Get E-Mail Updates

Tell Glenn Beck: I'm a Social Justice Christian

Glenn Beck says Christians should leave churches that use the word "social justice." He says social justice is a code word for communism and Nazism.

Related Reading

Take Action on This Issue

Tell the Senate: Don't Cut International Aid

Please join us in telling the Senate: Protect foreign aid programs that help the poor and the needy. 

But since the Catholic Church, the Black Churches, the Mainline Protestant churches, and more and more Evangelical and Pentecostal churches including Hispanic and Asian-American congregations all consider social justice central to biblical faith, Glenn Beck is telling all those Christians to leave their churches. Of course, Christians may disagree about what social justice means in our current political context -- and that conversation is an important one -- but the Bible is clear: from the Mosaic law of Jubilee, to the Hebrew prophets, to Jesus Christ, social justice is an integral part of God's plan for humanity.

Beck says Christians should leave their social justice churches, so I say Christians should leave Glenn Beck. I don't know if Beck is just strange, just trying to be controversial, or just trying to make money. But in any case, what he has said attacks the very heart of our Christian faith, and Christians should no longer watch his show. His show should now be in the same category as Howard Stern. Stern practices pornography and Beck denies the central teachings of Jesus and the Bible. So Christians should stop watching the Glenn Beck show and pray for him and Howard Stern.

Beck also said that if his church was about "social justice" he would report his church to the church authorities. What authorities? Church bodies as diverse in their theology as the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops and the National Association of Evangelicals have explicitly endorsed social justice as a biblical imperative.

So here's an idea: how about reporting ourselves to Glenn Beck as church members and pastors who practice and preach social justice.

Since Sojourners' mission is "to articulate the biblical call to social justice," I'll be the first to turn myself in. And I invite you to join me in turning yourself in to Glenn Beck as a Christian who believes in social justice. Let's send him thousands of names.

portrait-jim-wallisJim Wallis is the author of Rediscovering Values: On Wall Street, Main Street, and Your Street -- A Moral Compass for the New Economy, CEO of Sojourners and blogs at www.godspolitics.com.

Sojourners relies on the support of readers like you to sustain our message and ministry.

by: Craig

03-12-2010 @ 12:17pm

This reminds me of Hitler's perversion of Christianity in Germany. Subtle at first, as the Nazis government consolidated it's power pastors and priest who continued to preach the Gospel were silenced by intimidation or imprisonment and fascist philosophy replaced scripture and the cult of Nordic gods, from ancient times and manipulated by Nazi propagandist, became the new state religion. It is a sad for Glen Beck that he has set the same course for the destruction of his soul, and sadder that he is twisting the teachings of Christ to drag down with him as many as he can.

by: raulgarcia

03-11-2010 @ 4:38pm

Were you in New Orleans when Katrina struck?

You horrendously fail to mention how our society is being entrenched by a new form of socialism called government sponsored capitalism.

You and your fellow Beckoids are completely blind to the underlying issues which are effecting this country the most and the only issue you are concerned with is protecting your own selfish ideologies.

by: ft4all

03-12-2010 @ 12:12pm

Social justice is an integral part of repentence. When people truly repent they stop mistreating their follow human beings. The heart of the message of the Gospel is love God and your neighbor as yourself? Furthermore, Jesus refered to "your neighbor" as that (unclean) Samaritan... Social justice is one of the true signs of repentence and being born again.

by: BuxomBess

03-12-2010 @ 2:33am

False. Glen Beck is not a Mormon apostle. You want a list of them? I can rattle them off to you. I can even sing it to a silly little kids tune. Mormonism is not inherently right-wing. There are a couple of political stances that the LDS church takes that are specifically right -wing. However, there are plenty of liberal ones as well. Look at immigration. Glenn Beck is a crazy person. I'm often embarrassed, as a Mormon, whenever he says he's LDS.

by: fundamentalist

03-11-2010 @ 4:33pm

lizdyer: "What church is using the term in the way that you claim Beck meant????"

The American Catholic Bishops Assoc., most Episcopalean churches, many Presbyterian and Methodist and a few Baptists.

by: ft4all

03-12-2010 @ 12:04pm

That email address me@glennbeck.com is firewalled. When we send him our message it automatically bounces back. There must be some other way to tell him our stand, but I doubt that he'll ever listen. Glenn is just another false prophet of the age. He has no concern for God and Christianity. It's all about fame and money...

by: johnrallison

03-15-2010 @ 12:22am

One piece of DATA that gives me pause is how closely the Genesis account matches what scientists believe to be true about the origins and development of the universe and life on earth. Most other creation stories have to do gods fighting or eggs breaking or something else that is clearly not meant to give information about origins but meaning about existence. But how did some nomadic clansman 1,500 or more years before Christ write of a creation that so closely follows the progression that we observe in the cosmological, earth, and biological sciences? It should make a thinking person think.

by: BuxomBess

03-12-2010 @ 2:24am

Glenn Beck is not a representative of the LDS faith. Though he is a member, to my eternal embarrassment as a Mormon, he is NOT a representative. The LDS church has not directed him to say any of his superbly insane or alarmingly offensive nonsense.

by: fundamentalist

03-11-2010 @ 4:29pm

"You don't need "supernatural powers," just a healthy skepticism, a willingness to dig deeper, an understanding of human nature and knowing what's at stake..."

Actually, that betrays a lack of imagination. One of the most important lessons I learned about human psychology came from a professor of literature at the University of Oklahoma. In one of his books on novel writing he had a chapter on motivation, specifically, how to provide believable motivations for you characters. He wrote that it is easy and not to sweat it. You just need imagination. He said you can take any character in any situation and provide plausible motivations for his actions if you try.

Most people are lazy and don't try. They impute evil motives to people they don't like and good ones to those they like. But with a little imagination, they could come up with dozens of different motivations, all equally believable.

Tip for guys: when your girl starts questioning your motives, you know she is no longer in love with you. The reason people say love is blind is because when we're in love we impute only good motives to the one we love.

by: Grace|Truth

03-12-2010 @ 12:00pm

The core message was "repent and believe," not social justice. He came
to save lost sinners.

But when the Bible speaks of justice it isn't about equal outcomes or
taking from one neighbor by force to help another neighbor. It is
about not being too hard or too easy on either the rich or the poor,
but being fair.

You pollution comment is a false dichotomy. I reduce/reuse/recycle and
drive hih mileage vehicles. I don't condone pollution. Of course we
should be good stewards. But that does not have anything to do with
the fraudulent AGW data and the profit/power/control motive of those
advancing that agenda.

Yes, Jesus spoke often of spiritual blindness. Some read the Bible and
completely miss the point about all of us being sinners in need of a
Savior and that He is the only way to salvation.

by: johnrallison

03-15-2010 @ 12:14am

I believe this is the definition of "prejudice" from Jocta:

My opinion of "Religious" mind-controlled robotic proselytizing cohorts, or their 'button-pushing' "Confessors" precludes my granting creditability to anything 'they' would have to offer, or say. The mere fact 'they' call themselves 'Christians" exposes their insidious gullibility, and lack of a rational mind!

by: david_henderson

03-12-2010 @ 2:24am

Just wondering if you use this same standard for all your TV and news watching. You state, "Beck denies the central teachings of Jesus and the Bible. So Christians should stop watching the Glenn Beck show."

If this is true, what news outlet would you suggest we watch? Do you only watch news shows where the reporter/ commentator affirms the central teachings of the bible? Of course you don't! So is it his beliefs OR IS IT HIS POLITICS that lead you to make this statement?

Wallis, it is so obvious the politics come first for you. Just as they do for many right wing evangelicals. Quit masquerading as a Jesus follower first.

by: PASTOR JEFF

03-12-2010 @ 10:39pm

Has your pastor ever preached from the prophets or the Magnificat?

by: prgrs_ev

03-11-2010 @ 4:29pm

I find it interesting that you are attempting to be an apologist for Beck...I think he would be better served with prayer and therapy, not necessarily in that order. I don't think Beck desires to be understood as much as he wants to his ego fortified with attention...of any ilk.

by: ravelmaster

03-12-2010 @ 11:51am

Really? Jesus came to tell us that we should use fair weights, proper punishments, and everyone who can work, should? Funny--I read the Bible daily. Are you honestly trying to say that this is the core of His message? And regarding global warming, we are stewards of the earth. Does it make any sense that we can pollute for generations with no adverse affects? Doesn't work that way with our own human bodies, or any other created thing. Jesus often spoke about people who were blind and refused to see, or had ears but would not hear.

by: steamboathunter

03-14-2010 @ 11:59pm

It's there Jeff, you just don't want to see it. Woe to those prophets who say peace, peace, when there is no peace.

by: PASTOR JEFF

03-12-2010 @ 2:09am

Does this mean we should starve the rich? Some of the hardest working people I know are the poor.

by: PASTOR JEFF

03-12-2010 @ 10:37pm

"I would say 99% of those on here didn't know what social justice was."

Wow! What can you say to that?

by: prgrs_ev

03-11-2010 @ 4:19pm

As I said in a previous blog entry, Ronald Reagan did his best work in "Bed Time for Bonzo"...enough said.

by: johnrallison

03-14-2010 @ 11:51pm

Jocta, I am a Christian and a physics teacher... you throw around the label "Christians" as though everyone who claims the identity of "Christian" has the same belief about everything, which is a ridiculous and closed minded notion. It's the same with many groups, though. African Americans get painted with whatever beliefs their "black leaders" talk about. Republicans. Democrats. Conservatives. Liberals. Jews. Muslims. None of these are monoliths. You do yourself a great disservice by the argumentative stance you take rather than discussing issues with others who see things differently. I like to think that I am a Christian who is not fighting to discredit science education, since I am involved in it.

Regarding 'religion,' the 'facts' as you say are undeniable. While several founding fathers/signers did not have much use for fundamentalist Christianity, you would be hard-pressed to find one that didn't at least subscribe to a sort of deism and a belief in something beyond the material world available to the observation of our bodily senses.

Here's the first few sentences of the Declaration of Independence, which reference a transcendent God twice:

-------------------------------------------
hen in the Course of human events it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature's God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the separation.

We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.
-------------------------------------

I have had some very good discussions on Richard Dawkins's web site. I have also had some brief conversations with highly bigoted and prejudiced individuals who completely write off anyone who doesn't buy into their materialist presuppositions as just stupid. Unfortunately for those people, they are missing out on some very enlightening discussion because people of great intelligence and learning have often come to the conclusion that while science needs to be approached as a materialist endeavor, materialism is quite unsatisfactory as a view of life, the universe and everything.

Materialism doesn't answer the question: where did we come from?

Materialism's answer to why we are is is: no reason at all.

Oh, I gotta go put my kids to bed...

by: donnambrown

03-12-2010 @ 10:25pm

How does he get to speak to Christians and advise them....HE IS A MORMON...WE ARE CALLED CHRISTIANS BECAUSE WE BELIEVE THAT JESUS CHRIST IS THE SON OF GOD WHO CAME IN THE FLESH TO DIE FOR THE SINS OF MEN AND WOMEN AND IF WE BELIEVE IN HIM WE WILL NOT PERISH BUT HAVE ETERNAL LIFE. Mormons believe Jesus was a mere prophet not unlike Joseph Smith.

by: lizdyer

03-11-2010 @ 4:13pm

If that is what he meant than why is he saying "run away" from churches who use the term. My church and many of my friends churches use the term and they mean "loving and caring for the poor, oppressed, marginalized" What church is using the term in the way that you claim Beck meant????

by: jocta

03-15-2010 @ 12:50am

-
-
You say: "I thought you were interested in dialogue."
-
I say: 'What' "dialogue" can you possibly offer?
-
Your 'warped' mind cannot even 'conceive' of 'life' without your makbelieve "God"?
-
You have not even acknowledged my response to your earlier 'false' assertions about "Social Justice"!
-
The only "dialogue" you could offer would be an effort to 'convert me' to your absurd 'way' of thinking!
-
I have provided you with enough material to arouse a logical,
"scientific", rational, 'person's' interest in facts relating to how the
lying assertions of the "Religious" 'Charlatans' enslaved you!
-
'You' mention "preconceived notion"?
-
My 'knowledge', and, the information I provide do not derive from any so-called "preconceived notions"! I deal inthoroughly 'researched'
FACTS!
-
Religion, and the outrageous LIES it is based on, is very easily determined to be FARCICAL! GOOGLE IT!
-
INFINITY REFUTES DIVINITY
THERE NEVER WAS NOTHING
UNIVERSE IS INFINITE
CREATOR IS SUPERFLUOUS
-
'You' are the one who is suffering from someone elses "preconceived notions" of how to hoodwink 'you' into believing fairytales are FACTS!
-
As I have said: intelligent, rational "Teachers" do not use "PORNOGRAPHY" to exemplify the "misapplication" of "LIERATURE"!
-
That "ID" garbage is, as you know, just another attempt to promote "Creationism"!
-
Do you also "Teach" "Creationism"?
-
I 'will' "TELL YOU" THIS: 'you' are NOT a "Science Teacher"!
-
No 'respectable' "Science Teacher" would ever even 'whisper' "ID" in a Science Classroom!
-
You need help!
-
I would FIRE YOU!
-
Mass/Energy never disappear
Ever were/ever here
Religion's polluton
Is no solution
For Darwin's Evolution
-
-
-

by: squeaky

03-12-2010 @ 10:22pm

So please clarify, then. Does God=country? If so, please explain why equating anything other than Jesus and the Holy Spirit with God is not idolatry. Seems there is a commandment about that...

"I believe you are in a box you've made for yourself."

And that box is...?

By the way, I note your e-mail address came up in your response to me on the comment thread. I think this is because you responded to me directly from your e-mail. You probably don't want your e-mail out there for the world to see (or maybe you do, IDK). It's probably better if you respond through the website rather than directly from your e-mail account (convenient as that is).

by: steamboathunter

03-14-2010 @ 2:10am

Dear Menno, there is a report in your bible under the title "Jonah" which tells us if it takes a whale and seaweed wrapped around one's neck, God won't hesitate to summon a whale. Paul was blinded by the presence of Jesus and remained visually impaired from that moment on, but his thorn kept him from sinning. Please read you bible and you will see hundreds of dealings with mankind from a loving God even if it means bleached by whale acid.

by: tomerickson

03-11-2010 @ 4:10pm

Blessings brother (or sister). You nailed it. Jesus loves "all" the little children. Wallis cannot claim the higher ground as long as he continues to support the evil in the life of Obama and his anti-life policies. I view it as turning your eyes away from a murderer as he does his work.

by: squeaky

03-15-2010 @ 12:38am

Oh yes, absolutely. I read quite a bit of Hugh Ross when I was first emerging from my Young Earth days, and he, in fact, says this is what led him to Christianity. I recently picked up the Genesis Enigma which will argue the same thing, but haven't really gotten far with it.

I'm comfortable with the Bible providing a summary of God's creative acts without the details of when, exactly, things happened, or how.

I'm also comfortable with the notion of it being an issue of literary styles that we are not familiar with. Have you ever read anything on the Framework hypothesis? It's pretty compelling, IMO.

Cheers!

by: tyhamantoday

03-12-2010 @ 2:53am

the atheists, gays and lesbians seem to be writing the polices of the day now.....and politicians are to scared to stand against them, so they back down...this is why the country is out of control, it all started when they took god out of the schools, and the devil walked right in.....and now look what is happening in this country thanks to legislation being wr4itten by the gays and atheists,and for the gay and atheists, and enacted by scarred politicians....if the supreme court would start looking at the spirit, when the constitution was written, they would not be allowing so much sinful legislation to pass by there robes, and plastered upon the American people. It is the gays and lesbians, and atheists that are destroying this country for there own self interest. Yes, the devil and his demons are alive and well in America.

by: Andrew Abrams Marchant-Shapiro

03-14-2010 @ 1:52am

Just a quick few:

1. I'm a Christian who happens to be a Mormon (like there are Christians who happen to be Catholic or Lutheran or...). Yes, the church I belong to is populated by a lot of political conservatives. But there are a lot of conservative Southern Baptists, too, if I recall correctly. Don't commit the fallacy of assuming that we're all the same. Pick any congregation of any church in the mountain west and you'll find conservatives--you might be surprised at what my ward here in Connecticut looks like from a political perspective!

2. Beck is not now, nor has he ever been, a Mormon "Apostle." He is a Mormon (more accurately, a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints). Not an Apostle. I don't know whether he holds any local calling in his ward or stake, but Apostle is a specific office within the LDS organization, and he is NOT one the Apostles.

3. Mormon church leaders have no more influence over the members than do Catholic leaders over their members. We're not brainwashed.

Some of us lean right, some of us lean left. I happen to be among the latter, as are many of my friends.

by: Jesusistheway

03-11-2010 @ 3:58pm

I voted for Obama. You've just overplayed your card. Talk about rich.

by: steamboathunter

03-15-2010 @ 1:26am

Good.

by: steamboathunter

03-18-2010 @ 1:34pm

O the beauty of the first amendment! And.........

"Think not that I am come to send peace on earth: I came not to send peace, but a sword." Matthew 10:34

by: BuxomBess

03-12-2010 @ 2:49am

Mormons ARE Christians.

by: jocta

03-14-2010 @ 3:39am

-
-
-
-
-------------------------------------------------To: "kansasmennonite";
-
Please accept my apology for comment addressed to you IN ERROR?
-
I 'tapped' the wrong 'REPLY' BOX! SORRY!
-
-
-

by: steamboathunter

04-03-2010 @ 3:35pm

Dear Blue,

Of course gifts are misused, and that's sad. But don't employ that as a shell to hide in. If you are a prophet, give what God gives you and great crowds will hear you----and kill you. The word of prophecy is very powerful and its power is seen by all as real; but the cost of speaking God's word is high. Elijah was on Jezebel's most-wanted list; Jeremiah was thrown in a deep muddy hole and left to die; tradition reports Isaiah was put in a hollow log and cut in two; John the Baptist lost his head; and so on. Also, there is very little proof the prophets went around announcing their gift. Their lives were strong enough to garner opposition without any advertising.

by: rshin11

03-11-2010 @ 3:53pm

The aspect of Social Justice that Beck is talking about is one that was not only prevelant in Nazi Germany or Communist Russia but also one that is emerging here. It's simply the social justice that says the reason you dont have what you need is because of those people over there. Whether it is Jews, or the elite class, or maybe insurance companies and wall street bankers, it all comes from the same cloth. The thing with this type of social justice movement is that it ultimately orients people against each other and it is just another form of the same thing that they think they are striving against, which is one group of people even if its a minority or oppressed people trying to subjecate another whether by law, coercion or violence. Hitler, Stalin said very similar things that many of our Soical Justice advocates are saying now. The Jews are the reason you are poor, the workers must rise up to overthrow the elite bourgeoisie who are in control. That kind of speech whether you agree with it or not is the same as "Blame the insurance companies!" It really is. The biblical view of justice that is about defending the widows and fatherless, and pouring ourselves out on behalf of the poor and suffering is not about governmental redistributive policy. It is not about class warfare and myself as a person who strongly believes in justice ministries are saddened when well meaning people believe that this is what soical justice is about. These redistributive ideas of justice do nothing to help anybody, just look at the statistics about how peoples lives improve when they are on welfare, the sad images of people who where unable to leave their homes during Katrina because they kept waiting for a government bus instead of feeling empowered as a community to organize and rescue themselves. The sad thing about this article and Mr. Wallis in general is that he is moving from a Christ centered philosphy to becoming more and more driven by his political allegiance. The hypocrisy is what really scares me he blatantly is now pushing people to stop watching Glenn and tries to mask it as a moral imperitive by making some vauge comparison to Howard Stern at the same time he supports and advises a man in President Obama who was the most pro abortion senator in the US. As much as ignoring the poor is of biblical consequence so is the murder of children which God has knit in the womb. IF he is going as far to say that CHristians should write to Mr. Beck and declare ourselves Social Justice Christians, than he should at least call us to write to Mr. Obama and declare ourselves Sanctity of Life Christians as well.

by: kansasmennonite

03-13-2010 @ 4:27am

I'm not for bailouts for the ricH!

by: ximmeron

03-15-2010 @ 1:26am

My bible does. Don't know about yours :)

by: jocta

03-14-2010 @ 3:28am

-
-
I remind you that it was 'you' who commenced insulting 'me'!
-
And, as you imply; you had no idea what "worldview" I "was coming from".
-
Of course most 'rational' people do not need to know another's
"worldview" to comprend their 'written words'.
-
Also, 'I' 'now' better understand your persistant 'pettiness' which is to be expected of those who have lost part of their minds to a charlatan "Confessor" at an early age?
Or, am I mistaken in assuming that which your criticism and
other words imply?
-
Apparently your question about "clarification" was 'actually' meant to 'pry' from me whether or not I was a "Christian"?
As if my 'words' would make more sense to you by knowing 'this'?
Perhaps you believe only 'mind-controlled' "Christians" are capable of making reasonable statements?
-
When stating facts about a "worldview" known by 'rational' people to be 'irrational'; intelligent people are not offended, nor do they deem this an "insult"!
-
My first 'comment' was intended to alert ALL sensible people to the incredibly unjust intention of those people who wish to compel the poorest, most 'downtrodden' helpless people among us to have more children then they are properly capaple of caring for.
-
If, as 'they' 'claim', 'those people' wanted to 'Prevent' "Abortion", there is a 'humane' method of doing so via usage of proper medication. Which 'they' could easily provide.
But, their 'true' purpose is to 'increase' population, at any cost, their opposition to abortion, is just one more way of guaranteeing this.
And, because, no concern at all is shown for the well being of downtrodden destitute people in the 'ghetto' , I am sure 'those'
who go there to compel unwanted births are "religious-fanatical' saddists!
-
Everyone should know about this!
-
And act to end it!
-
-

by: steamboathunter

03-13-2010 @ 4:24am

Do visit the Arabia exhibit. It is a wonderful museum, all paid for by the Hawley family and two partners. They charge (horror) admission, but we are free in this country to line their pockets or not.

by: Lokomski

03-15-2010 @ 1:22am

Sure I may clarify this. Social Justice: Take from me and give to he with less. Don't force me. I will do so on my own. If another chooses to not help the poor that is his business; he still does not warrant my disdain (or perhaps even my attention at all). He does not need me telling him to give to the poor; that wastes his time and mine. ..And churches..not only huge ones..are so inward-looking they would turn away in disgust at the very person to whom Jesus would minister (I am sure there are exceptions; may your church be so). I've seen it. Heck, I've tested it. You should see me..I look like an old hippy. You should see the general look on the faces of a religious mass when I walk into their hall. Their first impression immediately noticable is I do not belong there. Perhaps they appear so out of disgust. Perhaps because I already feel myself I do not belong and they sense that, though I doubt the latter. I know from experience we each live with 7 billion other people on the planet and still, somehow, do not think of anyone but ourselves. That may need clarification. I have an example: While in nursing school on rotation through the surgery unit I was in the locker room changing into my scrubs. A veteran nurse was talking to me and he wondered why the scrubs were made reversible. "It's not like I'm going to get blood on my scrubs and turn it inside out with the blood against my skin just to show a clean uniform", he says. I told him the scrubs weren't made reversible for him. They are reversible for the laundry personal that have to fold them. It just didn't dawn on him. His thought was first about himself. Everyone's thoughts are first about themselves (again I am sure there are exceptions).
Help the poor if you wish. Don't tell your people they have to. Ministering must be difficult. You are expected to preach something all of the time; that's what people come to church to hear. You must struggle to find new things to say. Social justice. Justice. The very term suggests something unjustified to start. There is. However, there is no one man with right enough to enact laws or decrees to force equality. We must each choose to help another or let him fall. That is why a good God let's bad things happen. We must have free choice. God does not inerfere and suffers himself knowing we do not help each other and at times even hurt each other. Follow the example. Do not interfere. Just worship as you will.
Heh, himself, I call God. Him. Of all the religions the Tibetan monks have come the closest to knowing what God really is. Say, that may make an interesting surmon one day; telling your mass what God is. Maybe I should explain. I'll have to think about that. All organized religions may not be ready yet to know.
----- Original Message -----
From: Disqus<mailto:>
To: lokomski@msn.com<mailto:lokomski@msn.com>
Sent: Sunday, March 14, 2010 11:22 AM
Subject: [godspolitics] Re: Glenn Beck: I'm a Social Justice Christian

squeaky wrote, in response to Lokomski:

So, I was really confused by your comment to Pastor Jeff. What was Pastor Jeff responding to, I thought. So I waded through to find your comment.

Now I'm even more confused. In your comment to Pastor Jeff, you seem to be saying that organized religion SHOULD be caring for the poor, but that those huge churches are so inward-looking that they would turn away in disgust at the very person Jesus would minister to.

So I'm not sure how that invective meshes with your earlier post:

"Rev. Jim Wallis is a social justice christian? Social justice IS code for communism...The day we all live by the commandments we will need no other laws at all; thus no requirement for social justice. For now, however, we still hate our fellow man and keep our neighbor's children starving...Mr. Beck, Rev. Wallis says, attacks the very heart of his church with the comments related to churches preaching social justice. If that is the heart of Rev. Wallis' church I would want a different membership myself..perhaps a church with love at it's heart. "

So, wait...in one comment you attack churches for NOT being concerned about social justice, and in your earlier comment, you attack the very churches that ARE concerned about social justice.

Could you clarify this, please?

Link to comment: http://blog.sojo.net/2010/03/10/glenn-beck-im-a...>

-----
Options: Respond in the body to post a reply comment.

To turn off notifications, go to: http://disqus.com/account/notifications/<http:/...>

by: letjusticerolldown

03-10-2010 @ 10:59pm

I thinkest that Sojo contributors are a bit overly focussed on Glenn Beck--and don't bother reading (let alone talking with ) each other.

by: jocta

03-14-2010 @ 3:25am

-
-
I remind you that it was 'you' who commenced insulting 'me'!
-
And, as you imply; you had no idea what "worldview" I "was coming from".
-
Of course most 'rational' people do not need to know another's
"worldview" to comprend their 'written words'.
-
Also, 'I' 'now' better understand your persistant 'pettiness' which is to be expected of those who have lost part of their minds to a charlatan "Confessor" at an early age?
Or, am I mistaken in assuming that which your criticism and
other words imply?
-
Apparently your question about "clarification" was 'actually' meant to 'pry' from me whether or not I was a "Christian"?
As if my 'words' would make more sense to you by knowing 'this'?
Perhaps you believe only 'mind-controlled' "Christians" are capable of making reasonable statements?
-
When stating facts about a "worldview" known by 'rational' people to be 'irrational'; intelligent people are not offended, nor do they deem this an "insult"!
-
My first 'comment' was intended to alert ALL sensible people to the incredibly unjust intention of those people who wish to compel the poorest, most 'downtrodden' helpless people among us to have more children then they are properly capaple of caring for.
-
If, as 'they' 'claim', 'those people' wanted to 'Prevent' "Abortion", there is a 'humane' method of doing so via usage of proper medication. Which 'they' could easily provide.
But, their 'true' purpose is to 'increase' population, at any cost, their opposition to abortion, is just one more way of guaranteeing this.
And, because, no concern at all is shown for the well being of downtrodden destitute people in the 'ghetto' , I am sure 'those'
who go there to compel unwanted births are "religious-fanatical' saddists!
-
Everyone should know about this!
-
And act to end it!
-
-

by: steamboathunter

03-13-2010 @ 4:19am

What is higher taxation for the wealthy?

by: tomerickson

03-15-2010 @ 1:07am

Squeaky,
What is my job? And where do I work? Do you think that your position as a professor allows you to disrespect those that you deem uninformed. I'm not offended. I just would like to point out that education and degrees don't seem to keep a person from exhibiting prejudice for those who disagree with them. Many scientists believe in intellegent design. Many discredit evolution. Taking a poll won't solve the problem. Are we going to say 85% of scientists believe in evolution, or 90%, or 95%? What we believe or all the research in the world will not change the Truth of God. We see things very differently. Psalm 14:19

by: kansasmennonite

03-12-2010 @ 3:09am

You forgot to include gay politicians and preachers who use their power to demonize gays and we find out later they are themselves gay. How perverted!

by: kansasmennonite

03-13-2010 @ 4:14am

Tell me-fellow Mennonite. Where do these forcing of redistribution of wealth come from? I mean what sources of media have been spoon feeding this to you?

I might take my family up to KC this next weekend to check out the steamboat arabia exhibit.

by: PASTOR JEFF

03-15-2010 @ 1:07am

Now we're reading Scripture for what we want to see in it. I see where you are coming from now. Thanks

by: AliciaJeanne

03-12-2010 @ 3:03am

Wow, that was a cheap shot, and really low for Sojourners standards. I'm not impressed at all at how Jim Wallis reacted to Glenn's words in this piece. He comes off as self-righteous, bitter, childish and belittling. I hope that his aim wasn't to publicly defame Beck before approaching him in person about his feelings (just like Jesus exhorts us not to do in the Gospels). I didn't feel that Wallis truly approached Beck in a Christ-like way. This is the first article I am ashamed to read from Sojourners.

by: steamboathunter

03-13-2010 @ 4:11am

Dear Kansas Mennonite, adoption is only one of the "social graces." My point is that the government should not mandate what I do for the poor---like forcing the redistribution of wealth. Should we give? Sure! Probably even tithe. That's the Mennonite way---and I agree; but that dictum was mandated by God and not congress.

Comments sorted by highest rated. After voting you must refresh your page to see the sort order change.

by: jesse3

03-10-2010 @ 7:22pm

"Christians should no longer watch his show."
--I don't think I've ever read Wallis or any left-leaning person claim that Christians should or shouldn't watch certain programs on tv, which is why I find it so odd to turn up right here. Sound pretty fundamentalist, actually. Wallis has obviously watched Beck and other Fox contributors before. Why does he get to watch them, but I don't?

"Of course, Christians may disagree about what social justice means in our current political context - and that conversation is an important one - but the Bible is clear: from the Mosaic law of Jubilee, to the Hebrew prophets, to Jesus Christ, social justice is an integral part of God's plan for humanity."
--Well, maybe Beck was talking about social justice "in our current political context"?

I find Beck extremely annoying, but this is pretty ridiculous. I guess it's something to get people involved somehow in something, though.

by: jesse3

03-10-2010 @ 7:22pm

"Christians should no longer watch his show."
--I don't think I've ever read Wallis or any left-leaning person claim that Christians should or shouldn't watch certain programs on tv, which is why I find it so odd to turn up right here. Sound pretty fundamentalist, actually. Wallis has obviously watched Beck and other Fox contributors before. Why does he get to watch them, but I don't?

"Of course, Christians may disagree about what social justice means in our current political context - and that conversation is an important one - but the Bible is clear: from the Mosaic law of Jubilee, to the Hebrew prophets, to Jesus Christ, social justice is an integral part of God's plan for humanity."
--Well, maybe Beck was talking about social justice "in our current political context"?

I find Beck extremely annoying, but this is pretty ridiculous. I guess it's something to get people involved somehow in something, though.

by: Lord_Voldemort

03-10-2010 @ 7:51pm

Three separate articles on a Glenn Beck rant. Meanwhile, the health care bill is going through its most critical stretch run and Sojo has gone a full week without evening mentioning the thing.

Obamacare's doing that well eh?

LV

by: Lord_Voldemort

03-10-2010 @ 7:51pm

Three separate articles on a Glenn Beck rant. Meanwhile, the health care bill is going through its most critical stretch run and Sojo has gone a full week without evening mentioning the thing.

Obamacare's doing that well eh?

LV

by: tomerickson

03-10-2010 @ 8:15pm

History will prove who was correct on this one. I for one am really disturbed about my denomination picking and choosing what parts of the Bible to believe. The ABC news feed a few weeks ago said that Obama had not found a church yet. According to the article his "close friend and spiritual advisor Jim Wallis" stated that it is really difficult for Presidents to choose a church because it ties them to a certain ideology or denomination. Wallis said that Obama is unapologetically Christian (not to be confused with apologetically American). But the evidence is out there in the form of videos and audios of Obama stating that he doesn't believe parts of the Bible to be true. Am I missing something here or are we discussing different christianities and beliefs. I know there is a thing called Chrislam. Look it up. I think that is closer to what I hear from Obama than Biblical Christianity. Dismiss Glenn Beck as a kook if you want. He has brought up some interesting stuff. I am confident that God is in charge and the Truth (that Jesus came to bear witness to) will prevail. Hang on we're in for a real ride.

by: tomerickson

03-10-2010 @ 8:15pm

History will prove who was correct on this one. I for one am really disturbed about my denomination picking and choosing what parts of the Bible to believe. The ABC news feed a few weeks ago said that Obama had not found a church yet. According to the article his "close friend and spiritual advisor Jim Wallis" stated that it is really difficult for Presidents to choose a church because it ties them to a certain ideology or denomination. Wallis said that Obama is unapologetically Christian (not to be confused with apologetically American). But the evidence is out there in the form of videos and audios of Obama stating that he doesn't believe parts of the Bible to be true. Am I missing something here or are we discussing different christianities and beliefs. I know there is a thing called Chrislam. Look it up. I think that is closer to what I hear from Obama than Biblical Christianity. Dismiss Glenn Beck as a kook if you want. He has brought up some interesting stuff. I am confident that God is in charge and the Truth (that Jesus came to bear witness to) will prevail. Hang on we're in for a real ride.

by: BlueDeacon

03-10-2010 @ 8:26pm

But the evidence is out there in the form of videos and audios of Obama stating that he doesn't believe parts of the Bible to be true. Am I missing something here or are we discussing different christianities and beliefs.

You have to consider who made the videos and audios in the first place and if/how they were edited to paint Obama in possible the worst possible light. After all, some folks have tried to make him into a Muslim; others, a Marxist (if you're one you can't be the other).

by: BlueDeacon

03-10-2010 @ 8:26pm

But the evidence is out there in the form of videos and audios of Obama stating that he doesn't believe parts of the Bible to be true. Am I missing something here or are we discussing different christianities and beliefs.

You have to consider who made the videos and audios in the first place and if/how they were edited to paint Obama in possible the worst possible light. After all, some folks have tried to make him into a Muslim; others, a Marxist (if you're one you can't be the other).

by: bmurdock

03-10-2010 @ 8:41pm

OK, this is simple. Why should we email Glenn Beck? If I remember correctly, he has coverted to the Morman faith. Therefore, lets contact the "Elders" in Salt Lake City and ask them why the Morman church, a la Glenn Beck, is against social justice? Do I smell bacon cooking, or is Glenn's tush in the hot grease.

by: bmurdock

03-10-2010 @ 8:41pm

OK, this is simple. Why should we email Glenn Beck? If I remember correctly, he has coverted to the Morman faith. Therefore, lets contact the "Elders" in Salt Lake City and ask them why the Morman church, a la Glenn Beck, is against social justice? Do I smell bacon cooking, or is Glenn's tush in the hot grease.

by: letjusticerolldown

03-10-2010 @ 10:59pm

I thinkest that Sojo contributors are a bit overly focussed on Glenn Beck--and don't bother reading (let alone talking with ) each other.

by: letjusticerolldown

03-10-2010 @ 10:59pm

I thinkest that Sojo contributors are a bit overly focussed on Glenn Beck--and don't bother reading (let alone talking with ) each other.

by: Jesusistheway

03-10-2010 @ 11:41pm

I think Sojo is so focused on conservative extremists in order to make their own liberal positions somehow seem more mainline.
I think it's just another sign of the times and goes along with Jesus saying "the love of most will grow cold"

by: Jesusistheway

03-10-2010 @ 11:41pm

I think Sojo is so focused on conservative extremists in order to make their own liberal positions somehow seem more mainline.
I think it's just another sign of the times and goes along with Jesus saying "the love of most will grow cold"

by: Grace|Truth

03-10-2010 @ 11:57pm

First, Beck is a Mormon, not a Christian.

The key to any productive discussion is defining your terms. My guess is that Beck and the Sojourner's folks have wildly different definitions. Until that is straightened out people will be talking past each other.

I don't watch or listen to Beck (or Limbaugh, or Fox, etc.) so I'm not sure what context he used it in.

Some people actually consider abortion on demand to be part of social justice. But of course, if the right to life isn't a "social justice" issue, what is?

Also, some people view any inequality in outcome as evidence of social injustice. That view isn't biblical.

Some viewed "global warming" as evidence of social injustice but that turned out to be a big fraud.

The biblical version of justice is fair weights and measures, proper punishments regardless of income level, the expectation that those who can work should do so, etc.

by: Grace|Truth

03-10-2010 @ 11:57pm

First, Beck is a Mormon, not a Christian.

The key to any productive discussion is defining your terms. My guess is that Beck and the Sojourner's folks have wildly different definitions. Until that is straightened out people will be talking past each other.

I don't watch or listen to Beck (or Limbaugh, or Fox, etc.) so I'm not sure what context he used it in.

Some people actually consider abortion on demand to be part of social justice. But of course, if the right to life isn't a "social justice" issue, what is?

Also, some people view any inequality in outcome as evidence of social injustice. That view isn't biblical.

Some viewed "global warming" as evidence of social injustice but that turned out to be a big fraud.

The biblical version of justice is fair weights and measures, proper punishments regardless of income level, the expectation that those who can work should do so, etc.

by: pooch

03-11-2010 @ 12:21am

Forget the videos and audios, it's in his own books.

by: pooch

03-11-2010 @ 12:21am

Forget the videos and audios, it's in his own books.

by: kansasmennonite

03-11-2010 @ 12:44am

Because people like you come on here backing the conservative extreme position and trying to tell everone here that basically agrees with sojo that they're just a bunch of liberals that need some conservatism injected into their bloodstream!

by: kansasmennonite

03-11-2010 @ 12:44am

Because people like you come on here backing the conservative extreme position and trying to tell everone here that basically agrees with sojo that they're just a bunch of liberals that need some conservatism injected into their bloodstream!

by: pooch

03-11-2010 @ 12:45am

"I'll be the first to turn myself in...as a Christian who believes in social justice."

Quite an admission since the context of the "Social Justice" to which Mr. Beck was referring was that advanced by the Nazis and The Soviet Union (hardly the "central teachings of Jesus and the Bible"). But I'll give Mr. Wallis the benefit of the doubt that he's simply ignorant of Mr. Beck's complete commentary and couldn't resist the obvious cheap shot.

by: pooch

03-11-2010 @ 12:45am

"I'll be the first to turn myself in...as a Christian who believes in social justice."

Quite an admission since the context of the "Social Justice" to which Mr. Beck was referring was that advanced by the Nazis and The Soviet Union (hardly the "central teachings of Jesus and the Bible"). But I'll give Mr. Wallis the benefit of the doubt that he's simply ignorant of Mr. Beck's complete commentary and couldn't resist the obvious cheap shot.

by: kansasmennonite

03-11-2010 @ 12:45am

But if you go to your own blog it looks like some of it came from the likes of Beck, Limbaugh, etc.

by: kansasmennonite

03-11-2010 @ 12:45am

But if you go to your own blog it looks like some of it came from the likes of Beck, Limbaugh, etc.

by: PASTOR JEFF

03-11-2010 @ 1:16am

a fundamentalist talking about cold love...that's rich.

by: PASTOR JEFF

03-11-2010 @ 1:16am

a fundamentalist talking about cold love...that's rich.

by: PASTOR JEFF

03-11-2010 @ 1:21am

Do tell, what is the Social Justice advanced by the Nazis and Soviet Union referred to by Mr Beck.

by: PASTOR JEFF

03-11-2010 @ 1:21am

Do tell, what is the Social Justice advanced by the Nazis and Soviet Union referred to by Mr Beck.

by: jesse3

03-11-2010 @ 1:21am

"I think Sojo is so focused on conservative extremists in order to make their own liberal positions somehow seem more mainline."

--Nailed it. This is also why they will not mention that Beck is a Mormon in any of the posts that have appeared--nor will they entertain the idea that maybe they're talking about something different when they each speak of 'social justice.'

It is in their best interests for people to perceive Beck as the spokesperson of those crazy Christian conservatives, but they are the Bible-based, true gospel-believing alternative.

My guess is they give each other high fives whenever Beck, Pat Robertson, et al. say something extreme-sounding.

by: jesse3

03-11-2010 @ 1:21am

"I think Sojo is so focused on conservative extremists in order to make their own liberal positions somehow seem more mainline."

--Nailed it. This is also why they will not mention that Beck is a Mormon in any of the posts that have appeared--nor will they entertain the idea that maybe they're talking about something different when they each speak of 'social justice.'

It is in their best interests for people to perceive Beck as the spokesperson of those crazy Christian conservatives, but they are the Bible-based, true gospel-believing alternative.

My guess is they give each other high fives whenever Beck, Pat Robertson, et al. say something extreme-sounding.

by: PASTOR JEFF

03-11-2010 @ 1:30am

How would they have any time to type?

by: PASTOR JEFF

03-11-2010 @ 1:30am

How would they have any time to type?

by: Mennoman

03-11-2010 @ 1:48am

One must wonder why people keep returning to read blog entries that they find ridiculous.

by: Mennoman

03-11-2010 @ 1:48am

One must wonder why people keep returning to read blog entries that they find ridiculous.

by: jesse3

03-11-2010 @ 2:07am

Not reading the blog entries, dude, I'm reading the comments.

by: jesse3

03-11-2010 @ 2:07am

Not reading the blog entries, dude, I'm reading the comments.

by: NMRod

03-11-2010 @ 3:28am

Plenty of articles have pointed out that Glen Beck is a Mormon apostle.

The "War Jesus" folks really DO have more in common with Mormonism's generally very right-wing, militaristic stances than with the Jesus of Bible alone, rather than the Book of Mormon, so Beck's views are very attractive to them. They really ought to have the courage and honesty to go all the way over to Beck's side, converting to the Mormonism of their leader, seeing they agree with his opinions so fundamentally over against those of my Lord Jesus.

by: NMRod

03-11-2010 @ 3:28am

Plenty of articles have pointed out that Glen Beck is a Mormon apostle.

The "War Jesus" folks really DO have more in common with Mormonism's generally very right-wing, militaristic stances than with the Jesus of Bible alone, rather than the Book of Mormon, so Beck's views are very attractive to them. They really ought to have the courage and honesty to go all the way over to Beck's side, converting to the Mormonism of their leader, seeing they agree with his opinions so fundamentally over against those of my Lord Jesus.

by: uberVU - social comments

03-11-2010 @ 3:30am

Social comments and analytics for this post...

This post was mentioned on Twitter by cogrannie: Biblical Social Justice and Glenn Beck - http://blog.sojo.net/2010/03/10/glenn-beck-im-a-social-justice-christian/...

by: raulgarcia

03-11-2010 @ 4:49am

I would like to thank Jim Wallis and friends for calling Glenn Beck to task.

Whether Jim mentioned Beck being a Mormon or not is totally irrelevant to the point of this article.

by: raulgarcia

03-11-2010 @ 4:49am

I would like to thank Jim Wallis and friends for calling Glenn Beck to task.

Whether Jim mentioned Beck being a Mormon or not is totally irrelevant to the point of this article.

by: pcnot4me

03-11-2010 @ 11:12am

"Do I smell bacon cooking, or is Glenn's tush in the hot grease."

Somehow I think he will be just fine.

by: pcnot4me

03-11-2010 @ 11:12am

"Do I smell bacon cooking, or is Glenn's tush in the hot grease."

Somehow I think he will be just fine.

by: pcnot4me

03-11-2010 @ 11:19am

The problem Jim is that you consider justice = liberal policies. And then you try to use scripture passages that deal with justice to defend your point. You either have no understanding of the Scriptures or you just blatantly take them out of context.

The agenda of Sojo is not aligned with God's agenda of redemption. Your god is government.

by: pcnot4me

03-11-2010 @ 11:19am

The problem Jim is that you consider justice = liberal policies. And then you try to use scripture passages that deal with justice to defend your point. You either have no understanding of the Scriptures or you just blatantly take them out of context.

The agenda of Sojo is not aligned with God's agenda of redemption. Your god is government.

by: tomerickson

03-11-2010 @ 11:20am

When I get to Heaven there will be all kinds of people there. There will be Evangelicals, mainline Protestants, Roman Catholics, Mormons, and about every discription of person that one could imagine. Some of my best friends don't belong to any organized church at all. I know that scripture tells us to get hooked up with a local church, but that, like all our favorite causes, doesn't mean much if we haven't been washed in the Blood of Jesus. I, too, was an angry young man seeking and demanding social justice and peace. In college, I marched, organized for social causes, hated those I felt were war mongers, and generally worked for what you would call "social justice". I have personal testimony of many of the people that Beck has talked about in his programs. It was not until I came like Nicodemus to the point where I so sought the truth of what I was missing to achieve eternal life, that I was visit the Author and Creator of my life. You must be born again. If Beck has that relationship with Jesus, he will be there. If any of you, brothers and sisters, don't know Him, please accept today what He did on that cross. It doesn't matter where you are or what youv'e done, He will take you as you are. We live in a fallen world. Our attempts at social justice must come from us individually. We can not legislate morality. Before you force someone to follow a set social code, examine yourself. "Here I am, send me". Our hope is in the return of Jesus to bring the social justice that is so needed in this flawed world. Maranatha!

by: tomerickson

03-11-2010 @ 11:20am

When I get to Heaven there will be all kinds of people there. There will be Evangelicals, mainline Protestants, Roman Catholics, Mormons, and about every discription of person that one could imagine. Some of my best friends don't belong to any organized church at all. I know that scripture tells us to get hooked up with a local church, but that, like all our favorite causes, doesn't mean much if we haven't been washed in the Blood of Jesus. I, too, was an angry young man seeking and demanding social justice and peace. In college, I marched, organized for social causes, hated those I felt were war mongers, and generally worked for what you would call "social justice". I have personal testimony of many of the people that Beck has talked about in his programs. It was not until I came like Nicodemus to the point where I so sought the truth of what I was missing to achieve eternal life, that I was visit the Author and Creator of my life. You must be born again. If Beck has that relationship with Jesus, he will be there. If any of you, brothers and sisters, don't know Him, please accept today what He did on that cross. It doesn't matter where you are or what youv'e done, He will take you as you are. We live in a fallen world. Our attempts at social justice must come from us individually. We can not legislate morality. Before you force someone to follow a set social code, examine yourself. "Here I am, send me". Our hope is in the return of Jesus to bring the social justice that is so needed in this flawed world. Maranatha!

by: fundamentalist

03-11-2010 @ 12:06pm

How about trying to understand what Glenn Beck meant instead of claiming he meant something he never intended? That would seem to be the Christian thing to do. Anyone who uses Beck's statement to claim that Beck wants people to ignore the poor is a liar. Beck had a particular definition of the term "social justice" in mind when he made his statement. That definition is very common and it is closely linked to socialism. That is the "social justice" that Beck objects to and so do I. Beck's definition of "social justice" is the only one I have known for the past 30 years and as Pastor Jeff and other have indicated it is theirs as well. I was surprised to find that people on this blog held a different definition of the term.

Everyone is free to invent any definition for any term, but it's plainly dishonest to know that Beck is using the commonly understood definition of "social justice" while claiming he was using your personal definition of it. If your definition of "social justice" is nothing more than caring for the poor, then great, but understand that is not the defintion that Beck objected to. Beck objects, and I object, to the older, more common definition of "social justice" as the demand for socialism.

by: fundamentalist

03-11-2010 @ 12:06pm

How about trying to understand what Glenn Beck meant instead of claiming he meant something he never intended? That would seem to be the Christian thing to do. Anyone who uses Beck's statement to claim that Beck wants people to ignore the poor is a liar. Beck had a particular definition of the term "social justice" in mind when he made his statement. That definition is very common and it is closely linked to socialism. That is the "social justice" that Beck objects to and so do I. Beck's definition of "social justice" is the only one I have known for the past 30 years and as Pastor Jeff and other have indicated it is theirs as well. I was surprised to find that people on this blog held a different definition of the term.

Everyone is free to invent any definition for any term, but it's plainly dishonest to know that Beck is using the commonly understood definition of "social justice" while claiming he was using your personal definition of it. If your definition of "social justice" is nothing more than caring for the poor, then great, but understand that is not the defintion that Beck objected to. Beck objects, and I object, to the older, more common definition of "social justice" as the demand for socialism.

by: fundamentalist

03-11-2010 @ 12:10pm

PS, Someone asked why people like myself return to this blog when I find much of it annoying. I don't find all of it annoying. Some of it is very refreshing. But I want to know what socialists are really saying. I don't want to battle with straw men in my defense of capitalism. I find that many who oppose capitalism and free markets (or free people) are doing just that, attacking straw men of their own creation instead of real capitalism.