @ 6:41pm

Yes, there is reverse raceism in Louisiana. It was is poor taste for white students to display hanging ropes but It is criminal for six students to beat up a lone student... I have personal first hand knowledge of a white couple being beat up on Martin Luther King day in the French Quarter of New Orleans by a gang of black youths. The police refused to make a report unless the couple came to the police station.... During hurricane Katrina groups of black youths roamed through the few streets which remained unflooded and looted and beat up whites. Crime and violence is wrong regardless of the color. Until we prosecute the crime and not the color there will be more racial strife....

by: Mark P (the Yank)

09-20-2007 @ 6:44pm

I don't know the whole story and won't comment too deeply or make too many assumptions. And, no offense to this blog, but I take what I read here with a substantial grain of salt.

What I do know:
1. The nooses are horrifying. Regardless of the motivation, such a gesture is comparable to spray-painting a swastika on a synagogue. Utterly reprehensible and shocking.
2. Mychall Bell assaulted another kid violently. Given the background, the action seems particularly understandable (and the charge of attempted murder absurdly silly), but it still merits punishment (though I don't believe jail or prison time is AT ALL the answer) unless you want to encourage a subjective standard whereby instigating physical violence is acceptable under certain conditions.
3. Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton cloud issues and are a stumbling block to clear and non-partisan views of the case. Now, I have no beef with Sharpton on his handling of this issue. He was entirely right when he said that "we didn't bring race in it, those that hung the nooses brought the race into it." Absolutely right.

Nonetheless, past action in which both have knee-jerk reactions to anything involving whites and blacks (playing the race card in unrelated circumstances and drawing racial lines regardless of context) has created an incredible stench around their names.

It takes a conscious and deliberate effort on my behalf NOT to immediately write off anything the two men support or claim. I suspect I am not alone, and I know that had I heard of Sharpton and Jackson getting riled about a race issue and not investigated further, I would have rolled my eyes, assuming this was another attempt to create false racial tension.

So. The Jena 6 cause would be better off without these men; as soon as they enter the picture, "race relations" become far more tense. It is unfair, but people will make assumptions whenever Jackson or Sharpton claim race bias.

by: Rick Nowlin

09-20-2007 @ 6:49pm

We do not have white history month, white entertainment television, National Association of White People.

For the longest time American history was "white history." Everything was "white entertainment television." And in fact there indeed once was an NAAWP, headed by the beloved David Duke -- who actually ran for governor of (cough) Louisiana sometime in the 1990s.

I long for the day when we only celebrate July 4th. Not June Teenth, Cinco De Mayo. Just July 4th. Then, we won't be white, black, ore hispanic. We will be American.

Then start treating people as though they are Americans -- that is, "with liberty and justice for all." Your ancestors too were unjustly-treated "hyphenated-Americans" at one point, and you best not forget that.

by: Anonymous

09-20-2007 @ 6:53pm

Lousiana born:

"poor taste"

THAT is a DISGUSTING understatement. It's poor taste wear brown shoes and a black belt, get to a meeting five minutes late, or belch in mixed company.

Hanging a noose on a tree is an intimidation tactic that summons images of terror, racial violence, and murder. It is an essentially and overtly threatening gesture, hardly different than a verbal "If you... I'll kill you."

---

Some comments above (namely, the extent of the attack's violence, and the conflicting stories about the shotgun matter) support my decision to read with a certain reservation.

Ms Bean, I don't appreciate your obvious glossing over or ignoring certain aspects of the story in order to incite the passions of your readers.

by: Mark P (the Yank)

09-20-2007 @ 6:56pm

Lousiana born:

"poor taste"

THAT is a DISGUSTING understatement. It's poor taste wear brown shoes and a black belt, get to a meeting five minutes late, or belch in mixed company.

Hanging a noose on a tree is an intimidation tactic that summons images of terror, racial violence, and murder. It is an essentially and overtly threatening gesture, hardly different than a verbal "If you... I'll kill you."

---

Some comments above (namely, the extent of the attack's violence, and the conflicting stories about the shotgun matter) support my decision to read with a certain reservation.

Ms Bean, I don't appreciate your obvious glossing over or ignoring certain aspects of the story in order to incite the passions of your readers.

---

"We do not have white history month, white entertainment television, National Association of White People."

I used to think like that. Then I realized the legitimacy of Rick's perspective. There's no reason for watching the evolution of the history or evolution of "white America." It is certainly worth taking the time to appreciate overlooked achievements and matters of import in the development of America's minority populations...

(though I do still think Black History Month is a bit overdone, and most celebrations involve a lot of glossing over and revising histories to fit political motives)

by: marialynn

09-20-2007 @ 7:00pm

This makes me sad. When I start to think the country has made strides towards equality something always happens- James Byrd's brutal murder, the response to Katrina, and now this. I think about leaders like Bobby Kennedy and his speech that he gave the night MLK was killed. I think about Congressman John Lewis and the leadership of SNCC. I wish we had leaders like this today (Lewis is still in Congress but doesn't seem to be as much as a "spokesman").

I feel like this case is just one of the most visable but similiar things go on every day. I wish I had answers, I wish I knew how to be part of the solution. I just keep seeing it as 1 step forward, 5 steps back. This makes me sad.
Maria

by: kevin s.

09-20-2007 @ 7:01pm

"Yes, there is reverse raceism in Louisiana. It was is poor taste for white students to display hanging ropes but It is criminal for six students to beat up a lone student..."

The two events are apples and oranges, but equally severe in degree. Displaying hanging ropes on a tree in response to a black student asking if he may sit at a tree goes beyond poor taste. There is an implied threat. Such a threat may be difficult to prosecute, which is why the FBI left it to the school, but those kids should have been expelled. I don't even see how this is debatable.

by: Rick Nowlin

09-20-2007 @ 7:05pm

The Jena 6 cause would be better off without these men; as soon as they enter the picture, "race relations" become far more tense. It is unfair, but people will make assumptions whenever Jackson or Sharpton claim race bias.

The reality is that no one else in the African-American community has their pull and the kind of trust thereof that they won't be frightened or bought off by people who want things swept under the rug. Call them hucksters or charlatans if you will, and truth be told I'm not fans of them either, but they do maintain a certain amount of independence from the power structure that ensures that they won't be intimdated or dissuaded from the task at hand. That's at least part of the reason why conservative America resents them so deeply. Contrary to what you wrote, race relations did not become "more tense" upon their arrival; they simply expose the tension that already existed. (After all, the same charge was consistently made about MLK Jr.)

I remember reading a recent story in Time magazine about JFK agonizing what to do about Southern intransigence concerning racial desegregation, possibly in part because he didn't want to offend that base. He concluded, however, that the South would never clean up its act on its own and he had to use Federal authority to change things, and it's one reason why the white South is Republican today.

by: GOHERD93

09-20-2007 @ 7:36pm

a little focus on ..Jackson / Sharpton ...I believe Owe the Duke Players Public Apology . They assumed they were guilty with out any evidence ..( but one word against another )..They Lady who who cried rape( A super SERIOUS allegation) had nothing to back up her case- NOTHING !! but Jackson & Sharpton took her side immediately .. If you ask me .. They are wanting to keep the races divided ..

by: TRACEY

09-20-2007 @ 7:44pm

What happened to prosecuting individuals who commit hate crimes. (ropes hanging from trees symbolize hatred that stems very deeply into this Countries most shameful acts committed upon a race of people) I would make a wager that if swastika symbols had been spray painted onto the white tree not only would there had been major coverage by the mass media but the individuals responsible would have been expelled, arrested and prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. Moreover, it would have been acceptable to see Derkowich, Goldberg and any other Jewish organization freely speaking out and put together a movement to assure that those responsible for such acts be prosecuted. So I do not understand how people on this blog can write that its alright to commit a crime that opens the wounds of deep hatred that still plagues our society, and continues to keep us from uniting as "one people" Americans. I am an African American female who is disgusted by the continued injustices my people continue to endure on a daily bases, especially our Black men. I do not condone the fights that took place between the students, however, where is the equal justice.

by: GOHERD

09-20-2007 @ 8:08pm

OK .. why are were using the terms .. Afriacan American ..Why cant we be Americans (Period) When I go to England .. I dont hear the term -African British .. I dont go around calling my self German-American .. Lets just be AMERICANS !

by: Evelyn

09-20-2007 @ 8:11pm

Prayer is the answer to all things, if we pray according to His will then He hears us. American and the American people should realize that it's going to take prayer. It is a must that we be not of this world system but, be about the Kingdom of God. When I read about the problems I immediately went in prayer for the boys, their families and for the other families that God may touch lives and bring justice and peace in the town of Jena. I am praying for you JENA 6.

by: Payshun

09-20-2007 @ 8:19pm

ok Duke has nothing and I do mean nothing to do w/ this. So please Goherd93 let it go. If you want an apology from Sharpton or whoever go ask them for it. But please stop writing about that case.

Tracey,
As one of those black men I feel the same way for the beautiful and amazing black women in this country.

This is not a simple case but the way the authorities handled it was wrong. That's why so many black people are angry. Many whites suffer from fatigue at seeing angry black people marching or protesting this type of injustice. I can understand that. I suffer fatigue from hearing about this stupid crap.

I am also really tired of seeing people not taking Sharpton or others seriously because they happen to piss off a bunch of the more conservative or "color blinded" white folks. Sharpton in particular is a great man. The problem w/ this whole discussion is that some people are still blind to the racial issues still plaguing our country. They are fine w/ it as long as it doesn't affect their daily lives. Now that it is (even in a small measure) they want to know why? What can be done to make it stop?

I think those questions are vaild but are kind of silly at this stage in the game. Until we start by openly talking about culture, ethnicity, gender, class, sexual oritentation and how we can love our fellow man nothing will really change. That's the thing that black people are protesting the most. Those boys did not deserve everything that was initially brought to them especially when they are responding to years of being discrimiated against.

p

by: M. Hill

09-20-2007 @ 8:23pm

"Overt and very stark racial disparities are a matter of daily occurrence when it comes to law enforcement, the judicial process, and the prison system". Jim Wallis said this and that is the heart of this issue. Black people are up in arms not just because of this lone issue, but because this is an example of a common occurrances in America, where people of color are given harsher and more dire consequences in the judicial system than whites. No one is saying what these CHILDREN did are wrong (please remember that these are children when you speak harsh about them), both black and white. The white kids that beat up the black student days before at a party were not charged with attempted murder yet they committed the same crime. Children in America are not receiving the guidance they need from Adults in their community and this is outcome.

by: splinterlog

09-20-2007 @ 8:23pm

Lets just be AMERICANS

And that's all visible minorities are asking for. And yet every time there is a case of discrimination this refrain gets turned on its head so that it means, "we'll discriminate based on colour but the moment a visible minority protests coloured racism, we'll accuse THEM of being racist not US".

Its something like Shelby Steele taking a phrase from a famous speech by MLK and turning it on its head - "The Content of their Character". Steele argues that colour based strategies (like AA) go against the spirit of this speech as much as racism does - all the while ignoring the fact that strategies like AA exist BECAUSE of colour based discrimination and not FOR it.

by: Rick Nowlin

09-20-2007 @ 8:27pm

OK .. why are were using the terms .. African American ..Why cant we be Americans (Period) When I go to England .. I dont hear the term -African British .. I dont go around calling my self German-American .. Lets just be AMERICANS !

FWIW, "African-American" started in general usage in or around 1988 as an alternative to "black" (which to this day I still prefer, personally) because "black" was seen as having negative connotations -- "black market," "black sheep of the family" etc. So it represented a way for people to define themselves rather than having others define them, which is a major key to respect and equality, which can lead to eventual reconciliation. Besides, blacks have never had that kind of presence, at least for that long, in Europe, so racism there isn't quite as pervasive as it is here (of course, I'd be a fool to deny that it doesn't exist at all).

Besides, most white Americans, especially in major cities, are so mixed up ethnically due to intermarriage that just because they have a certain surname doesn't mean they have that cultural background. A close friend of mine has a German last name but also comes from Eastern European stock as well.

by: Nuttshell

09-20-2007 @ 8:47pm

As a black woman who experienced incidents like the one in Jena up through the 80's in MD, let me offer some perspective about the reaction of the Jena 6. I am not nor have I heard any other black people including Mychal Bell's mother, saying that the Jena 6 should not be held responsible for the incident where there was 6 on 1. What I have problem with is how the local prosecuter chose to deal with that attack versus other incidents. Should Mychal Bell go to prison for 22 years over this? I think not. Most people seem to gloss over the fact that a black youth was physically attacked at a party by white youths before the last incident. What about the black guys who had a shotgun pointed at them? How is that not a crime as well? No one but the black guys were charged in that incident. As for the school board, they overturned the susupension of the kids involved in the noose incident. Of course the black families were insensed. Here's another example of white privilege. The DA didn't make things better with his not-so-subtle threat about ruining the lives of black kids in that community. That was code meant to scare and intimidate those kids and frankly they erupted. How many adults would do differently?

Let me mention proportionality. Most white people act as if these entire incidents happened in a vacuum. What kinds of violence and intimidation have the black people of Jena, LA been experiencing before Sept 1, 2006? Many, many black people experience racial intimidation and threats of violence as a rather common experience. What kind of place must Jena be if in 2006, there is a "white" tree that only white kids sit under? How absurd! The fact that this practice has existed for so long means that the people of Jena have a log in their eye regarding race. And the reaction white students had towards presumptious black students who would dare sit under the tree... Many of you folks have no idea what kind of internal rage exists in people who grow up under that kind of bigotry.

My sister and I used to be routinely "menaced" (we would be surrounded by a group of guys who would call us the n-word and other vile names while making threatening moves against us) by white guys in our community in suburban MD. My sister and I took to carrying a bat in our car and invited the menacers to let us practice our swing on their ignorant heads. I mention this to say that many black people experience many slights that cut and corrode the soul and when larger issues like the nooses and the other acts of intimidation (and we don't know all the things that have happened)occur, the response is usually severe. A cauldron has been bubbling in this community for a long time and unfortunately these kinds of things happen.

Now, some will say that you can't lash out when someone is unkind to you. While it is true, it is understandable that after a series of injustices, people will lash out and sometimes violently. Jena leaders had an opportunity to prevent nearly everything that has happened. Now they are trying to unfairly put all the blame on the black kids. In this case, white and black kids were hurt by the Jena leaders and officials cowardice.

I'm no big Sharpton fan but I think his involvement is consistent and appropriate for this kind of incident. He would be roundly criticized (by his constituency) if he wasn't involved.

by: Lynn Bergfalk

09-20-2007 @ 8:51pm

There is no question that racism persists, and the Jena situation demonstrates it in a variety of ways. However, we don't advance justice with the selective omission of factual material. Lydia Bean does a huge disservice to the cause by not being forthright about the act of violence that was the basis of the legal action. One individual was beaten, held down, & viciously kicked in the head by a group of youths. Had this happened to any of us, we would not consider the concussion and other injuries insignificant. I have been involved in urban ministries for years, and believe unequivocally that there is never an excuse for this kind of violence - period. It doesn't matter who hit who, or what color the hitter or 'hittee' is - humans, let alone Christians, cannot not excuse this kind of gratuitous violence. I agreed with nearly everything that Ms. Bean said, and her analysis of the larger context, and regret that she ruined her credibility, in my judgment, by not being forthcoming about all the details. Her case would not have been weakened by telling the whole story. Had someone on the other side of the spectrum slanted a story is this way (which in my judgment happens too often), I would have been infuriated - and so in fairness, must express in this case my disappointment with the omission of certain information, and the failure to categorically reject violence.

by: Warren Sapp

09-20-2007 @ 9:03pm

I still believe in the best in people. Racism presents us all with a huge blind spot. Violence of any kind most often grows from blind spots. Did the teens who hung the nooses not see how reprehensible (way beyond "poor taste") and threatening that was? I do not encourage criminal prosecution or permanent expulsion for hanging nooses -- I encourage strong and sustained action on the part of the school system to confront the issue -- suspension if necessary. After Jessie and Al have gone home to other dramas, Jena will have to sweep up the mess. This is an opportunity for dialog, learning, reconciliation after all the uproar has died down. Is Jena and its school system racist? You bet. Can they see it? Not yet. Can human beings learn? I hope. I'm so glad for the intervention of "outsiders." But it will have to be "insiders" who finally bring the reconciliation home. Where are the churches and their leaders?
Peace, Warren

by: Mark P (the Yank)

09-20-2007 @ 9:32pm

Is the assault considered a hate crime? I intend that as a factual legal question, though it is, no doubt, loaded.

by: Rick Nowlin

09-20-2007 @ 10:40pm

Lydia Bean does a huge disservice to the cause by not being forthright about the act of violence that was the basis of the legal action.

I'm not so sure about that. The whole situation reminds me a bit of the aftermath of the L. A. riots after the cops were acquitted for beating Rodney King -- I didn't condone them (and, in fact, when I saw Reginald Denny having a brick hit him in the head I burst into tears), but I understand the frustration of justice not being done. There does seem to be a double-standard here, and that's why people marched today.

by: kevin s.

09-20-2007 @ 10:47pm

"I would make a wager that if swastika symbols had been spray painted onto the white tree not only would there had been major coverage by the mass media but the individuals responsible would have been expelled, arrested and prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. "

I would take that bet in a heartbeat. There are swastikas all over Minneapolis, the product of gang graffiti. Nobody cares. At all. When was the last time a national news story arose from a swastika being painted? Do you think that it doesn't happen?

I agree that the students should have been expelled, but there was simply no case for prosecution here.

by: Gordon

09-20-2007 @ 11:04pm

"I agree that the students should have been expelled, but there was simply no case for prosecution here."

I have given this a lot of thought, and so far haven't come up with a crime that could have been charged. Defacing a public tree maybe? Malicious mischief?

by: Jeff

09-21-2007 @ 12:07am

The gun theft angle is the key I think. One source I read said there was a fight and a white student went and got a gun, which was then taken from him by a black student. The black student was then charged with theft. Another story is the incident was an assault and robbery with the black student stealing the gun.

Getting to the bottom of this is important. If the first story is true. Then we have the police protecting someone making a threat with a gun. If the second story is true, we have a media that is willing to foment a race riot to boost ratings.

Jeff

by: Rick Nowlin

09-21-2007 @ 1:21am

The gun theft angle is the key I think. One source I read said there was a fight and a white student went and got a gun, which was then taken from him by a black student.

Because the white student was threatening the black student with it, I'm told.

by: letjusticerolldown

09-21-2007 @ 1:43am

I think the problem is my heart.
Jena is America and it is a VERY complex place. And I really would prefer to be left alone rather than try to dissect and understand everything involved. It is absolutely unfair to project 400 years of a nation's racial issues onto a handful of people in Jena--but neither does a noose in Jena exist in a vacuum.
I look in my home cities of Montgomery AL and Minneapolis MN and see our (i.e. Christian churches) dire failure to incarnate a creative, loving and just Gospel. We so need to courageously create a space of great grace, forgiveness, courage, clarity, and loving truth-telling--in which redemption and reconciliation and partnership occur.
Peace to all in Jena tonight.

by: Mark P (the Yank)

09-21-2007 @ 1:55am

The gun threaten/theft is a big deal; I agree.

The Jena Times states that unconnected eyewitnesses support the claim that it was a robbery, NOT a self-defense against a threat (see kevin's link to the article). Perhaps the paper itself is compromised. All the sources for the Jena 6 support the self-defense claim, but (so far as I've seen) they offer no citation, evidence, or support aside from the testimony of those accused. I'll try not to pass final judgment from afar; thus far the preponderance of evidence evidently stands behind robbery, though certainly not beyond a reasonable doubt.

The fact that Ms Bean chose to ignore even that possibility, stating that it was self-defense with absolute factuality (and without any reference of assertions to the contrary in any way) tells me that she's more into inflaming than investigating.

And again, to reiterate, I do not believe that the "six" ought to be in jail or prison, but neither do I believe that they ought to escape without any justice. Regardless of circumstances, let's remember that there is only one brutal beating in this matter; the Jena 6 are obviously not hardened criminals or "lost causes" to be thrown away in the penal system, but nor are they innocent little angels.

by: Bob

09-21-2007 @ 2:04am

You don't have the facts straight. The nooses appeared the day after the black kids sat under the tree. The white kids who hung the nooses all got suspended.

The black kid who was sentenced to a long jail term (for kicking the unconscious white kid in the head), had a prior criminal record. The uproar is over racial inequity. But many are acting as if hanging the nooses from the tree was a worse crime than a potentially deadly assault! Let's get the facts straight, and a get a realistic view of the situation.

by: Rick Nowlin

09-21-2007 @ 11:21am

But many are acting as if hanging the nooses from the tree was a worse crime than a potentially deadly assault!

YOU DON'T GET IT!!! In that context, it's similar to threatening someone with a gun -- and as such it's not a prank but a hate crime! As such, the white kids should have been expelled!

by: Mark P (the Yank)

09-21-2007 @ 12:56pm

Rick, it IS serious, as I've said. And it is indeed a very serious threat. And they *should* have been expelled.

Bob's implication is that the assault was a worse crime than the threat. Do you disagree?

Is threatening someone worse than knocking them unconscious and then kicking the s*** out of them?

by: Rick Nowlin

09-21-2007 @ 1:07pm

Bob's implication is that the assault was a worse crime than the threat. Do you disagree?

In that context, I do -- because the "noose prank" was purely racially motivated and the fight, if anything, was retaliation for that. Now, I don't condone the fight, but the clearly racist atmosphere had a hand in creating the conditions under which it occurred.

by: Nuttshell

09-21-2007 @ 1:27pm

Mark P & Bob,

Why do you keep ignoring the fact that there were black kids who were also assaulted? A black kid was jumped at a party which in turn led to other violence. My goodness this kind of thing has been going on for nearly 40 years after schools were desegregated. It happened at my high school. And usually after one kid got jumped, then a group of other kids would go out and jump some other kids (usually of a different race). Given the attitudes of people in that town, do you really think blacks down there would instigate violence if they didn't think they were being provoked or intimidated? It wasn't too long ago (and I'm sure the parents made sure their kids knew it) when black youths could be killed for doing little of nothing that offended white people, especially down South. Mark P & Bob are all too willing to believe that apart from the nooses, the white kids down there are pure. And yes the kids who put up the nooses were originally suspended but then the school board overturned that decision so effectively nothing happened to them. That's when this whole situation started. The school board and DA are to blame for everything that happened afterwards.

by: Rick Nowlin

09-21-2007 @ 1:50pm

It wasn't too long ago (and I'm sure the parents made sure their kids knew it) when black youths could be killed for doing little or nothing that offended white people, especially down South.

That's why the nooses are the central issue in this conflict.

by: Rick Nowlin

09-21-2007 @ 3:38pm

neuro_nurse -- That's what this is all about.

I can't say a lot of that stuff has happened to me. While driving I've never been stopped by a cop for no good reason. I've never knowingly been followed around by a store clerk. But, as I mentioned earlier, people have tried to exclude me and twice even picked fights with me. I always doubted that, despite the progress I've seen in my 46 years, we've "cured" racism.

My own racially- and culturally-diverse evangelical church had a "diversity luncheon" last Sunday, and I wondered why it was even necessary. This situation reminded me.

by: letjusticerolldown

09-21-2007 @ 4:04pm

Rick,

It took me many years to grasp the "threat of the noose"--that there is a long history and present capacity of Black lives to be taken with the system offering nothing but a bland, blank, stare (at best).
My dear white brothers and sisters--at the heart of racism and at the heart of complaints against US foreign policy--is the human capacity to murder--the human capacity to make another invisible--to shut them down--with a wave of the hand, or look of disgust, to shut down another person as a nothing--to commit homicide in our hearts that can in a more ultimate form produce genocide.
One of the good things, in my thinking, about the cultural hostility to conservative Christians is that it gives some of us just an inkling of what it feels like to be made invisible and a legitimate target of scorn.
Before we argue over details/facts of cases in situations like this, I believe we really need hearts, minds and ears opened. We need to perceive in our spirits what the noose is about and then apply our heads.
The noose hangers could well have been semi-innocent pranksters. In which case white parents, pastors, teachers are needed to minister something very deep--something they may have not taken time to understand.
Persons, such as Rick, have been a profound blessing in my journey--African-Americans who through and through feel it is a lost cause to attempt to communicate their journey to conservative white guys like me--and yet they pause, take a deep breath, and again help me to see and hear. Until we hear the reality of this central relationship (white-black relations) in the American church and nation--our ears will be crippled and twisted in hearing the voices of the world--which we must do if we are to fulfill our God-assigned purposes.

by: Rick Nowlin

09-21-2007 @ 4:12pm

One of the good things, in my thinking, about the cultural hostility to conservative Christians is that it gives some of us just an inkling of what it feels like to be made invisible and a legitimate target of scorn.

FWIW, probably most of the scorn that conservative Christians -- which, to a certain extent, includes me -- receive is, frankly, earned. It's our touchiness, arrogance and self-righteousness, not our Savior, that non-believers react to, plus the fact that we haven't always communicate a message of grace and reconcilation.

Otherwise, you've got it down pat.

Comments sorted by highest rated. After voting you must refresh your page to see the sort order change.

by: GOHERD

09-20-2007 @ 8:08pm

OK .. why are were using the terms .. Afriacan American ..Why cant we be Americans (Period) When I go to England .. I dont hear the term -African British .. I dont go around calling my self German-American .. Lets just be AMERICANS !

by: Payshun

09-20-2007 @ 3:44pm

I want that t shirt. As a black man this is raising some rather deep issues for me. I also don't know exactly what to say. But I agree w/ your blog completely. I find that the majority of white people I talk to are quite sympathetic if disempowered so... But all the black people I talked to are up in arms about this and want some heads to roll. I feel this too. I am really tired of being nice.

I really tired of people still sleeping. I am tired of playing the alarm button. I don't know what to do completely except support what's going on over there and call Jesse Jackson on his stupid comments about Barrack. But that's a separate and dumb issue. Sorry for bringing it up.

But there are so many layers to this case, the story and everything else. I don't know where to start exactly.

p

by: scgirl

09-20-2007 @ 3:57pm

Just because you feel wronged .. you cant not take the law in to your own hands .. This is a case of bullying . If the races were reversed ... Would the White boys have your support ? as A minotity woman . I am see this is another case of not moving forward . We should not still be looking at color and dividing America .

by: scgirl

09-20-2007 @ 3:57pm

Just because you feel wronged .. you cant not take the law in to your own hands .. This is a case of bullying . If the races were reversed ... Would the White boys have your support ? as A minotity woman . I am see this is another case of not moving forward . We should not still be looking at color and dividing America .

by: Jeff

09-20-2007 @ 4:03pm

I have only read one article on this, but it seems like there is some injustice here. I grudgingly have to agree with Jesse Jackson in part. Someone on the national stage should have made this an issue sooner. It may be a tad racist to take only Barak to task. Many people will pick sides on this issue based on Jesse Jackson ("if Jesse's for it, I'm against it).

If this is truly an injustice it should not be Dems or blacks stepping up, but all Americans. As a white very conservative American, count me in.

Jeff

by: Jeff

09-20-2007 @ 4:03pm

I have only read one article on this, but it seems like there is some injustice here. I grudgingly have to agree with Jesse Jackson in part. Someone on the national stage should have made this an issue sooner. It may be a tad racist to take only Barak to task. Many people will pick sides on this issue based on Jesse Jackson ("if Jesse's for it, I'm against it).

If this is truly an injustice it should not be Dems or blacks stepping up, but all Americans. As a white very conservative American, count me in.

Jeff

by: neuro_nurse

09-20-2007 @ 4:09pm

"We should not still be looking at color and dividing America."

Welcome to Louisiana!

"If the races were reversed ..."

Not in this state or, as far as I can tell, anywhere south of the Mason-Dixon Line.

Racism is alive and well in this country, in the words of Justin Wilson, "I guarantee!"

Jena is a 4 hour drive from New Orleans, and I have a class I can't skip this afternoon, otherwise I'd go.

Seek peace and pursue it.

by: neuro_nurse

09-20-2007 @ 4:09pm

"We should not still be looking at color and dividing America."

Welcome to Louisiana!

"If the races were reversed ..."

Not in this state or, as far as I can tell, anywhere south of the Mason-Dixon Line.

Racism is alive and well in this country, in the words of Justin Wilson, "I guarantee!"

Jena is a 4 hour drive from New Orleans, and I have a class I can't skip this afternoon, otherwise I'd go.

Seek peace and pursue it.

by: Jeff

09-20-2007 @ 4:15pm

Scgirl,
The troubling thing for me is that the school and the local police treated the two groups differently. The authorities lost control when they let the white boys off with barely a hand slap. When the authorities don't protect you, what choices do you have? When the ropes were hang in the tree, that should have been the point that severe punishment took place. The white boys continued to push the boundaries of what they could get away with. The police didn't draw the line, the black young men did. Someone was going to get seriously hurt, they made sure it was them.

Jeff

by: Jeff

09-20-2007 @ 4:15pm

Scgirl,
The troubling thing for me is that the school and the local police treated the two groups differently. The authorities lost control when they let the white boys off with barely a hand slap. When the authorities don't protect you, what choices do you have? When the ropes were hang in the tree, that should have been the point that severe punishment took place. The white boys continued to push the boundaries of what they could get away with. The police didn't draw the line, the black young men did. Someone was going to get seriously hurt, they made sure it was them.

Jeff

by: Stephanie

09-20-2007 @ 4:16pm

I am from the Jena area and I can say the racisim is a very powerful force there. Sadly, none of this story surprises me. (sigh)

by: Stephanie

09-20-2007 @ 4:16pm

I am from the Jena area and I can say the racisim is a very powerful force there. Sadly, none of this story surprises me. (sigh)

by: Eric

09-20-2007 @ 5:47pm

It's pretty sad that things like this still go on today. Where were the school and city officials when the first signs of this problem erupted? If they had done something then their town wouldn't be all over CNN this morning.

by: Eric

09-20-2007 @ 5:47pm

It's pretty sad that things like this still go on today. Where were the school and city officials when the first signs of this problem erupted? If they had done something then their town wouldn't be all over CNN this morning.

by: Payshun

09-20-2007 @ 6:05pm

scgirl,

I am not going to attack a white guy walking down my neighborhood streets. It's just not going to happen. All I am doing is talking about how I feel which is better than acting out of vengeance.

p

by: Payshun

09-20-2007 @ 6:05pm

scgirl,

I am not going to attack a white guy walking down my neighborhood streets. It's just not going to happen. All I am doing is talking about how I feel which is better than acting out of vengeance.

p

by: GOHERD93

09-20-2007 @ 6:07pm

SC girl isnt far off of her thinking .. The black community seems to alwasy stick up for their race .. right or wrong if it is against Whites. For instance, The Duke Lacross players. Jesse has not apologized to them as of yet .

by: GOHERD93

09-20-2007 @ 6:07pm

SC girl isnt far off of her thinking .. The black community seems to alwasy stick up for their race .. right or wrong if it is against Whites. For instance, The Duke Lacross players. Jesse has not apologized to them as of yet .

by: Harold C

09-20-2007 @ 6:30pm

I live in Louisiana,and it amazes me that a so-called Christian leaves the main portio of 'truth' out of this story. The 'Jena six' are 6 people of color who held a white boy down,kicked his ribs,ruined both his ears (permanently) ND BEAT HIM WITH SHOES. wHY WAS THIS LEFT OUT OF YOUR SO-CALLED STORY? sINCE THESE BRAVE SIX AGAINST ONE ALMOST COMMITED DEADLY ASSAULT,THEY were charged as adults. A black radio station in Baton Rouge has been trying their best to ignite a national riot against 'police,nat. guard and others'. Then one nat. media source appeared angry because the only restuarant in Jena would not be open for the 'celebration'-they failed to report that the black radio station told its listeners 'not to spend one penny in Jena'. I don't believe the fools have yet realized that it is a federal crime to encourage a riot across state lines.

by: Harold C

09-20-2007 @ 6:30pm

I live in Louisiana,and it amazes me that a so-called Christian leaves the main portio of 'truth' out of this story. The 'Jena six' are 6 people of color who held a white boy down,kicked his ribs,ruined both his ears (permanently) ND BEAT HIM WITH SHOES. wHY WAS THIS LEFT OUT OF YOUR SO-CALLED STORY? sINCE THESE BRAVE SIX AGAINST ONE ALMOST COMMITED DEADLY ASSAULT,THEY were charged as adults. A black radio station in Baton Rouge has been trying their best to ignite a national riot against 'police,nat. guard and others'. Then one nat. media source appeared angry because the only restuarant in Jena would not be open for the 'celebration'-they failed to report that the black radio station told its listeners 'not to spend one penny in Jena'. I don't believe the fools have yet realized that it is a federal crime to encourage a riot across state lines.

by: Daniel

09-20-2007 @ 6:32pm

I will start this off by stating that I am white, and I am prejudice. I can't stand lazy people who starve society and prefer to stand on the street looking for handouts instead of getting a job. That prejudice has no race, gender, or age.

I think what the boys did was wrong and stupid. However, it was not illegal. The ACLU would argue that is was free speech.

I am tired of Jesse Jackson, Rev Al Sharpton, NAACP, etc of playing the race card. The black boys committed assault, which was illegal the last time I checked, and should be punished. Not because they are black, but because they were wrong.

I do believe there is still a lot of racism in this country. However, I fell more, not all, of it is with blacks.

We do not have white history month, white entertainment television, National Association of White People.

I long for the day when we only celebrate July 4th. Not June Teenth, Cinco De Mayo. Just July 4th. Then, we won't be white, black, ore hispanic. We will be American.

by: Daniel

09-20-2007 @ 6:32pm

I will start this off by stating that I am white, and I am prejudice. I can't stand lazy people who starve society and prefer to stand on the street looking for handouts instead of getting a job. That prejudice has no race, gender, or age.

I think what the boys did was wrong and stupid. However, it was not illegal. The ACLU would argue that is was free speech.

I am tired of Jesse Jackson, Rev Al Sharpton, NAACP, etc of playing the race card. The black boys committed assault, which was illegal the last time I checked, and should be punished. Not because they are black, but because they were wrong.

I do believe there is still a lot of racism in this country. However, I fell more, not all, of it is with blacks.

We do not have white history month, white entertainment television, National Association of White People.

I long for the day when we only celebrate July 4th. Not June Teenth, Cinco De Mayo. Just July 4th. Then, we won't be white, black, ore hispanic. We will be American.

by: Gordon

09-20-2007 @ 6:34pm

I found this case appalling. There does indeed seem to be some prejudice at work here. Whether it's evidence of a larger problem nationally is arguable.

by: Gordon

09-20-2007 @ 6:34pm

I found this case appalling. There does indeed seem to be some prejudice at work here. Whether it's evidence of a larger problem nationally is arguable.

by: Annie (UK)

09-20-2007 @ 6:37pm

I've just seen the News reports on today's events in Jena on British TV. What concerns me is that 99% of the people present were Afro-American. Where were the white evangelical leaders who are usually so vocal on social issues like abortion and gay rights? Did no white Christians feel that they should attend and offer support. It seems that hundreds of poor black and white American youths can die together in Iraq to serve the interests of their government but are certainly not treated equally back in the "democratic" Homeland.

by: Annie (UK)

09-20-2007 @ 6:37pm

I've just seen the News reports on today's events in Jena on British TV. What concerns me is that 99% of the people present were Afro-American. Where were the white evangelical leaders who are usually so vocal on social issues like abortion and gay rights? Did no white Christians feel that they should attend and offer support. It seems that hundreds of poor black and white American youths can die together in Iraq to serve the interests of their government but are certainly not treated equally back in the "democratic" Homeland.

by: kevin s.

09-20-2007 @ 6:37pm

I am generally sympathetic to the cause of the Jena 6, but turning this into polemic seems neither helpful nor useful. The Jena Times offers a chronological account of the events (offered largely without commentary) at this address. Just scroll down to view it.

http://www.thejenatimes.net/home_page_graphics/home.html

With regard to the weapon theft incident, a white male reported that he had been robbed and beaten. The account conflicted with those who were arrested, but eyewitness accounts to gel with those of the alleged victim.

The biggest problems that I see are thus:

1) Putting nooses on trees is like bringing a gun to school. Nooses are murder weapons. The students responsible should have been expelled. That said, criminal charges would have been very difficult to bring to prosecution, and only an overzealous DA would prosecute such a case.

2) The media did everything in its power to sensationalize the story.

3) The prosecution decided to become overzealous once black participants were involved in a crime. The beating was a clear case of battery (knocking someone unconscious is battery), but not attempted murder.

I don't see where all the protests (with SWAT teams and Black Panthers and etc...) are going to make this situation better. I wish the black community had better spokespeople that Sharpton and Jackson, whose preening participation will only fuel the contention that this is simply an example of playing the race card.

by: Louisiana born

09-20-2007 @ 6:41pm

Yes, there is reverse raceism in Louisiana. It was is poor taste for white students to display hanging ropes but It is criminal for six students to beat up a lone student... I have personal first hand knowledge of a white couple being beat up on Martin Luther King day in the French Quarter of New Orleans by a gang of black youths. The police refused to make a report unless the couple came to the police station.... During hurricane Katrina groups of black youths roamed through the few streets which remained unflooded and looted and beat up whites. Crime and violence is wrong regardless of the color. Until we prosecute the crime and not the color there will be more racial strife....

by: Mark P (the Yank)

09-20-2007 @ 6:44pm

I don't know the whole story and won't comment too deeply or make too many assumptions. And, no offense to this blog, but I take what I read here with a substantial grain of salt.

What I do know:
1. The nooses are horrifying. Regardless of the motivation, such a gesture is comparable to spray-painting a swastika on a synagogue. Utterly reprehensible and shocking.
2. Mychall Bell assaulted another kid violently. Given the background, the action seems particularly understandable (and the charge of attempted murder absurdly silly), but it still merits punishment (though I don't believe jail or prison time is AT ALL the answer) unless you want to encourage a subjective standard whereby instigating physical violence is acceptable under certain conditions.
3. Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton cloud issues and are a stumbling block to clear and non-partisan views of the case. Now, I have no beef with Sharpton on his handling of this issue. He was entirely right when he said that "we didn't bring race in it, those that hung the nooses brought the race into it." Absolutely right.

Nonetheless, past action in which both have knee-jerk reactions to anything involving whites and blacks (playing the race card in unrelated circumstances and drawing racial lines regardless of context) has created an incredible stench around their names.

It takes a conscious and deliberate effort on my behalf NOT to immediately write off anything the two men support or claim. I suspect I am not alone, and I know that had I heard of Sharpton and Jackson getting riled about a race issue and not investigated further, I would have rolled my eyes, assuming this was another attempt to create false racial tension.

So. The Jena 6 cause would be better off without these men; as soon as they enter the picture, "race relations" become far more tense. It is unfair, but people will make assumptions whenever Jackson or Sharpton claim race bias.

by: Rick Nowlin

09-20-2007 @ 6:49pm

We do not have white history month, white entertainment television, National Association of White People.

For the longest time American history was "white history." Everything was "white entertainment television." And in fact there indeed once was an NAAWP, headed by the beloved David Duke -- who actually ran for governor of (cough) Louisiana sometime in the 1990s.

I long for the day when we only celebrate July 4th. Not June Teenth, Cinco De Mayo. Just July 4th. Then, we won't be white, black, ore hispanic. We will be American.

Then start treating people as though they are Americans -- that is, "with liberty and justice for all." Your ancestors too were unjustly-treated "hyphenated-Americans" at one point, and you best not forget that.

by: Anonymous

09-20-2007 @ 6:53pm

Lousiana born:

"poor taste"

THAT is a DISGUSTING understatement. It's poor taste wear brown shoes and a black belt, get to a meeting five minutes late, or belch in mixed company.

Hanging a noose on a tree is an intimidation tactic that summons images of terror, racial violence, and murder. It is an essentially and overtly threatening gesture, hardly different than a verbal "If you... I'll kill you."

---

Some comments above (namely, the extent of the attack's violence, and the conflicting stories about the shotgun matter) support my decision to read with a certain reservation.

Ms Bean, I don't appreciate your obvious glossing over or ignoring certain aspects of the story in order to incite the passions of your readers.

by: Mark P (the Yank)

09-20-2007 @ 6:56pm

Lousiana born:

"poor taste"

THAT is a DISGUSTING understatement. It's poor taste wear brown shoes and a black belt, get to a meeting five minutes late, or belch in mixed company.

Hanging a noose on a tree is an intimidation tactic that summons images of terror, racial violence, and murder. It is an essentially and overtly threatening gesture, hardly different than a verbal "If you... I'll kill you."

---

Some comments above (namely, the extent of the attack's violence, and the conflicting stories about the shotgun matter) support my decision to read with a certain reservation.

Ms Bean, I don't appreciate your obvious glossing over or ignoring certain aspects of the story in order to incite the passions of your readers.

---

"We do not have white history month, white entertainment television, National Association of White People."

I used to think like that. Then I realized the legitimacy of Rick's perspective. There's no reason for watching the evolution of the history or evolution of "white America." It is certainly worth taking the time to appreciate overlooked achievements and matters of import in the development of America's minority populations...

(though I do still think Black History Month is a bit overdone, and most celebrations involve a lot of glossing over and revising histories to fit political motives)

by: marialynn

09-20-2007 @ 7:00pm

This makes me sad. When I start to think the country has made strides towards equality something always happens- James Byrd's brutal murder, the response to Katrina, and now this. I think about leaders like Bobby Kennedy and his speech that he gave the night MLK was killed. I think about Congressman John Lewis and the leadership of SNCC. I wish we had leaders like this today (Lewis is still in Congress but doesn't seem to be as much as a "spokesman").

I feel like this case is just one of the most visable but similiar things go on every day. I wish I had answers, I wish I knew how to be part of the solution. I just keep seeing it as 1 step forward, 5 steps back. This makes me sad.
Maria

by: kevin s.

09-20-2007 @ 7:01pm

"Yes, there is reverse raceism in Louisiana. It was is poor taste for white students to display hanging ropes but It is criminal for six students to beat up a lone student..."

The two events are apples and oranges, but equally severe in degree. Displaying hanging ropes on a tree in response to a black student asking if he may sit at a tree goes beyond poor taste. There is an implied threat. Such a threat may be difficult to prosecute, which is why the FBI left it to the school, but those kids should have been expelled. I don't even see how this is debatable.

by: Rick Nowlin

09-20-2007 @ 7:05pm

The Jena 6 cause would be better off without these men; as soon as they enter the picture, "race relations" become far more tense. It is unfair, but people will make assumptions whenever Jackson or Sharpton claim race bias.

The reality is that no one else in the African-American community has their pull and the kind of trust thereof that they won't be frightened or bought off by people who want things swept under the rug. Call them hucksters or charlatans if you will, and truth be told I'm not fans of them either, but they do maintain a certain amount of independence from the power structure that ensures that they won't be intimdated or dissuaded from the task at hand. That's at least part of the reason why conservative America resents them so deeply. Contrary to what you wrote, race relations did not become "more tense" upon their arrival; they simply expose the tension that already existed. (After all, the same charge was consistently made about MLK Jr.)

I remember reading a recent story in Time magazine about JFK agonizing what to do about Southern intransigence concerning racial desegregation, possibly in part because he didn't want to offend that base. He concluded, however, that the South would never clean up its act on its own and he had to use Federal authority to change things, and it's one reason why the white South is Republican today.

by: GOHERD93

09-20-2007 @ 7:36pm

a little focus on ..Jackson / Sharpton ...I believe Owe the Duke Players Public Apology . They assumed they were guilty with out any evidence ..( but one word against another )..They Lady who who cried rape( A super SERIOUS allegation) had nothing to back up her case- NOTHING !! but Jackson & Sharpton took her side immediately .. If you ask me .. They are wanting to keep the races divided ..

by: TRACEY

09-20-2007 @ 7:44pm

What happened to prosecuting individuals who commit hate crimes. (ropes hanging from trees symbolize hatred that stems very deeply into this Countries most shameful acts committed upon a race of people) I would make a wager that if swastika symbols had been spray painted onto the white tree not only would there had been major coverage by the mass media but the individuals responsible would have been expelled, arrested and prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. Moreover, it would have been acceptable to see Derkowich, Goldberg and any other Jewish organization freely speaking out and put together a movement to assure that those responsible for such acts be prosecuted. So I do not understand how people on this blog can write that its alright to commit a crime that opens the wounds of deep hatred that still plagues our society, and continues to keep us from uniting as "one people" Americans. I am an African American female who is disgusted by the continued injustices my people continue to endure on a daily bases, especially our Black men. I do not condone the fights that took place between the students, however, where is the equal justice.

by: GOHERD

09-20-2007 @ 8:08pm

OK .. why are were using the terms .. Afriacan American ..Why cant we be Americans (Period) When I go to England .. I dont hear the term -African British .. I dont go around calling my self German-American .. Lets just be AMERICANS !

by: Evelyn

09-20-2007 @ 8:11pm

Prayer is the answer to all things, if we pray according to His will then He hears us. American and the American people should realize that it's going to take prayer. It is a must that we be not of this world system but, be about the Kingdom of God. When I read about the problems I immediately went in prayer for the boys, their families and for the other families that God may touch lives and bring justice and peace in the town of Jena. I am praying for you JENA 6.

by: Payshun

09-20-2007 @ 8:19pm

ok Duke has nothing and I do mean nothing to do w/ this. So please Goherd93 let it go. If you want an apology from Sharpton or whoever go ask them for it. But please stop writing about that case.

Tracey,
As one of those black men I feel the same way for the beautiful and amazing black women in this country.

This is not a simple case but the way the authorities handled it was wrong. That's why so many black people are angry. Many whites suffer from fatigue at seeing angry black people marching or protesting this type of injustice. I can understand that. I suffer fatigue from hearing about this stupid crap.

I am also really tired of seeing people not taking Sharpton or others seriously because they happen to piss off a bunch of the more conservative or "color blinded" white folks. Sharpton in particular is a great man. The problem w/ this whole discussion is that some people are still blind to the racial issues still plaguing our country. They are fine w/ it as long as it doesn't affect their daily lives. Now that it is (even in a small measure) they want to know why? What can be done to make it stop?

I think those questions are vaild but are kind of silly at this stage in the game. Until we start by openly talking about culture, ethnicity, gender, class, sexual oritentation and how we can love our fellow man nothing will really change. That's the thing that black people are protesting the most. Those boys did not deserve everything that was initially brought to them especially when they are responding to years of being discrimiated against.

p

by: M. Hill

09-20-2007 @ 8:23pm

"Overt and very stark racial disparities are a matter of daily occurrence when it comes to law enforcement, the judicial process, and the prison system". Jim Wallis said this and that is the heart of this issue. Black people are up in arms not just because of this lone issue, but because this is an example of a common occurrances in America, where people of color are given harsher and more dire consequences in the judicial system than whites. No one is saying what these CHILDREN did are wrong (please remember that these are children when you speak harsh about them), both black and white. The white kids that beat up the black student days before at a party were not charged with attempted murder yet they committed the same crime. Children in America are not receiving the guidance they need from Adults in their community and this is outcome.

by: splinterlog

09-20-2007 @ 8:23pm

Lets just be AMERICANS

And that's all visible minorities are asking for. And yet every time there is a case of discrimination this refrain gets turned on its head so that it means, "we'll discriminate based on colour but the moment a visible minority protests coloured racism, we'll accuse THEM of being racist not US".

Its something like Shelby Steele taking a phrase from a famous speech by MLK and turning it on its head - "The Content of their Character". Steele argues that colour based strategies (like AA) go against the spirit of this speech as much as racism does - all the while ignoring the fact that strategies like AA exist BECAUSE of colour based discrimination and not FOR it.

by: Rick Nowlin

09-20-2007 @ 8:27pm

OK .. why are were using the terms .. African American ..Why cant we be Americans (Period) When I go to England .. I dont hear the term -African British .. I dont go around calling my self German-American .. Lets just be AMERICANS !

FWIW, "African-American" started in general usage in or around 1988 as an alternative to "black" (which to this day I still prefer, personally) because "black" was seen as having negative connotations -- "black market," "black sheep of the family" etc. So it represented a way for people to define themselves rather than having others define them, which is a major key to respect and equality, which can lead to eventual reconciliation. Besides, blacks have never had that kind of presence, at least for that long, in Europe, so racism there isn't quite as pervasive as it is here (of course, I'd be a fool to deny that it doesn't exist at all).

Besides, most white Americans, especially in major cities, are so mixed up ethnically due to intermarriage that just because they have a certain surname doesn't mean they have that cultural background. A close friend of mine has a German last name but also comes from Eastern European stock as well.

by: Nuttshell

09-20-2007 @ 8:47pm

As a black woman who experienced incidents like the one in Jena up through the 80's in MD, let me offer some perspective about the reaction of the Jena 6. I am not nor have I heard any other black people including Mychal Bell's mother, saying that the Jena 6 should not be held responsible for the incident where there was 6 on 1. What I have problem with is how the local prosecuter chose to deal with that attack versus other incidents. Should Mychal Bell go to prison for 22 years over this? I think not. Most people seem to gloss over the fact that a black youth was physically attacked at a party by white youths before the last incident. What about the black guys who had a shotgun pointed at them? How is that not a crime as well? No one but the black guys were charged in that incident. As for the school board, they overturned the susupension of the kids involved in the noose incident. Of course the black families were insensed. Here's another example of white privilege. The DA didn't make things better with his not-so-subtle threat about ruining the lives of black kids in that community. That was code meant to scare and intimidate those kids and frankly they erupted. How many adults would do differently?

Let me mention proportionality. Most white people act as if these entire incidents happened in a vacuum. What kinds of violence and intimidation have the black people of Jena, LA been experiencing before Sept 1, 2006? Many, many black people experience racial intimidation and threats of violence as a rather common experience. What kind of place must Jena be if in 2006, there is a "white" tree that only white kids sit under? How absurd! The fact that this practice has existed for so long means that the people of Jena have a log in their eye regarding race. And the reaction white students had towards presumptious black students who would dare sit under the tree... Many of you folks have no idea what kind of internal rage exists in people who grow up under that kind of bigotry.

My sister and I used to be routinely "menaced" (we would be surrounded by a group of guys who would call us the n-word and other vile names while making threatening moves against us) by white guys in our community in suburban MD. My sister and I took to carrying a bat in our car and invited the menacers to let us practice our swing on their ignorant heads. I mention this to say that many black people experience many slights that cut and corrode the soul and when larger issues like the nooses and the other acts of intimidation (and we don't know all the things that have happened)occur, the response is usually severe. A cauldron has been bubbling in this community for a long time and unfortunately these kinds of things happen.

Now, some will say that you can't lash out when someone is unkind to you. While it is true, it is understandable that after a series of injustices, people will lash out and sometimes violently. Jena leaders had an opportunity to prevent nearly everything that has happened. Now they are trying to unfairly put all the blame on the black kids. In this case, white and black kids were hurt by the Jena leaders and officials cowardice.

I'm no big Sharpton fan but I think his involvement is consistent and appropriate for this kind of incident. He would be roundly criticized (by his constituency) if he wasn't involved.

by: Lynn Bergfalk

09-20-2007 @ 8:51pm

There is no question that racism persists, and the Jena situation demonstrates it in a variety of ways. However, we don't advance justice with the selective omission of factual material. Lydia Bean does a huge disservice to the cause by not being forthright about the act of violence that was the basis of the legal action. One individual was beaten, held down, & viciously kicked in the head by a group of youths. Had this happened to any of us, we would not consider the concussion and other injuries insignificant. I have been involved in urban ministries for years, and believe unequivocally that there is never an excuse for this kind of violence - period. It doesn't matter who hit who, or what color the hitter or 'hittee' is - humans, let alone Christians, cannot not excuse this kind of gratuitous violence. I agreed with nearly everything that Ms. Bean said, and her analysis of the larger context, and regret that she ruined her credibility, in my judgment, by not being forthcoming about all the details. Her case would not have been weakened by telling the whole story. Had someone on the other side of the spectrum slanted a story is this way (which in my judgment happens too often), I would have been infuriated - and so in fairness, must express in this case my disappointment with the omission of certain information, and the failure to categorically reject violence.

by: Lynn Bergfalk

09-20-2007 @ 8:51pm

There is no question that racism persists, and the Jena situation demonstrates it in a variety of ways. However, we don't advance justice with the selective omission of factual material. Lydia Bean does a huge disservice to the cause by not being forthright about the act of violence that was the basis of the legal action. One individual was beaten, held down, & viciously kicked in the head by a group of youths. Had this happened to any of us, we would not consider the concussion and other injuries insignificant. I have been involved in urban ministries for years, and believe unequivocally that there is never an excuse for this kind of violence - period. It doesn't matter who hit who, or what color the hitter or 'hittee' is - humans, let alone Christians, cannot not excuse this kind of gratuitous violence. I agreed with nearly everything that Ms. Bean said, and her analysis of the larger context, and regret that she ruined her credibility, in my judgment, by not being forthcoming about all the details. Her case would not have been weakened by telling the whole story. Had someone on the other side of the spectrum slanted a story is this way (which in my judgment happens too often), I would have been infuriated - and so in fairness, must express in this case my disappointment with the omission of certain information, and the failure to categorically reject violence.

by: Warren Sapp

09-20-2007 @ 9:03pm

I still believe in the best in people. Racism presents us all with a huge blind spot. Violence of any kind most often grows from blind spots. Did the teens who hung the nooses not see how reprehensible (way beyond "poor taste") and threatening that was? I do not encourage criminal prosecution or permanent expulsion for hanging nooses -- I encourage strong and sustained action on the part of the school system to confront the issue -- suspension if necessary. After Jessie and Al have gone home to other dramas, Jena will have to sweep up the mess. This is an opportunity for dialog, learning, reconciliation after all the uproar has died down. Is Jena and its school system racist? You bet. Can they see it? Not yet. Can human beings learn? I hope. I'm so glad for the intervention of "outsiders." But it will have to be "insiders" who finally bring the reconciliation home. Where are the churches and their leaders?
Peace, Warren

by: Warren Sapp

09-20-2007 @ 9:03pm

I still believe in the best in people. Racism presents us all with a huge blind spot. Violence of any kind most often grows from blind spots. Did the teens who hung the nooses not see how reprehensible (way beyond "poor taste") and threatening that was? I do not encourage criminal prosecution or permanent expulsion for hanging nooses -- I encourage strong and sustained action on the part of the school system to confront the issue -- suspension if necessary. After Jessie and Al have gone home to other dramas, Jena will have to sweep up the mess. This is an opportunity for dialog, learning, reconciliation after all the uproar has died down. Is Jena and its school system racist? You bet. Can they see it? Not yet. Can human beings learn? I hope. I'm so glad for the intervention of "outsiders." But it will have to be "insiders" who finally bring the reconciliation home. Where are the churches and their leaders?
Peace, Warren

by: Mark P (the Yank)

09-20-2007 @ 9:32pm

Is the assault considered a hate crime? I intend that as a factual legal question, though it is, no doubt, loaded.

by: Mark P (the Yank)

09-20-2007 @ 9:32pm

Is the assault considered a hate crime? I intend that as a factual legal question, though it is, no doubt, loaded.