Get E-Mail Updates

Endurance in the Struggle for Health-Care Reform

President Obama has postponed his trip to Guam, Indonesia, and Australia to work for the passage of health-care reform. The president's determination reminds me of wisdom my mother taught me: "The race is not given to the swift, nor victories to the strong, but to she who endures to the end." Her lesson to me was one of endurance.

Related Reading

Take Action on This Issue

Tell the Senate: Don't Cut International Aid

Please join us in telling the Senate: Protect foreign aid programs that help the poor and the needy. 

This wisdom is a conflation of two verses of Bible, Ecclesiastes 9:11 and Matthew 10:22. The verse in Ecclesiastes says: "the race is not given to the swift, nor the battle to the strong, nor bread to the wise, nor riches to the intelligent, nor favor to the skillful, but time and chance happens to them all." This was much too existential for my mother's faith. The teaching of Jesus was more fitting. Matthew 10:22 says: "and you will be hated by all because of my name. But the one who endures to the end will be saved."

Sometimes there is no way out but through. The lesson is to keep on keeping on until the thing is done. Ecclesiastes 7:8 says: "Better is the end of a thing than its beginning; the patient in spirit better than the proud in spirit." Endurance is a virtue. It is the fortitude, the strength of mind and will to persevere through adversity. Endurance is courage.

When the discussion on health-care reform first began over a year ago, I had no idea that passing reform legislation would be so difficult. I thought it indubitable, unquestionable that the health-care system in the United States was antiquated, far behind nearly every other system of health-care in the developed world. It had been a campaign promise of Barack Obama and the Democrats. They won big, thus it was obvious that a majority of people in the nation wanted a change.

And then came summer with raucous town hall meetings, death panel nonsense, talk of President Obama's Waterloo, a push for the public option, Republican obstructionism, Democratic recalcitrance on this or that issue, the passage of two bills, a presidential summit, more disingenuous talking points and the work is not finished as of this writing.

However, the good news is that it is not over until the victory is won. Gospel singer Maurette Brown Clark reminds us in her song: "It Ain't Over" that the impossible is God's chance, God's opportunity to show up and work a miracle. She encourages us to keep fighting, praying, fasting, pressing, progressing, moving, reading, interceding, believing, trusting, trying, travailing, living, giving, going.

No matter the issue, God has the final say. It is our responsibility to continue to do the work to which we have been called. It is our work to struggle for justice. Health-care reform is a justice issue. It is an issue of equitable distribution of the good things of a society. Endurance is a necessary virtue in both matters of public policy and personal righteousness. And as our sister Clark reminds us: "keep fighting until your victory is won."

Dr. Valerie Elverton Dixon is an independent scholar who publishes lectures and essays at JustPeaceTheory.com. She received her Ph.D. in religion and society from Temple University and taught Christian ethics at United Theological Seminary and Andover Newton Theological School.

+Click here to take action on health care

Sojourners relies on the support of readers like you to sustain our message and ministry.

by: SpareChange

03-15-2010 @ 11:49pm

You missed my parrot...or should I say sarcasm.

And as far as the Archbishop's quote, the key word in the first sentance is GIVE. I assume that means GIVE freely. If not, then it is taken which does not mean giving freely. And I would not call him a communist for asking why they have no food...I would call him a communist if his belief system is in a forceful distribution of wealth. Because then you can pretty much throw the "giving" aspect out the window.

by: DRJ

03-15-2010 @ 11:15pm

"When I give food to the poor, they call me a saint. When I ask why the poor have no food, they call me a communist." This quote from Dom Helder Camara, the former Archbishop of Olinda and Recife, Brazil, can be applied to so many discussions on this blog. Whenever someone tries to point out how the essence of Christ's message should be applied to our society or world community, that person is subjected to being labeled a socialist, communist, or that dreadful epithet, a liberal. Let me remind some of the posters here that being able to parrot verses from the Bible and CALLING yourself a Christian does NOT mean you actually practice the faith.

by: Bungarra

03-16-2010 @ 2:59am

Comment above .."I empathize with those who fear and deeply mistrust government, yet I find fear and vehement cynicism incompatible with work for social equality. .."

I am not sure that there is a full comprehension of the consequences that the engendering of fear/distrust of the government has in the US society. It is to increase the rate of murder of strangers by those who feel alienated from the government. See "American Homicide", Randolph Roth, Harvard University Press

Bit like crying "fire" where there is no fire in a full theater, and not withstanding freedom of speech that is probably a criminal/terrorist act.

On the topic of how good US health care is, if you pay the most, you will accumulate a very highly skilled group of doctors, many of whom are expats, so it is not surprising that some with means come for top end health care. Plus English is the norm, and I suspect that a certain degree of anonymity from those in the country of origin is desired. Both government or press. However on a per capita basis and results per dollar spent, the US overall is getting poor value per head when measured by life expectancy, and overall health.

If you care for the poor, have a look at how things are done else where, and then ask 'Is my ideology condemning fellow citizens to an early death" Yes, we are having that sort of debate in Australia as the Federal Government is considering reliving the States of the responsibility of running the public hospital system, as there has been too much cost shifting resulting is bed shortages. One of our rural doctors suggested to the PM that we explore Cuba's system of doctor training to get better returns for our $ and people.

by: Mihs

03-16-2010 @ 12:48am

I empathize with those who fear and deeply mistrust government, yet I find fear and vehement cynicism incompatible with work for social equality.

If we want any social change for the better --like providing health care as human right rather than as a privilege -- we have to engage the most influential social intuitions in our society, including the US government. This means, despite its many imperfections, we must have the courage to trust the government to do the right thing, and to hold our representatives accountable if they falter.

Individuals and small groups can do all the charitable giving they want, and the need will persist. It's like treating a symptom without addressing cause of the disease. To respond to the root of the need (i.e. social structures that support inequity) we need policies that support equity. This health care bill is a relatively modest push towards greater health equity, but a start nonetheless.

Besides, rampant cynicism is against hope, forgiveness, compassion, and collaboration; and is effectively an excuse not to act as Jesus called. How can an unwavering cynic love their enemy and their neighbor as they love themselves?

by: SpareChange

03-15-2010 @ 10:18pm

- Matthew 10:22 says: "and you will be hated by all because of my name. But the one who endures to the end will be saved."

Valerie, can I claim this verse too??? I feel like this applies to me anytime I post something against the current version of health-care being pushed right now...Or do biblical verses only apply to Obama?

And you wonder why he's jokingly referred to as "The Annointed One"

by: NCG8r

03-15-2010 @ 9:09pm

"I thought it indubitable, unquestionable that the health-care system in the United States was antiquated, far behind nearly every other system of health-care in the developed world."

So, then explain to me why the rich of other countries in this world come to the US for healthcare? If our healthcare is so far below EVERY other country why do they come here if they can afford it?

You are just one more Black Liberation socialist!!

by: jesse3

03-15-2010 @ 8:48pm

"It is an issue of equitable distribution of the good things of a society."
--Say what?

Does anyone else believe this?

by: SpareChange

03-15-2010 @ 11:49pm

You missed my parrot...or should I say sarcasm.

And as far as the Archbishop's quote, the key word in the first sentance is GIVE. I assume that means GIVE freely. If not, then it is taken which does not mean giving freely. And I would not call him a communist for asking why they have no food...I would call him a communist if his belief system is in a forceful distribution of wealth. Because then you can pretty much throw the "giving" aspect out the window.

by: DRJ

03-15-2010 @ 11:15pm

"When I give food to the poor, they call me a saint. When I ask why the poor have no food, they call me a communist." This quote from Dom Helder Camara, the former Archbishop of Olinda and Recife, Brazil, can be applied to so many discussions on this blog. Whenever someone tries to point out how the essence of Christ's message should be applied to our society or world community, that person is subjected to being labeled a socialist, communist, or that dreadful epithet, a liberal. Let me remind some of the posters here that being able to parrot verses from the Bible and CALLING yourself a Christian does NOT mean you actually practice the faith.

by: Bungarra

03-16-2010 @ 2:59am

Comment above .."I empathize with those who fear and deeply mistrust government, yet I find fear and vehement cynicism incompatible with work for social equality. .."

I am not sure that there is a full comprehension of the consequences that the engendering of fear/distrust of the government has in the US society. It is to increase the rate of murder of strangers by those who feel alienated from the government. See "American Homicide", Randolph Roth, Harvard University Press

Bit like crying "fire" where there is no fire in a full theater, and not withstanding freedom of speech that is probably a criminal/terrorist act.

On the topic of how good US health care is, if you pay the most, you will accumulate a very highly skilled group of doctors, many of whom are expats, so it is not surprising that some with means come for top end health care. Plus English is the norm, and I suspect that a certain degree of anonymity from those in the country of origin is desired. Both government or press. However on a per capita basis and results per dollar spent, the US overall is getting poor value per head when measured by life expectancy, and overall health.

If you care for the poor, have a look at how things are done else where, and then ask 'Is my ideology condemning fellow citizens to an early death" Yes, we are having that sort of debate in Australia as the Federal Government is considering reliving the States of the responsibility of running the public hospital system, as there has been too much cost shifting resulting is bed shortages. One of our rural doctors suggested to the PM that we explore Cuba's system of doctor training to get better returns for our $ and people.

by: Mihs

03-16-2010 @ 12:48am

I empathize with those who fear and deeply mistrust government, yet I find fear and vehement cynicism incompatible with work for social equality.

If we want any social change for the better --like providing health care as human right rather than as a privilege -- we have to engage the most influential social intuitions in our society, including the US government. This means, despite its many imperfections, we must have the courage to trust the government to do the right thing, and to hold our representatives accountable if they falter.

Individuals and small groups can do all the charitable giving they want, and the need will persist. It's like treating a symptom without addressing cause of the disease. To respond to the root of the need (i.e. social structures that support inequity) we need policies that support equity. This health care bill is a relatively modest push towards greater health equity, but a start nonetheless.

Besides, rampant cynicism is against hope, forgiveness, compassion, and collaboration; and is effectively an excuse not to act as Jesus called. How can an unwavering cynic love their enemy and their neighbor as they love themselves?

by: SpareChange

03-15-2010 @ 10:18pm

- Matthew 10:22 says: "and you will be hated by all because of my name. But the one who endures to the end will be saved."

Valerie, can I claim this verse too??? I feel like this applies to me anytime I post something against the current version of health-care being pushed right now...Or do biblical verses only apply to Obama?

And you wonder why he's jokingly referred to as "The Annointed One"

by: NCG8r

03-15-2010 @ 9:09pm

"I thought it indubitable, unquestionable that the health-care system in the United States was antiquated, far behind nearly every other system of health-care in the developed world."

So, then explain to me why the rich of other countries in this world come to the US for healthcare? If our healthcare is so far below EVERY other country why do they come here if they can afford it?

You are just one more Black Liberation socialist!!

by: jesse3

03-15-2010 @ 8:48pm

"It is an issue of equitable distribution of the good things of a society."
--Say what?

Does anyone else believe this?

Comments sorted by highest rated. After voting you must refresh your page to see the sort order change.

by: jesse3

03-15-2010 @ 8:48pm

"It is an issue of equitable distribution of the good things of a society."
--Say what?

Does anyone else believe this?

by: jesse3

03-15-2010 @ 8:48pm

"It is an issue of equitable distribution of the good things of a society."
--Say what?

Does anyone else believe this?

by: NCG8r

03-15-2010 @ 9:09pm

"I thought it indubitable, unquestionable that the health-care system in the United States was antiquated, far behind nearly every other system of health-care in the developed world."

So, then explain to me why the rich of other countries in this world come to the US for healthcare? If our healthcare is so far below EVERY other country why do they come here if they can afford it?

You are just one more Black Liberation socialist!!

by: NCG8r

03-15-2010 @ 9:09pm

"I thought it indubitable, unquestionable that the health-care system in the United States was antiquated, far behind nearly every other system of health-care in the developed world."

So, then explain to me why the rich of other countries in this world come to the US for healthcare? If our healthcare is so far below EVERY other country why do they come here if they can afford it?

You are just one more Black Liberation socialist!!

by: SpareChange

03-15-2010 @ 10:18pm

- Matthew 10:22 says: "and you will be hated by all because of my name. But the one who endures to the end will be saved."

Valerie, can I claim this verse too??? I feel like this applies to me anytime I post something against the current version of health-care being pushed right now...Or do biblical verses only apply to Obama?

And you wonder why he's jokingly referred to as "The Annointed One"

by: SpareChange

03-15-2010 @ 10:18pm

- Matthew 10:22 says: "and you will be hated by all because of my name. But the one who endures to the end will be saved."

Valerie, can I claim this verse too??? I feel like this applies to me anytime I post something against the current version of health-care being pushed right now...Or do biblical verses only apply to Obama?

And you wonder why he's jokingly referred to as "The Annointed One"

by: DRJ

03-15-2010 @ 11:15pm

"When I give food to the poor, they call me a saint. When I ask why the poor have no food, they call me a communist." This quote from Dom Helder Camara, the former Archbishop of Olinda and Recife, Brazil, can be applied to so many discussions on this blog. Whenever someone tries to point out how the essence of Christ's message should be applied to our society or world community, that person is subjected to being labeled a socialist, communist, or that dreadful epithet, a liberal. Let me remind some of the posters here that being able to parrot verses from the Bible and CALLING yourself a Christian does NOT mean you actually practice the faith.

by: DRJ

03-15-2010 @ 11:15pm

"When I give food to the poor, they call me a saint. When I ask why the poor have no food, they call me a communist." This quote from Dom Helder Camara, the former Archbishop of Olinda and Recife, Brazil, can be applied to so many discussions on this blog. Whenever someone tries to point out how the essence of Christ's message should be applied to our society or world community, that person is subjected to being labeled a socialist, communist, or that dreadful epithet, a liberal. Let me remind some of the posters here that being able to parrot verses from the Bible and CALLING yourself a Christian does NOT mean you actually practice the faith.

by: SpareChange

03-15-2010 @ 11:49pm

You missed my parrot...or should I say sarcasm.

And as far as the Archbishop's quote, the key word in the first sentance is GIVE. I assume that means GIVE freely. If not, then it is taken which does not mean giving freely. And I would not call him a communist for asking why they have no food...I would call him a communist if his belief system is in a forceful distribution of wealth. Because then you can pretty much throw the "giving" aspect out the window.

by: SpareChange

03-15-2010 @ 11:49pm

You missed my parrot...or should I say sarcasm.

And as far as the Archbishop's quote, the key word in the first sentance is GIVE. I assume that means GIVE freely. If not, then it is taken which does not mean giving freely. And I would not call him a communist for asking why they have no food...I would call him a communist if his belief system is in a forceful distribution of wealth. Because then you can pretty much throw the "giving" aspect out the window.

by: Mihs

03-16-2010 @ 12:48am

I empathize with those who fear and deeply mistrust government, yet I find fear and vehement cynicism incompatible with work for social equality.

If we want any social change for the better --like providing health care as human right rather than as a privilege -- we have to engage the most influential social intuitions in our society, including the US government. This means, despite its many imperfections, we must have the courage to trust the government to do the right thing, and to hold our representatives accountable if they falter.

Individuals and small groups can do all the charitable giving they want, and the need will persist. It's like treating a symptom without addressing cause of the disease. To respond to the root of the need (i.e. social structures that support inequity) we need policies that support equity. This health care bill is a relatively modest push towards greater health equity, but a start nonetheless.

Besides, rampant cynicism is against hope, forgiveness, compassion, and collaboration; and is effectively an excuse not to act as Jesus called. How can an unwavering cynic love their enemy and their neighbor as they love themselves?

by: Mihs

03-16-2010 @ 12:48am

I empathize with those who fear and deeply mistrust government, yet I find fear and vehement cynicism incompatible with work for social equality.

If we want any social change for the better --like providing health care as human right rather than as a privilege -- we have to engage the most influential social intuitions in our society, including the US government. This means, despite its many imperfections, we must have the courage to trust the government to do the right thing, and to hold our representatives accountable if they falter.

Individuals and small groups can do all the charitable giving they want, and the need will persist. It's like treating a symptom without addressing cause of the disease. To respond to the root of the need (i.e. social structures that support inequity) we need policies that support equity. This health care bill is a relatively modest push towards greater health equity, but a start nonetheless.

Besides, rampant cynicism is against hope, forgiveness, compassion, and collaboration; and is effectively an excuse not to act as Jesus called. How can an unwavering cynic love their enemy and their neighbor as they love themselves?

by: Bungarra

03-16-2010 @ 2:59am

Comment above .."I empathize with those who fear and deeply mistrust government, yet I find fear and vehement cynicism incompatible with work for social equality. .."

I am not sure that there is a full comprehension of the consequences that the engendering of fear/distrust of the government has in the US society. It is to increase the rate of murder of strangers by those who feel alienated from the government. See "American Homicide", Randolph Roth, Harvard University Press

Bit like crying "fire" where there is no fire in a full theater, and not withstanding freedom of speech that is probably a criminal/terrorist act.

On the topic of how good US health care is, if you pay the most, you will accumulate a very highly skilled group of doctors, many of whom are expats, so it is not surprising that some with means come for top end health care. Plus English is the norm, and I suspect that a certain degree of anonymity from those in the country of origin is desired. Both government or press. However on a per capita basis and results per dollar spent, the US overall is getting poor value per head when measured by life expectancy, and overall health.

If you care for the poor, have a look at how things are done else where, and then ask 'Is my ideology condemning fellow citizens to an early death" Yes, we are having that sort of debate in Australia as the Federal Government is considering reliving the States of the responsibility of running the public hospital system, as there has been too much cost shifting resulting is bed shortages. One of our rural doctors suggested to the PM that we explore Cuba's system of doctor training to get better returns for our $ and people.

by: Bungarra

03-16-2010 @ 2:59am

Comment above .."I empathize with those who fear and deeply mistrust government, yet I find fear and vehement cynicism incompatible with work for social equality. .."

I am not sure that there is a full comprehension of the consequences that the engendering of fear/distrust of the government has in the US society. It is to increase the rate of murder of strangers by those who feel alienated from the government. See "American Homicide", Randolph Roth, Harvard University Press

Bit like crying "fire" where there is no fire in a full theater, and not withstanding freedom of speech that is probably a criminal/terrorist act.

On the topic of how good US health care is, if you pay the most, you will accumulate a very highly skilled group of doctors, many of whom are expats, so it is not surprising that some with means come for top end health care. Plus English is the norm, and I suspect that a certain degree of anonymity from those in the country of origin is desired. Both government or press. However on a per capita basis and results per dollar spent, the US overall is getting poor value per head when measured by life expectancy, and overall health.

If you care for the poor, have a look at how things are done else where, and then ask 'Is my ideology condemning fellow citizens to an early death" Yes, we are having that sort of debate in Australia as the Federal Government is considering reliving the States of the responsibility of running the public hospital system, as there has been too much cost shifting resulting is bed shortages. One of our rural doctors suggested to the PM that we explore Cuba's system of doctor training to get better returns for our $ and people.