Get E-Mail Updates

God's Politics Blog

This Thanksgiving Remember the Immigrant, Pilgrim

by Jim Wallis 11-25-2009 | 4:30pm
Print
57 Comments | Login or Register to post comments

091125_immigrationAs I take time to reflect on what I am truly thankful for, my family certainly tops the list. I've just been out of the country for a week, so I will cherish the time sitting around the table with my kids, asking one another to share what we are most thankful for. And this year, my wife Joy will celebrate her first Thanksgiving as a U.S. citizen.

Related Reading

Take Action on This Issue

Tell the Senate: Don't Cut International Aid

Please join us in telling the Senate: Protect foreign aid programs that help the poor and the needy. 

I am painfully aware that not every family is as fortunate as mine. The broken nature of America's immigration system is deeply felt during the holidays by millions in the United States who long to be reunited with their loved ones.

Long backlogs in our nation's family immigration system have kept families apart for years -- even decades, in some instances. I was also shocked to learn that over the past ten years, more than 100,000 parents of U.S. citizen children have been deported by our government. Four million U.S. citizen kids live in "mixed-status families" -- families comprised of both legal and undocumented residents who are fighting to stay together in the face of deportation and permanent separation. For us in the faith community who value and cherish families, this should not be acceptable.

In the coming months, you'll be hearing a lot more from us about the broken U.S. immigration system and how you can advocate for just and humane immigration reform that builds up families. Sign up for our Christians for Comprehensive Immigration Reform newsletter and we promise to keep you up to date on ways you can advocate and engage in our work.

When you gather around the table with friends, family, and loved ones this Thanksgiving, remember the immigrant. Think of the empty seats at the tables of households across this nation. And join with me in imagining what next year's Thanksgiving might look like if we are successful in reforming our nation's immigration system with strong measures that reunite families. Now that would be something to be grateful for.

57 Comments | Login or Register to post comments
Sojourners relies on the support of readers like you to sustain our message and ministry.

Related Stories

Resources

Like what you're reading? Get Sojourners E-Mail updates!

by: Tapestry

07-30-2011 @ 1:36am

Smoke...

[

by: jhutto77

11-25-2009 @ 5:15pm

Thanks for allowing me to express my short opinion.

Simply put, this Thanksgiving and every Thanksgiving, we should and must remember the millions of natives of this land decimated by the European settlers. The Trail of Tears that is still taking place on today's reservations. Our Thanksgiving is their genocide and not since Robert Kennedy has any Presidential candidate or Executive even bothered to visit a reservation. My heart goes out to them. Thank you.

J. Hutto, Sr.

by: Monte_Asbury

11-28-2009 @ 6:21pm

It was, of course, the breaking of laws for the purpose of showing mercy that first aroused anger toward Jesus. What right has the USA to expect obedience from his followers to laws that, similarly, would prevent mercy?

Is Jesus Lord, or is Caesar?

by: betsydewitt

11-28-2009 @ 4:25pm

Many of the deported parents of U.S. citizen children were legal permanent residents deported for convictions defined as aggravated felonies ( a very broad definition that includes some misdemeanors). Many of these parents have lived in the U.S. for the majority of their lives and now find themselves returned to countries where they don't speak the language and have no contacts or support systems. As "aggravated felons" they are automatically detained and deported (exiled for life) without the opportunity to have an immigration judge review the facts of their case and make a reasonable judgement. The current laws need to be reversed to allow for judicial discretion. A "one size fits all" punishment of banishment is unjust and does not adhere to the principles upon which this country was founded.

by: Justin Fung

11-25-2009 @ 6:33pm

Actually, last year during the presidential campaign, then-Senator Obama visited the Crow Reservation in Montana. But your point is still well-made.

by: Police Car Auctions

06-26-2011 @ 1:56pm

Police Car Auctions...

I was wondering if you ever considered changing the structure of your site? Its very well written; I love what youve got to say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better. Youve got an awful lot of t...

by: ElrondPA

11-25-2009 @ 5:59pm

This article evades a discussion of why parents of U.S. citizen kids are being deported. Anyone born in the U.S., even of parents here illegally, is a citizen under the 14th Amendment. If Mr. Wallis thinks no parent of a U.S. citizen child should be deported, he is really saying either 1) there should be no limitation of any sort on immigration (number, criminal status, health, willingness to swear allegiance to the country, anything else) or 2) managing to deliver a baby in the U.S. means you get a free pass from any of the limitations on immigration that exist.

The honest and law-abiding thing for families of "mixed status" to do is to return to the country from which the parents came (together--no need for the family to be separated). At age 18, the children who have U.S. citizen status can choose for themselves to come here, legally (and potentially bring family members later as they are ready to sponsor them), or they can stay with their parents, legally.

I am not a "lock the doors and build a steel fence around the U.S." person. A certain level of immigration, involving both family reunification and those who seek economic opportunity and political freedom (including refugees), is healthy. But at the same time, we cannot accept every person who would like to come here and still have a society that is anything like the one we cherish.

by: lvnwrth

11-25-2009 @ 6:49pm

I am not without compassion for the children who suffer the consequences of their parents' poor decisions. And I do believe that as Christians we must work for more liberal immigration policies. HOWEVER, to legitimate the previous illegal activities of "undocumented residents" after the fact; or to expedite their citizenship process in any manner not available to any other applicant for immigration is not right.

Our choices have consequences. Requiring people to deal with the consequences of their previous bad decisions does not demonstrate a lack of grace or compassion.

by: jhutto77

11-25-2009 @ 5:15pm

Thanks for allowing me to express my short opinion.

Simply put, this Thanksgiving and every Thanksgiving, we should and must remember the millions of natives of this land decimated by the European settlers. The Trail of Tears that is still taking place on today's reservations. Our Thanksgiving is their genocide and not since Robert Kennedy has any Presidential candidate or Executive even bothered to visit a reservation. My heart goes out to them. Thank you.

J. Hutto, Sr.

by: lindsaykevan

11-25-2009 @ 8:05pm

Immigration is such a sensitive issue. My heart aches at the conundrum we all face. I have the privilege of working at a refugee resettlement agency. Each day I hear the stories of refugees who have fled their home countries in search for a place of solice. I am constantly faced with a tough question, what would I do for my own family if I were in such terrible situation as these people are? How far would I go? To what extent would I break laws, cross borders, or steal, just so that my family could survive. Would the line of morality blur in the face of such desperation. The phrase, "desperate times call for desperate measures," takes on a whole new meaning to me when I hear their stories. I have no idea what REAL desperation looks like. And I have to ask myself, depite the "illegality" of undocumented workers, if life in America would provide my family stability, a chance for a better life, would I take it myself? It's a question I thank God that I never have to actually ask and actually answer. One thing I do know, is that God loves the family unit. We weren't made to be alone. And I believe he rejoices when families are together and I believe he is saddened when they are separated. I guess the question we all need to wrestle with is, "what is the greater law/principal/commandment?" Jesus asked this question of his followers and hearers often. Is is lawful to work on the Sabbath? Is it lawful to heal on the Sabbath? "Which is lawful on the Sabbath: to do good or to do evil, to save life or to kill?"(Mark 3:4) I really don't claim to have the answer. God's word also says we are to respect the rulers and government in authority. Hence our conundrum... The whole reason I wanted to post was actually to send a link to a news site.
http://www.ktvb.com/news/local/A-First-Thanksgi....
A lovely church in my town hosts a Thanksgiving Dinner for newly arrived Refugees that we resettle each year. It's a nice reminder that like them, our ancestors came to America for a new life too at one time. And like them, these refugees are Thankful to be in America and to be alive. I hope the story is one that touches your hearts as it touches mine. Happy Thanksgiving Sojourners Community.

by: talitha_koum

11-25-2009 @ 8:25pm

You highlight a subtext of the immigration debate beautifully lindsaykevan. All of us, before judging those who choose to immigrate illegally, must ask, "what would I be prepared to do to ensure my children were safe and healthy?". Until we have fled war-torn nations, knowing we may never see our extended family or ancestral homes again, our judgement (all too often couched in comfort, security and peace) should be covered by grace.

by: WaveTossed

11-25-2009 @ 8:55pm

From the article: the key point:

"Long backlogs in our nation's family immigration system

by: Justin Fung

11-25-2009 @ 6:33pm

Actually, last year during the presidential campaign, then-Senator Obama visited the Crow Reservation in Montana. But your point is still well-made.

by: ElrondPA

11-25-2009 @ 5:59pm

This article evades a discussion of why parents of U.S. citizen kids are being deported. Anyone born in the U.S., even of parents here illegally, is a citizen under the 14th Amendment. If Mr. Wallis thinks no parent of a U.S. citizen child should be deported, he is really saying either 1) there should be no limitation of any sort on immigration (number, criminal status, health, willingness to swear allegiance to the country, anything else) or 2) managing to deliver a baby in the U.S. means you get a free pass from any of the limitations on immigration that exist.

The honest and law-abiding thing for families of "mixed status" to do is to return to the country from which the parents came (together--no need for the family to be separated). At age 18, the children who have U.S. citizen status can choose for themselves to come here, legally (and potentially bring family members later as they are ready to sponsor them), or they can stay with their parents, legally.

I am not a "lock the doors and build a steel fence around the U.S." person. A certain level of immigration, involving both family reunification and those who seek economic opportunity and political freedom (including refugees), is healthy. But at the same time, we cannot accept every person who would like to come here and still have a society that is anything like the one we cherish.

by: melodyhanson

11-25-2009 @ 9:59pm

I would like to help. what can I do? I live in Madison, WI and have often thought I'd like to help refugees or those settling here, but I don't know where to start and what would be most helpful? My time volunteering, my money? Thanks.

by: tegaderm

05-13-2011 @ 12:42pm

tegaderm medical gear...

I would like to get as many links to my site as posible, rite now this is what I am doing!...

by: lvnwrth

11-25-2009 @ 6:49pm

I am not without compassion for the children who suffer the consequences of their parents' poor decisions. And I do believe that as Christians we must work for more liberal immigration policies. HOWEVER, to legitimate the previous illegal activities of "undocumented residents" after the fact; or to expedite their citizenship process in any manner not available to any other applicant for immigration is not right.

Our choices have consequences. Requiring people to deal with the consequences of their previous bad decisions does not demonstrate a lack of grace or compassion.

by: Joe_Allen_Doty

11-26-2009 @ 12:21am

The man in the direct linage of my Cherokee genealogy left the Eastern Cherokee lands before the "Trail where we Cried" took place. He and other went to Arkansas first. I am in the same family tree as Will Rogers; he (actually his descendent's now) and I have the same Cherokee Chief as an ancestor.

Edward Doty was one of the Mayflower passengers; but, he was not a Pilgrim. He got man on the trip to pay his passage and he worked and an indentured servant to pay that off.

The Cherokees had a several day annual thanksgiving festival, commonly known in English as the "Green Corn Festival."

by: Joe_Allen_Doty

11-26-2009 @ 12:27am

What about the people who know in advance that they are going to be illegals before they leave their home countries?

They know that it is against the law of the USA to cross the border where there are no places to go through legal channels.

I don't have a problem with legal immigrants; but, I do with those who know that they will be breaking the law as soon as the cross the border.

You cannot use the Biblical example of aliens in Israel during Jesus time to support the law breakers. In Jesus day, folks who live in the countries of the Roman Empire didn't have to take documents with them when they crossed borders of countries.

by: lindsaykevan

11-25-2009 @ 8:05pm

Immigration is such a sensitive issue. My heart aches at the conundrum we all face. I have the privilege of working at a refugee resettlement agency. Each day I hear the stories of refugees who have fled their home countries in search for a place of solice. I am constantly faced with a tough question, what would I do for my own family if I were in such terrible situation as these people are? How far would I go? To what extent would I break laws, cross borders, or steal, just so that my family could survive. Would the line of morality blur in the face of such desperation. The phrase, "desperate times call for desperate measures," takes on a whole new meaning to me when I hear their stories. I have no idea what REAL desperation looks like. And I have to ask myself, depite the "illegality" of undocumented workers, if life in America would provide my family stability, a chance for a better life, would I take it myself? It's a question I thank God that I never have to actually ask and actually answer. One thing I do know, is that God loves the family unit. We weren't made to be alone. And I believe he rejoices when families are together and I believe he is saddened when they are separated. I guess the question we all need to wrestle with is, "what is the greater law/principal/commandment?" Jesus asked this question of his followers and hearers often. Is is lawful to work on the Sabbath? Is it lawful to heal on the Sabbath? "Which is lawful on the Sabbath: to do good or to do evil, to save life or to kill?"(Mark 3:4) I really don't claim to have the answer. God's word also says we are to respect the rulers and government in authority. Hence our conundrum... The whole reason I wanted to post was actually to send a link to a news site.
http://www.ktvb.com/news/local/A-First-Thanksgi....
A lovely church in my town hosts a Thanksgiving Dinner for newly arrived Refugees that we resettle each year. It's a nice reminder that like them, our ancestors came to America for a new life too at one time. And like them, these refugees are Thankful to be in America and to be alive. I hope the story is one that touches your hearts as it touches mine. Happy Thanksgiving Sojourners Community.

by: talitha_koum

11-25-2009 @ 8:25pm

You highlight a subtext of the immigration debate beautifully lindsaykevan. All of us, before judging those who choose to immigrate illegally, must ask, "what would I be prepared to do to ensure my children were safe and healthy?". Until we have fled war-torn nations, knowing we may never see our extended family or ancestral homes again, our judgement (all too often couched in comfort, security and peace) should be covered by grace.

by: ElrondPA

11-26-2009 @ 1:54am

It's really easy to just tar people who disagree with you with a nativist (subtext: racist) brush; it means you don't have to deal honestly with the arguments they're making. Legal immigration is happening in droves; in the last couple of decades, it has actually been occurring at a rate higher than even the "golden age" of immigration in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The backlogs are happening because, no matter how many people we permit to come in, far more still want to come in. People around the world understand that the U.S. is a land of opportunity and freedom, and they want to participate in that. And that's great; but we can only absorb so many at a time. There are only so many jobs available, so much housing, so many English teachers, etc. And that's the reason for putting limits on immigration (not to mention keeping out people who want to do us harm; should Osama bin Laden be permitted to send his friends and family over, too?).

It's easy for upper-middle-class people with college degrees to say, "Sure, we'll find jobs and space for them all." But those with limited income and skills look at the wave of immigrants and legitimately see them as competition for the jobs, apartments, and other aspects of life that they're struggling for. That's all the more true as unemployment tops 10%. Probably the majority of Haitians would move to the U.S. if they had a chance; does anyone honestly think we could absorb 5 million destitute people and provide them with anything close to an American-style life all at once?

by: WaveTossed

11-25-2009 @ 8:55pm

From the article: the key point:

"Long backlogs in our nation's family immigration system

by: melodyhanson

11-25-2009 @ 9:59pm

I would like to help. what can I do? I live in Madison, WI and have often thought I'd like to help refugees or those settling here, but I don't know where to start and what would be most helpful? My time volunteering, my money? Thanks.

by: Joe_Allen_Doty

11-26-2009 @ 12:21am

The man in the direct linage of my Cherokee genealogy left the Eastern Cherokee lands before the "Trail where we Cried" took place. He and other went to Arkansas first. I am in the same family tree as Will Rogers; he (actually his descendent's now) and I have the same Cherokee Chief as an ancestor.

Edward Doty was one of the Mayflower passengers; but, he was not a Pilgrim. He got man on the trip to pay his passage and he worked and an indentured servant to pay that off.

The Cherokees had a several day annual thanksgiving festival, commonly known in English as the "Green Corn Festival."

by: Joe_Allen_Doty

11-26-2009 @ 12:27am

What about the people who know in advance that they are going to be illegals before they leave their home countries?

They know that it is against the law of the USA to cross the border where there are no places to go through legal channels.

I don't have a problem with legal immigrants; but, I do with those who know that they will be breaking the law as soon as the cross the border.

You cannot use the Biblical example of aliens in Israel during Jesus time to support the law breakers. In Jesus day, folks who live in the countries of the Roman Empire didn't have to take documents with them when they crossed borders of countries.

by: GlenPeterson

11-26-2009 @ 2:43pm

Melody, I am glad to see your blog. I am sure that Justin Fung will chime in here with some specifics, but until then, check out this site: http://faithandimmigration.org/ a product of Sojourners. There is so much we can and need to do this coming year. Blessings.

by: ElrondPA

11-26-2009 @ 1:54am

It's really easy to just tar people who disagree with you with a nativist (subtext: racist) brush; it means you don't have to deal honestly with the arguments they're making. Legal immigration is happening in droves; in the last couple of decades, it has actually been occurring at a rate higher than even the "golden age" of immigration in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The backlogs are happening because, no matter how many people we permit to come in, far more still want to come in. People around the world understand that the U.S. is a land of opportunity and freedom, and they want to participate in that. And that's great; but we can only absorb so many at a time. There are only so many jobs available, so much housing, so many English teachers, etc. And that's the reason for putting limits on immigration (not to mention keeping out people who want to do us harm; should Osama bin Laden be permitted to send his friends and family over, too?).

It's easy for upper-middle-class people with college degrees to say, "Sure, we'll find jobs and space for them all." But those with limited income and skills look at the wave of immigrants and legitimately see them as competition for the jobs, apartments, and other aspects of life that they're struggling for. That's all the more true as unemployment tops 10%. Probably the majority of Haitians would move to the U.S. if they had a chance; does anyone honestly think we could absorb 5 million destitute people and provide them with anything close to an American-style life all at once?

by: WaveTossed

11-26-2009 @ 5:58pm

Check out this information from a free-market organization: Cato Institute. This is the most sane informtion I've ever seen about the issue of immigration.

http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=3638

by: WaveTossed

11-26-2009 @ 6:04pm

I'll refer you to the same link that I have referred others to. It speaks directly on the issue of illegal immigration.

http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=3638

by: GlenPeterson

11-26-2009 @ 2:43pm

Melody, I am glad to see your blog. I am sure that Justin Fung will chime in here with some specifics, but until then, check out this site: http://faithandimmigration.org/ a product of Sojourners. There is so much we can and need to do this coming year. Blessings.

by: WaveTossed

11-26-2009 @ 5:58pm

Check out this information from a free-market organization: Cato Institute. This is the most sane informtion I've ever seen about the issue of immigration.

http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=3638

by: WaveTossed

11-26-2009 @ 6:04pm

I'll refer you to the same link that I have referred others to. It speaks directly on the issue of illegal immigration.

http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=3638

by: nissan canada

07-19-2011 @ 7:13am

nissan z350...

Awesome post, I've linked back to your blog here http://www.vwsuv.net/sites-we-like/ return the favor if you can, thanks!...

by: MManatee

11-28-2009 @ 1:21am

Well said.

by: eye exercises to improve eyesight

06-21-2011 @ 5:33pm

For Your Information...

Im new to websites and just found out about trackbacks, which I venture is a means for me to recognize your internet site through a linkback through my site. I ran across your web site in the "currently buzzing" segment of one of the bookmarking sit...

by: Mennoman

11-28-2009 @ 4:12am

"You cannot use the Biblical example of aliens in Israel during Jesus time to support the law breakers. In Jesus day, folks who live in the countries of the Roman Empire didn't have to take documents with them when they crossed borders of countries." Joe Allen Doty

I think you are right. Since the Bible was written 2000 years ago for people living in a different time and context, it is largely obsolete. That is why we have science, philosophy, and myriad of other sources of knowledge to derive a human ethic that reflects the Spirit of Christ.

Few posts on this subject have been written with the eloquence displayed in Lindsaykevan's post above. I would be interested in your take on what Lindsaykevan states.

by: betsydewitt

11-28-2009 @ 2:25pm

Many of the deported parents of U.S. citizen children were legal permanent residents deported for convictions defined as aggravated felonies ( a very broad definition that includes some misdemeanors). Many of these parents have lived in the U.S. for the majority of their lives and now find themselves returned to countries where they don't speak the language and have no contacts or support systems. As "aggravated felons" they are automatically detained and deported (exiled for life) without the opportunity to have an immigration judge review the facts of their case and make a reasonable judgement. The current laws need to be reversed to allow for judicial discretion. A "one size fits all" punishment of banishment is unjust and does not adhere to the principles upon which this country was founded.

by: MManatee

11-28-2009 @ 1:21am

Well said.

by: Monte_Asbury

11-28-2009 @ 4:21pm

It was, of course, the breaking of laws for the purpose of showing mercy that first aroused anger toward Jesus. What right has the USA to expect obedience from us to laws that, similarly, would prevent mercy? Is Jesus Lord, or Caesar?

by: Mennoman

11-28-2009 @ 4:12am

"You cannot use the Biblical example of aliens in Israel during Jesus time to support the law breakers. In Jesus day, folks who live in the countries of the Roman Empire didn't have to take documents with them when they crossed borders of countries." Joe Allen Doty

I think you are right. Since the Bible was written 2000 years ago for people living in a different time and context, it is largely obsolete. That is why we have science, philosophy, and myriad of other sources of knowledge to derive a human ethic that reflects the Spirit of Christ.

Few posts on this subject have been written with the eloquence displayed in Lindsaykevan's post above. I would be interested in your take on what Lindsaykevan states.

by: betsydewitt

11-28-2009 @ 2:25pm

Many of the deported parents of U.S. citizen children were legal permanent residents deported for convictions defined as aggravated felonies ( a very broad definition that includes some misdemeanors). Many of these parents have lived in the U.S. for the majority of their lives and now find themselves returned to countries where they don't speak the language and have no contacts or support systems. As "aggravated felons" they are automatically detained and deported (exiled for life) without the opportunity to have an immigration judge review the facts of their case and make a reasonable judgement. The current laws need to be reversed to allow for judicial discretion. A "one size fits all" punishment of banishment is unjust and does not adhere to the principles upon which this country was founded.

by: Monte_Asbury

11-28-2009 @ 4:21pm

It was, of course, the breaking of laws for the purpose of showing mercy that first aroused anger toward Jesus. What right has the USA to expect obedience from us to laws that, similarly, would prevent mercy? Is Jesus Lord, or Caesar?

by: Monte_Asbury

11-28-2009 @ 6:21pm

It was, of course, the breaking of laws for the purpose of showing mercy that first aroused anger toward Jesus. What right has the USA to expect obedience from his followers to laws that, similarly, would prevent mercy?

Is Jesus Lord, or is Caesar?

by: betsydewitt

11-28-2009 @ 4:25pm

Many of the deported parents of U.S. citizen children were legal permanent residents deported for convictions defined as aggravated felonies ( a very broad definition that includes some misdemeanors). Many of these parents have lived in the U.S. for the majority of their lives and now find themselves returned to countries where they don't speak the language and have no contacts or support systems. As "aggravated felons" they are automatically detained and deported (exiled for life) without the opportunity to have an immigration judge review the facts of their case and make a reasonable judgement. The current laws need to be reversed to allow for judicial discretion. A "one size fits all" punishment of banishment is unjust and does not adhere to the principles upon which this country was founded.

by: sunless tanner

07-18-2011 @ 4:42pm

I just linked to your site...

Im inexperienced to blogs and recently learnt about trackbacks, which I reckon is a way for me to recognize your website through a linkback through my blog. I ran into your web site in the "currently buzzing" segment of one of the bookmarking sites ...

by: Butler Auto Auction

07-30-2011 @ 12:02am

Butler Auto Auction...

Hi! Quick question that's completely off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My web site looks weird when browsing from my iphone4. I'm trying to find a theme or plugin that might be able to correct this problem. If you have any...

by: Fix

08-03-2011 @ 3:23am

Must...

[

by: bielizna damska

07-19-2011 @ 9:46am

bielizna sklep...

This design is incredible! You definitely know how to keep a reader entertained. Between your wit and your videos, I was almost moved to start my own blog (well, almost...HaHa!) Excellent job. I really loved what you had to say, and more than that, how...

by: Flash Factory

06-17-2011 @ 12:15am

Web Site Builders Says It's An Incredible Article Cool!...

Wonderful info, thought I could add a few not related posts, yet still worth having a look......

Comments sorted by highest rated. After voting you must refresh your page to see the sort order change.

by: jhutto77

11-25-2009 @ 5:15pm

Thanks for allowing me to express my short opinion.

Simply put, this Thanksgiving and every Thanksgiving, we should and must remember the millions of natives of this land decimated by the European settlers. The Trail of Tears that is still taking place on today's reservations. Our Thanksgiving is their genocide and not since Robert Kennedy has any Presidential candidate or Executive even bothered to visit a reservation. My heart goes out to them. Thank you.

J. Hutto, Sr.

by: jhutto77

11-25-2009 @ 5:15pm

Thanks for allowing me to express my short opinion.

Simply put, this Thanksgiving and every Thanksgiving, we should and must remember the millions of natives of this land decimated by the European settlers. The Trail of Tears that is still taking place on today's reservations. Our Thanksgiving is their genocide and not since Robert Kennedy has any Presidential candidate or Executive even bothered to visit a reservation. My heart goes out to them. Thank you.

J. Hutto, Sr.

by: ElrondPA

11-25-2009 @ 5:59pm

This article evades a discussion of why parents of U.S. citizen kids are being deported. Anyone born in the U.S., even of parents here illegally, is a citizen under the 14th Amendment. If Mr. Wallis thinks no parent of a U.S. citizen child should be deported, he is really saying either 1) there should be no limitation of any sort on immigration (number, criminal status, health, willingness to swear allegiance to the country, anything else) or 2) managing to deliver a baby in the U.S. means you get a free pass from any of the limitations on immigration that exist.

The honest and law-abiding thing for families of "mixed status" to do is to return to the country from which the parents came (together--no need for the family to be separated). At age 18, the children who have U.S. citizen status can choose for themselves to come here, legally (and potentially bring family members later as they are ready to sponsor them), or they can stay with their parents, legally.

I am not a "lock the doors and build a steel fence around the U.S." person. A certain level of immigration, involving both family reunification and those who seek economic opportunity and political freedom (including refugees), is healthy. But at the same time, we cannot accept every person who would like to come here and still have a society that is anything like the one we cherish.

by: ElrondPA

11-25-2009 @ 5:59pm

This article evades a discussion of why parents of U.S. citizen kids are being deported. Anyone born in the U.S., even of parents here illegally, is a citizen under the 14th Amendment. If Mr. Wallis thinks no parent of a U.S. citizen child should be deported, he is really saying either 1) there should be no limitation of any sort on immigration (number, criminal status, health, willingness to swear allegiance to the country, anything else) or 2) managing to deliver a baby in the U.S. means you get a free pass from any of the limitations on immigration that exist.

The honest and law-abiding thing for families of "mixed status" to do is to return to the country from which the parents came (together--no need for the family to be separated). At age 18, the children who have U.S. citizen status can choose for themselves to come here, legally (and potentially bring family members later as they are ready to sponsor them), or they can stay with their parents, legally.

I am not a "lock the doors and build a steel fence around the U.S." person. A certain level of immigration, involving both family reunification and those who seek economic opportunity and political freedom (including refugees), is healthy. But at the same time, we cannot accept every person who would like to come here and still have a society that is anything like the one we cherish.

by: Justin Fung

11-25-2009 @ 6:33pm

Actually, last year during the presidential campaign, then-Senator Obama visited the Crow Reservation in Montana. But your point is still well-made.

by: Justin Fung

11-25-2009 @ 6:33pm

Actually, last year during the presidential campaign, then-Senator Obama visited the Crow Reservation in Montana. But your point is still well-made.

by: lvnwrth

11-25-2009 @ 6:49pm

I am not without compassion for the children who suffer the consequences of their parents' poor decisions. And I do believe that as Christians we must work for more liberal immigration policies. HOWEVER, to legitimate the previous illegal activities of "undocumented residents" after the fact; or to expedite their citizenship process in any manner not available to any other applicant for immigration is not right.

Our choices have consequences. Requiring people to deal with the consequences of their previous bad decisions does not demonstrate a lack of grace or compassion.

by: lvnwrth

11-25-2009 @ 6:49pm

I am not without compassion for the children who suffer the consequences of their parents' poor decisions. And I do believe that as Christians we must work for more liberal immigration policies. HOWEVER, to legitimate the previous illegal activities of "undocumented residents" after the fact; or to expedite their citizenship process in any manner not available to any other applicant for immigration is not right.

Our choices have consequences. Requiring people to deal with the consequences of their previous bad decisions does not demonstrate a lack of grace or compassion.

by: lindsaykevan

11-25-2009 @ 8:05pm

Immigration is such a sensitive issue. My heart aches at the conundrum we all face. I have the privilege of working at a refugee resettlement agency. Each day I hear the stories of refugees who have fled their home countries in search for a place of solice. I am constantly faced with a tough question, what would I do for my own family if I were in such terrible situation as these people are? How far would I go? To what extent would I break laws, cross borders, or steal, just so that my family could survive. Would the line of morality blur in the face of such desperation. The phrase, "desperate times call for desperate measures," takes on a whole new meaning to me when I hear their stories. I have no idea what REAL desperation looks like. And I have to ask myself, depite the "illegality" of undocumented workers, if life in America would provide my family stability, a chance for a better life, would I take it myself? It's a question I thank God that I never have to actually ask and actually answer. One thing I do know, is that God loves the family unit. We weren't made to be alone. And I believe he rejoices when families are together and I believe he is saddened when they are separated. I guess the question we all need to wrestle with is, "what is the greater law/principal/commandment?" Jesus asked this question of his followers and hearers often. Is is lawful to work on the Sabbath? Is it lawful to heal on the Sabbath? "Which is lawful on the Sabbath: to do good or to do evil, to save life or to kill?"(Mark 3:4) I really don't claim to have the answer. God's word also says we are to respect the rulers and government in authority. Hence our conundrum... The whole reason I wanted to post was actually to send a link to a news site.
http://www.ktvb.com/news/local/A-First-Thanksgi....
A lovely church in my town hosts a Thanksgiving Dinner for newly arrived Refugees that we resettle each year. It's a nice reminder that like them, our ancestors came to America for a new life too at one time. And like them, these refugees are Thankful to be in America and to be alive. I hope the story is one that touches your hearts as it touches mine. Happy Thanksgiving Sojourners Community.

by: lindsaykevan

11-25-2009 @ 8:05pm

Immigration is such a sensitive issue. My heart aches at the conundrum we all face. I have the privilege of working at a refugee resettlement agency. Each day I hear the stories of refugees who have fled their home countries in search for a place of solice. I am constantly faced with a tough question, what would I do for my own family if I were in such terrible situation as these people are? How far would I go? To what extent would I break laws, cross borders, or steal, just so that my family could survive. Would the line of morality blur in the face of such desperation. The phrase, "desperate times call for desperate measures," takes on a whole new meaning to me when I hear their stories. I have no idea what REAL desperation looks like. And I have to ask myself, depite the "illegality" of undocumented workers, if life in America would provide my family stability, a chance for a better life, would I take it myself? It's a question I thank God that I never have to actually ask and actually answer. One thing I do know, is that God loves the family unit. We weren't made to be alone. And I believe he rejoices when families are together and I believe he is saddened when they are separated. I guess the question we all need to wrestle with is, "what is the greater law/principal/commandment?" Jesus asked this question of his followers and hearers often. Is is lawful to work on the Sabbath? Is it lawful to heal on the Sabbath? "Which is lawful on the Sabbath: to do good or to do evil, to save life or to kill?"(Mark 3:4) I really don't claim to have the answer. God's word also says we are to respect the rulers and government in authority. Hence our conundrum... The whole reason I wanted to post was actually to send a link to a news site.
http://www.ktvb.com/news/local/A-First-Thanksgi....
A lovely church in my town hosts a Thanksgiving Dinner for newly arrived Refugees that we resettle each year. It's a nice reminder that like them, our ancestors came to America for a new life too at one time. And like them, these refugees are Thankful to be in America and to be alive. I hope the story is one that touches your hearts as it touches mine. Happy Thanksgiving Sojourners Community.

by: talitha_koum

11-25-2009 @ 8:25pm

You highlight a subtext of the immigration debate beautifully lindsaykevan. All of us, before judging those who choose to immigrate illegally, must ask, "what would I be prepared to do to ensure my children were safe and healthy?". Until we have fled war-torn nations, knowing we may never see our extended family or ancestral homes again, our judgement (all too often couched in comfort, security and peace) should be covered by grace.

by: talitha_koum

11-25-2009 @ 8:25pm

You highlight a subtext of the immigration debate beautifully lindsaykevan. All of us, before judging those who choose to immigrate illegally, must ask, "what would I be prepared to do to ensure my children were safe and healthy?". Until we have fled war-torn nations, knowing we may never see our extended family or ancestral homes again, our judgement (all too often couched in comfort, security and peace) should be covered by grace.

by: WaveTossed

11-25-2009 @ 8:55pm

From the article: the key point:

"Long backlogs in our nation's family immigration system

by: WaveTossed

11-25-2009 @ 8:55pm

From the article: the key point:

"Long backlogs in our nation's family immigration system

by: melodyhanson

11-25-2009 @ 9:59pm

I would like to help. what can I do? I live in Madison, WI and have often thought I'd like to help refugees or those settling here, but I don't know where to start and what would be most helpful? My time volunteering, my money? Thanks.

by: melodyhanson

11-25-2009 @ 9:59pm

I would like to help. what can I do? I live in Madison, WI and have often thought I'd like to help refugees or those settling here, but I don't know where to start and what would be most helpful? My time volunteering, my money? Thanks.

by: Joe_Allen_Doty

11-26-2009 @ 12:21am

The man in the direct linage of my Cherokee genealogy left the Eastern Cherokee lands before the "Trail where we Cried" took place. He and other went to Arkansas first. I am in the same family tree as Will Rogers; he (actually his descendent's now) and I have the same Cherokee Chief as an ancestor.

Edward Doty was one of the Mayflower passengers; but, he was not a Pilgrim. He got man on the trip to pay his passage and he worked and an indentured servant to pay that off.

The Cherokees had a several day annual thanksgiving festival, commonly known in English as the "Green Corn Festival."

by: Joe_Allen_Doty

11-26-2009 @ 12:21am

The man in the direct linage of my Cherokee genealogy left the Eastern Cherokee lands before the "Trail where we Cried" took place. He and other went to Arkansas first. I am in the same family tree as Will Rogers; he (actually his descendent's now) and I have the same Cherokee Chief as an ancestor.

Edward Doty was one of the Mayflower passengers; but, he was not a Pilgrim. He got man on the trip to pay his passage and he worked and an indentured servant to pay that off.

The Cherokees had a several day annual thanksgiving festival, commonly known in English as the "Green Corn Festival."

by: Joe_Allen_Doty

11-26-2009 @ 12:27am

What about the people who know in advance that they are going to be illegals before they leave their home countries?

They know that it is against the law of the USA to cross the border where there are no places to go through legal channels.

I don't have a problem with legal immigrants; but, I do with those who know that they will be breaking the law as soon as the cross the border.

You cannot use the Biblical example of aliens in Israel during Jesus time to support the law breakers. In Jesus day, folks who live in the countries of the Roman Empire didn't have to take documents with them when they crossed borders of countries.

by: Joe_Allen_Doty

11-26-2009 @ 12:27am

What about the people who know in advance that they are going to be illegals before they leave their home countries?

They know that it is against the law of the USA to cross the border where there are no places to go through legal channels.

I don't have a problem with legal immigrants; but, I do with those who know that they will be breaking the law as soon as the cross the border.

You cannot use the Biblical example of aliens in Israel during Jesus time to support the law breakers. In Jesus day, folks who live in the countries of the Roman Empire didn't have to take documents with them when they crossed borders of countries.

by: ElrondPA

11-26-2009 @ 1:54am

It's really easy to just tar people who disagree with you with a nativist (subtext: racist) brush; it means you don't have to deal honestly with the arguments they're making. Legal immigration is happening in droves; in the last couple of decades, it has actually been occurring at a rate higher than even the "golden age" of immigration in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The backlogs are happening because, no matter how many people we permit to come in, far more still want to come in. People around the world understand that the U.S. is a land of opportunity and freedom, and they want to participate in that. And that's great; but we can only absorb so many at a time. There are only so many jobs available, so much housing, so many English teachers, etc. And that's the reason for putting limits on immigration (not to mention keeping out people who want to do us harm; should Osama bin Laden be permitted to send his friends and family over, too?).

It's easy for upper-middle-class people with college degrees to say, "Sure, we'll find jobs and space for them all." But those with limited income and skills look at the wave of immigrants and legitimately see them as competition for the jobs, apartments, and other aspects of life that they're struggling for. That's all the more true as unemployment tops 10%. Probably the majority of Haitians would move to the U.S. if they had a chance; does anyone honestly think we could absorb 5 million destitute people and provide them with anything close to an American-style life all at once?

by: ElrondPA

11-26-2009 @ 1:54am

It's really easy to just tar people who disagree with you with a nativist (subtext: racist) brush; it means you don't have to deal honestly with the arguments they're making. Legal immigration is happening in droves; in the last couple of decades, it has actually been occurring at a rate higher than even the "golden age" of immigration in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The backlogs are happening because, no matter how many people we permit to come in, far more still want to come in. People around the world understand that the U.S. is a land of opportunity and freedom, and they want to participate in that. And that's great; but we can only absorb so many at a time. There are only so many jobs available, so much housing, so many English teachers, etc. And that's the reason for putting limits on immigration (not to mention keeping out people who want to do us harm; should Osama bin Laden be permitted to send his friends and family over, too?).

It's easy for upper-middle-class people with college degrees to say, "Sure, we'll find jobs and space for them all." But those with limited income and skills look at the wave of immigrants and legitimately see them as competition for the jobs, apartments, and other aspects of life that they're struggling for. That's all the more true as unemployment tops 10%. Probably the majority of Haitians would move to the U.S. if they had a chance; does anyone honestly think we could absorb 5 million destitute people and provide them with anything close to an American-style life all at once?

by: GlenPeterson

11-26-2009 @ 2:43pm

Melody, I am glad to see your blog. I am sure that Justin Fung will chime in here with some specifics, but until then, check out this site: http://faithandimmigration.org/ a product of Sojourners. There is so much we can and need to do this coming year. Blessings.

by: GlenPeterson

11-26-2009 @ 2:43pm

Melody, I am glad to see your blog. I am sure that Justin Fung will chime in here with some specifics, but until then, check out this site: http://faithandimmigration.org/ a product of Sojourners. There is so much we can and need to do this coming year. Blessings.

by: WaveTossed

11-26-2009 @ 5:58pm

Check out this information from a free-market organization: Cato Institute. This is the most sane informtion I've ever seen about the issue of immigration.

http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=3638

by: WaveTossed

11-26-2009 @ 5:58pm

Check out this information from a free-market organization: Cato Institute. This is the most sane informtion I've ever seen about the issue of immigration.

http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=3638

by: WaveTossed

11-26-2009 @ 6:04pm

I'll refer you to the same link that I have referred others to. It speaks directly on the issue of illegal immigration.

http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=3638

by: WaveTossed

11-26-2009 @ 6:04pm

I'll refer you to the same link that I have referred others to. It speaks directly on the issue of illegal immigration.

http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=3638

by: MManatee

11-28-2009 @ 1:21am

Well said.

by: MManatee

11-28-2009 @ 1:21am

Well said.

by: Mennoman

11-28-2009 @ 4:12am

"You cannot use the Biblical example of aliens in Israel during Jesus time to support the law breakers. In Jesus day, folks who live in the countries of the Roman Empire didn't have to take documents with them when they crossed borders of countries." Joe Allen Doty

I think you are right. Since the Bible was written 2000 years ago for people living in a different time and context, it is largely obsolete. That is why we have science, philosophy, and myriad of other sources of knowledge to derive a human ethic that reflects the Spirit of Christ.

Few posts on this subject have been written with the eloquence displayed in Lindsaykevan's post above. I would be interested in your take on what Lindsaykevan states.

by: Mennoman

11-28-2009 @ 4:12am

"You cannot use the Biblical example of aliens in Israel during Jesus time to support the law breakers. In Jesus day, folks who live in the countries of the Roman Empire didn't have to take documents with them when they crossed borders of countries." Joe Allen Doty

I think you are right. Since the Bible was written 2000 years ago for people living in a different time and context, it is largely obsolete. That is why we have science, philosophy, and myriad of other sources of knowledge to derive a human ethic that reflects the Spirit of Christ.

Few posts on this subject have been written with the eloquence displayed in Lindsaykevan's post above. I would be interested in your take on what Lindsaykevan states.

by: betsydewitt

11-28-2009 @ 2:25pm

Many of the deported parents of U.S. citizen children were legal permanent residents deported for convictions defined as aggravated felonies ( a very broad definition that includes some misdemeanors). Many of these parents have lived in the U.S. for the majority of their lives and now find themselves returned to countries where they don't speak the language and have no contacts or support systems. As "aggravated felons" they are automatically detained and deported (exiled for life) without the opportunity to have an immigration judge review the facts of their case and make a reasonable judgement. The current laws need to be reversed to allow for judicial discretion. A "one size fits all" punishment of banishment is unjust and does not adhere to the principles upon which this country was founded.

by: betsydewitt

11-28-2009 @ 2:25pm

Many of the deported parents of U.S. citizen children were legal permanent residents deported for convictions defined as aggravated felonies ( a very broad definition that includes some misdemeanors). Many of these parents have lived in the U.S. for the majority of their lives and now find themselves returned to countries where they don't speak the language and have no contacts or support systems. As "aggravated felons" they are automatically detained and deported (exiled for life) without the opportunity to have an immigration judge review the facts of their case and make a reasonable judgement. The current laws need to be reversed to allow for judicial discretion. A "one size fits all" punishment of banishment is unjust and does not adhere to the principles upon which this country was founded.

by: Monte_Asbury

11-28-2009 @ 4:21pm

It was, of course, the breaking of laws for the purpose of showing mercy that first aroused anger toward Jesus. What right has the USA to expect obedience from us to laws that, similarly, would prevent mercy? Is Jesus Lord, or Caesar?

by: Monte_Asbury

11-28-2009 @ 4:21pm

It was, of course, the breaking of laws for the purpose of showing mercy that first aroused anger toward Jesus. What right has the USA to expect obedience from us to laws that, similarly, would prevent mercy? Is Jesus Lord, or Caesar?

by: betsydewitt

11-28-2009 @ 4:25pm

Many of the deported parents of U.S. citizen children were legal permanent residents deported for convictions defined as aggravated felonies ( a very broad definition that includes some misdemeanors). Many of these parents have lived in the U.S. for the majority of their lives and now find themselves returned to countries where they don't speak the language and have no contacts or support systems. As "aggravated felons" they are automatically detained and deported (exiled for life) without the opportunity to have an immigration judge review the facts of their case and make a reasonable judgement. The current laws need to be reversed to allow for judicial discretion. A "one size fits all" punishment of banishment is unjust and does not adhere to the principles upon which this country was founded.

by: betsydewitt

11-28-2009 @ 4:25pm

Many of the deported parents of U.S. citizen children were legal permanent residents deported for convictions defined as aggravated felonies ( a very broad definition that includes some misdemeanors). Many of these parents have lived in the U.S. for the majority of their lives and now find themselves returned to countries where they don't speak the language and have no contacts or support systems. As "aggravated felons" they are automatically detained and deported (exiled for life) without the opportunity to have an immigration judge review the facts of their case and make a reasonable judgement. The current laws need to be reversed to allow for judicial discretion. A "one size fits all" punishment of banishment is unjust and does not adhere to the principles upon which this country was founded.

by: Monte_Asbury

11-28-2009 @ 6:21pm

It was, of course, the breaking of laws for the purpose of showing mercy that first aroused anger toward Jesus. What right has the USA to expect obedience from his followers to laws that, similarly, would prevent mercy?

Is Jesus Lord, or is Caesar?

by: Monte_Asbury

11-28-2009 @ 6:21pm

It was, of course, the breaking of laws for the purpose of showing mercy that first aroused anger toward Jesus. What right has the USA to expect obedience from his followers to laws that, similarly, would prevent mercy?

Is Jesus Lord, or is Caesar?

by: Treasure Hunters Roadshow

05-13-2011 @ 11:55am

cool!...

[..]So I checked out this amazing site today!![..]...

by: tegaderm

05-13-2011 @ 12:42pm

tegaderm medical gear...

I would like to get as many links to my site as posible, rite now this is what I am doing!...

by: Taylor Lautner Workout

05-16-2011 @ 2:12am

Taylor Lautner Workout...

Also you might wanna' check out this blog I found here......

by: Flash Factory

06-17-2011 @ 12:15am

Web Site Builders Says It's An Incredible Article Cool!...

Wonderful info, thought I could add a few not related posts, yet still worth having a look......

by: eye exercises to improve eyesight

06-21-2011 @ 5:33pm

For Your Information...

Im new to websites and just found out about trackbacks, which I venture is a means for me to recognize your internet site through a linkback through my site. I ran across your web site in the "currently buzzing" segment of one of the bookmarking sit...

by: Police Car Auctions

06-26-2011 @ 1:56pm

Police Car Auctions...

I was wondering if you ever considered changing the structure of your site? Its very well written; I love what youve got to say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better. Youve got an awful lot of t...

by: registry cleaners

07-04-2011 @ 8:35am

registry cleaners...

Hi there! This is kind of off topic but I need some help from an established blog. Is it very hard to set up your own blog? I'm not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty quick. I'm thinking about making my own but I'm not sure where to s...

by: sunless tanner

07-18-2011 @ 4:42pm

I just linked to your site...

Im inexperienced to blogs and recently learnt about trackbacks, which I reckon is a way for me to recognize your website through a linkback through my blog. I ran into your web site in the "currently buzzing" segment of one of the bookmarking sites ...

by: nissan canada

07-19-2011 @ 7:13am

nissan z350...

Awesome post, I've linked back to your blog here http://www.vwsuv.net/sites-we-like/ return the favor if you can, thanks!...

by: bielizna damska

07-19-2011 @ 9:46am

bielizna sklep...

This design is incredible! You definitely know how to keep a reader entertained. Between your wit and your videos, I was almost moved to start my own blog (well, almost...HaHa!) Excellent job. I really loved what you had to say, and more than that, how...