Get E-Mail Updates

Exorcising the Demons of a Church's Racial Divide

On a sad but pivotal day in the late 1780s, several of the African American members of Philadelphia's St. George's Methodist Church were thrown out of the church by the congregation's white leaders because of their refusal to sit in a blacks-only gallery area. Those African American Christians eventually went on to form what would become the first congregation of the African American Methodist Episcopal Church, Mother Bethel A.M.E.

Related Reading

Take Action on This Issue

Tell the Senate: Don't Cut International Aid

Please join us in telling the Senate: Protect foreign aid programs that help the poor and the needy. 

Now, 200 years after racism divided black from white at St. George's Methodist, members of the modern-day congregations of St. George's and Mother Bethel have reunited.

In an emotional worship service this past weekend, 300 of Mother Bethel's members joined the 30 current members of St. George's to celebrate the 240th anniversary of St. George's -- and to finally address head on the ugly sins of prejudice and segregation that had split the church by race.

According to The Philadelphia Inquirer, St. George's pastor, the Rev. Fred Day, presented Bethel's pastor, the Rev. Mark Kelly Tyler, with a cross constructed with the original nails from the balcony that was built to segregate black and white.

091028-richard-allenIndeed, it was the same balcony that A.M.E. founder Richard Allen and his fellow African American congregants refused to sit in on that fateful day 200 years earlier when they were banished from the church. Tyler told the Inquirer:

It almost defies words to go back to preaching in a place that our founder, Richard Allen -- who had been pulled off his knees in morning prayer -- had vowed never to return to ... It's a sense of rejoicing, moving beyond bitterness.

The Inquirer continues: "By the time the final hymns were sung, it was as if demons had been exorcised and a 200-year-old abyss had been bridged."

Read The Philadelphia Inquirer story here. For an extensive history of the infamous split and subsequent founding of the African Methodist Episcopal denomination, visit the Mother Bethel A.M.E. website.

portrait-edward-gilbreathEdward Gilbreath is director of editorial for Urban Ministries Inc., editor of UrbanFaith.com, and the author of Reconciliation Blues: A Black Evangelical's Inside View of White Christianity. He blogs at Reconciliation Blog. This article appears courtesy of a partnership with UrbanFaith.com.

Sojourners relies on the support of readers like you to sustain our message and ministry.

by: conservativenut

11-04-2009 @ 8:10pm

I think that in the end the key to overcoming the effects of racism is preaching the Word of God consistently. People of all races will be drawn to it and at the same time be convicted of their many sins, including racism. I attend a church where this occurs and people of all races seem to be drawn by the Holy Spirit to hear what God has to say. In the end we are all joining together, no longer conscious of our race or economic status, but rather our common membership in the body of Christ.

by: SisterMarie

10-28-2009 @ 6:10pm

I suspect that for those who take the time to closely research church history in the United States, they would find many other churches where racial issues and racism has divided a church denomination or a specific congregation. I applaud this church for recognizing the inequity and attempting to reconcile.

by: ando

10-28-2009 @ 6:58pm

Wouldn't it be nice if more Sojo authors would write about positive news regarding racial reconciliation as well as the growth of multi-cultural churches around the country. Thanks, Edward.

by: SisterMarie

10-28-2009 @ 6:10pm

I suspect that for those who take the time to closely research church history in the United States, they would find many other churches where racial issues and racism has divided a church denomination or a specific congregation. I applaud this church for recognizing the inequity and attempting to reconcile.

by: squeaky

10-28-2009 @ 8:48pm

Hey ando, it's not clear what you mean in your comment. I think you are being positive, but the way you worded your post can be interpreted as a sarcastic comment, as well. You may wish to edit it for clarity so there is no ambiguity. Just a suggestion.

by: ando

10-28-2009 @ 6:58pm

Wouldn't it be nice if more Sojo authors would write about positive news regarding racial reconciliation as well as the growth of multi-cultural churches around the country. Thanks, Edward.

by: squeaky

10-28-2009 @ 8:48pm

Hey ando, it's not clear what you mean in your comment. I think you are being positive, but the way you worded your post can be interpreted as a sarcastic comment, as well. You may wish to edit it for clarity so there is no ambiguity. Just a suggestion.

by: ando

10-28-2009 @ 9:27pm

I was being positive toward Edward's blog and wondering there isn't more positive news about racial reconciliation and multi-cultural churches here.

by: squeaky

10-28-2009 @ 10:48pm

Thanks for the clarification--that's what I thought you meant.

by: WitnessforPeace

10-28-2009 @ 11:54pm

Thank you, thank you for this story. Positive news isn't just desirable because it makes us feel good, as worthwhile as that is. But it shows what WORKS.
Blessings,
Witness4Peace

by: ando

10-28-2009 @ 9:27pm

I was being positive toward Edward's blog and wondering there isn't more positive news about racial reconciliation and multi-cultural churches here.

by: Jesdisciple

10-29-2009 @ 12:11am

No doubt, too many mistakes have been made. And these are so deep that they're taking well over 200 years (not certain when it all began) to finally die and wither away.

by: squeaky

10-28-2009 @ 10:48pm

Thanks for the clarification--that's what I thought you meant.

by: WitnessforPeace

10-28-2009 @ 11:54pm

Thank you, thank you for this story. Positive news isn't just desirable because it makes us feel good, as worthwhile as that is. But it shows what WORKS.
Blessings,
Witness4Peace

by: Jesdisciple

10-29-2009 @ 12:11am

No doubt, too many mistakes have been made. And these are so deep that they're taking well over 200 years (not certain when it all began) to finally die and wither away.

by: tam73

10-29-2009 @ 12:22pm

What good news to hear that people can come together and forgive and forget. I know that there is still a lot of racial tension out there but if we would truly seek God and gaze upon his face, we would all be ashamed of whatever prejudices and biases we have. Oh, that we would all see people as God sees them.

Thanks for a good article.

by: BlueDeacon

10-29-2009 @ 12:30pm

Because there aren't that many of them. Most interracial/multicultural churches are of fairly recent vintage and often designed to be just that; thus, they don't have the history that these two assemblies do.

Three years ago I wrote a story for ESA on my church, which is over a hundred years old and where just a generation ago African-Americans were not welcome; now, however, it's fully-integrated. But I can tell you that the same process that these two Methodist churches referred to in this post was in play; before I came there church members -- and I kid you not -- had literally prayed the spirit of racism out of even every closet! Racism in that context really was considered a spiritual stronghold.

by: tam73

10-29-2009 @ 12:22pm

What good news to hear that people can come together and forgive and forget. I know that there is still a lot of racial tension out there but if we would truly seek God and gaze upon his face, we would all be ashamed of whatever prejudices and biases we have. Oh, that we would all see people as God sees them.

Thanks for a good article.

by: BlueDeacon

10-29-2009 @ 12:30pm

Because there aren't that many of them. Most interracial/multicultural churches are of fairly recent vintage and often designed to be just that; thus, they don't have the history that these two assemblies do.

Three years ago I wrote a story for ESA on my church, which is over a hundred years old and where just a generation ago African-Americans were not welcome; now, however, it's fully-integrated. But I can tell you that the same process that these two Methodist churches referred to in this post was in play; before I came there church members -- and I kid you not -- had literally prayed the spirit of racism out of even every closet! Racism in that context really was considered a spiritual stronghold.

by: conservativenut

11-04-2009 @ 6:10pm

I think that in the end the key to overcoming the effects of racism is preaching the Word of God consistently. People of all races will be drawn to it and at the same time be convicted of their many sins, including racism. I attend a church where this occurs and people of all races seem to be drawn by the Holy Spirit to hear what God has to say. In the end we are all joining together, no longer conscious of our race or economic status, but rather our common membership in the body of Christ.

by: conservativenut

11-04-2009 @ 6:10pm

I think that in the end the key to overcoming the effects of racism is preaching the Word of God consistently. People of all races will be drawn to it and at the same time be convicted of their many sins, including racism. I attend a church where this occurs and people of all races seem to be drawn by the Holy Spirit to hear what God has to say. In the end we are all joining together, no longer conscious of our race or economic status, but rather our common membership in the body of Christ.

by: conservativenut

11-04-2009 @ 8:10pm

I think that in the end the key to overcoming the effects of racism is preaching the Word of God consistently. People of all races will be drawn to it and at the same time be convicted of their many sins, including racism. I attend a church where this occurs and people of all races seem to be drawn by the Holy Spirit to hear what God has to say. In the end we are all joining together, no longer conscious of our race or economic status, but rather our common membership in the body of Christ.

by: irish_annie

10-30-2009 @ 2:39am

amen ando... amidst the multitude of protests for "what we are against", finally, there is a voice for what we are FOR. selah.

by: irish_annie

10-30-2009 @ 2:39am

amen ando... amidst the multitude of protests for "what we are against", finally, there is a voice for what we are FOR. selah.

Comments sorted by highest rated. After voting you must refresh your page to see the sort order change.

by: SisterMarie

10-28-2009 @ 6:10pm

I suspect that for those who take the time to closely research church history in the United States, they would find many other churches where racial issues and racism has divided a church denomination or a specific congregation. I applaud this church for recognizing the inequity and attempting to reconcile.

by: SisterMarie

10-28-2009 @ 6:10pm

I suspect that for those who take the time to closely research church history in the United States, they would find many other churches where racial issues and racism has divided a church denomination or a specific congregation. I applaud this church for recognizing the inequity and attempting to reconcile.

by: ando

10-28-2009 @ 6:58pm

Wouldn't it be nice if more Sojo authors would write about positive news regarding racial reconciliation as well as the growth of multi-cultural churches around the country. Thanks, Edward.

by: ando

10-28-2009 @ 6:58pm

Wouldn't it be nice if more Sojo authors would write about positive news regarding racial reconciliation as well as the growth of multi-cultural churches around the country. Thanks, Edward.

by: squeaky

10-28-2009 @ 8:48pm

Hey ando, it's not clear what you mean in your comment. I think you are being positive, but the way you worded your post can be interpreted as a sarcastic comment, as well. You may wish to edit it for clarity so there is no ambiguity. Just a suggestion.

by: squeaky

10-28-2009 @ 8:48pm

Hey ando, it's not clear what you mean in your comment. I think you are being positive, but the way you worded your post can be interpreted as a sarcastic comment, as well. You may wish to edit it for clarity so there is no ambiguity. Just a suggestion.

by: ando

10-28-2009 @ 9:27pm

I was being positive toward Edward's blog and wondering there isn't more positive news about racial reconciliation and multi-cultural churches here.

by: ando

10-28-2009 @ 9:27pm

I was being positive toward Edward's blog and wondering there isn't more positive news about racial reconciliation and multi-cultural churches here.

by: squeaky

10-28-2009 @ 10:48pm

Thanks for the clarification--that's what I thought you meant.

by: squeaky

10-28-2009 @ 10:48pm

Thanks for the clarification--that's what I thought you meant.

by: WitnessforPeace

10-28-2009 @ 11:54pm

Thank you, thank you for this story. Positive news isn't just desirable because it makes us feel good, as worthwhile as that is. But it shows what WORKS.
Blessings,
Witness4Peace

by: WitnessforPeace

10-28-2009 @ 11:54pm

Thank you, thank you for this story. Positive news isn't just desirable because it makes us feel good, as worthwhile as that is. But it shows what WORKS.
Blessings,
Witness4Peace

by: Jesdisciple

10-29-2009 @ 12:11am

No doubt, too many mistakes have been made. And these are so deep that they're taking well over 200 years (not certain when it all began) to finally die and wither away.

by: Jesdisciple

10-29-2009 @ 12:11am

No doubt, too many mistakes have been made. And these are so deep that they're taking well over 200 years (not certain when it all began) to finally die and wither away.

by: tam73

10-29-2009 @ 12:22pm

What good news to hear that people can come together and forgive and forget. I know that there is still a lot of racial tension out there but if we would truly seek God and gaze upon his face, we would all be ashamed of whatever prejudices and biases we have. Oh, that we would all see people as God sees them.

Thanks for a good article.

by: tam73

10-29-2009 @ 12:22pm

What good news to hear that people can come together and forgive and forget. I know that there is still a lot of racial tension out there but if we would truly seek God and gaze upon his face, we would all be ashamed of whatever prejudices and biases we have. Oh, that we would all see people as God sees them.

Thanks for a good article.

by: BlueDeacon

10-29-2009 @ 12:30pm

Because there aren't that many of them. Most interracial/multicultural churches are of fairly recent vintage and often designed to be just that; thus, they don't have the history that these two assemblies do.

Three years ago I wrote a story for ESA on my church, which is over a hundred years old and where just a generation ago African-Americans were not welcome; now, however, it's fully-integrated. But I can tell you that the same process that these two Methodist churches referred to in this post was in play; before I came there church members -- and I kid you not -- had literally prayed the spirit of racism out of even every closet! Racism in that context really was considered a spiritual stronghold.

by: BlueDeacon

10-29-2009 @ 12:30pm

Because there aren't that many of them. Most interracial/multicultural churches are of fairly recent vintage and often designed to be just that; thus, they don't have the history that these two assemblies do.

Three years ago I wrote a story for ESA on my church, which is over a hundred years old and where just a generation ago African-Americans were not welcome; now, however, it's fully-integrated. But I can tell you that the same process that these two Methodist churches referred to in this post was in play; before I came there church members -- and I kid you not -- had literally prayed the spirit of racism out of even every closet! Racism in that context really was considered a spiritual stronghold.

by: irish_annie

10-30-2009 @ 2:39am

amen ando... amidst the multitude of protests for "what we are against", finally, there is a voice for what we are FOR. selah.

by: irish_annie

10-30-2009 @ 2:39am

amen ando... amidst the multitude of protests for "what we are against", finally, there is a voice for what we are FOR. selah.

by: conservativenut

11-04-2009 @ 6:10pm

I think that in the end the key to overcoming the effects of racism is preaching the Word of God consistently. People of all races will be drawn to it and at the same time be convicted of their many sins, including racism. I attend a church where this occurs and people of all races seem to be drawn by the Holy Spirit to hear what God has to say. In the end we are all joining together, no longer conscious of our race or economic status, but rather our common membership in the body of Christ.

by: conservativenut

11-04-2009 @ 6:10pm

I think that in the end the key to overcoming the effects of racism is preaching the Word of God consistently. People of all races will be drawn to it and at the same time be convicted of their many sins, including racism. I attend a church where this occurs and people of all races seem to be drawn by the Holy Spirit to hear what God has to say. In the end we are all joining together, no longer conscious of our race or economic status, but rather our common membership in the body of Christ.

by: conservativenut

11-04-2009 @ 8:10pm

I think that in the end the key to overcoming the effects of racism is preaching the Word of God consistently. People of all races will be drawn to it and at the same time be convicted of their many sins, including racism. I attend a church where this occurs and people of all races seem to be drawn by the Holy Spirit to hear what God has to say. In the end we are all joining together, no longer conscious of our race or economic status, but rather our common membership in the body of Christ.

by: conservativenut

11-04-2009 @ 8:10pm

I think that in the end the key to overcoming the effects of racism is preaching the Word of God consistently. People of all races will be drawn to it and at the same time be convicted of their many sins, including racism. I attend a church where this occurs and people of all races seem to be drawn by the Holy Spirit to hear what God has to say. In the end we are all joining together, no longer conscious of our race or economic status, but rather our common membership in the body of Christ.